d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Entertainment Room > Favorite Songs & Bands > D2jsp's Official Hardcore Thread V5
Prev1134135136137138224Next
Closed New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 12,617
Joined: Jan 26 2010
Gold: 320.52
Warn: 60%
Nov 29 2010 07:44pm
Quote (HookedOnLSD @ 29 Nov 2010 18:40)
as much as i love violent shows, have heart is one of the most respected bands i ever seen/listened too. they are nothing short of a perfect posi hardcore band.


Posicore? Hardcore was built on the violence, the angry, and all the fun that came with it. I mean, do you think black flag would sing about being happy with no beer, no violence, and no sex? Hell, even Henry Rollins was violent.
Member
Posts: 27,711
Joined: May 26 2006
Gold: 454.00
Nov 29 2010 07:46pm
Quote (Anthraxinsoup @ Nov 29 2010 07:44pm)
Posicore? Hardcore was built on the violence, the angry, and all the fun that came with it. I mean, do you think black flag would sing about being happy with no beer, no violence, and no sex? Hell, even Henry Rollins was violent.


do you know anything about the roots of hardcore music?

minor threat. open your eyes one day bro
Member
Posts: 12,617
Joined: Jan 26 2010
Gold: 320.52
Warn: 60%
Nov 29 2010 07:47pm


Doesn't look very positive and upbeat, I love straight edge music even though I will have a couple drinks in my life(I will in the future), but I also love normal hardcore, and I can tell you, neither are about being positive and anti-violence.
Member
Posts: 22,360
Joined: Feb 20 2008
Gold: 600.69
Warn: 100%
Nov 29 2010 07:47pm
Quote (HookedOnLSD @ Nov 29 2010 05:40pm)
as much as i love violent shows, have heart is one of the most respected bands i ever seen/listened too. they are nothing short of a perfect posi hardcore band.


they aren't very respected out here

in fact almost none of the Boston hardcore scene gets any love out here and very few straight edge or "positive" hardcore (whatever the fuck that's supposed to mean) does

I personally hate have heart they are like a pop punk band but as you know I hate 99% of current hardcore so that's not a surprise
Member
Posts: 12,617
Joined: Jan 26 2010
Gold: 320.52
Warn: 60%
Nov 29 2010 07:48pm
Quote (HookedOnLSD @ 29 Nov 2010 18:46)
do you know anything about the roots of hardcore music?

minor threat. open your eyes one day bro


Minor threat had many violent shows. Hardcore is called HARDcore for a reason, not fagcore, or posicore.
Member
Posts: 27,711
Joined: May 26 2006
Gold: 454.00
Nov 29 2010 07:49pm
Quote (Anthraxinsoup @ Nov 29 2010 07:47pm)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1w5aML-dbno

Doesn't look very positive and upbeat, I love straight edge music even though I will have a couple drinks in my life(I will in the future), but I also love normal hardcore, and I can tell you, neither are about being positive and anti-violence.


go look up the lyrics to that song and then tell me its not a positive message song.


have heart is one of the best hardcore bands in my book. now would i prefer something hard as nails with more balls? fuck yeah.
Member
Posts: 12,617
Joined: Jan 26 2010
Gold: 320.52
Warn: 60%
Nov 29 2010 07:50pm
Quote (Monster666 @ 29 Nov 2010 18:47)
they aren't very respected out here

in fact almost none of the Boston hardcore scene gets any love out here and very few straight edge or "positive" hardcore (whatever the fuck that's supposed to mean) does

I personally hate have heart they are like a pop punk band but as you know I hate 99% of current hardcore so that's not a surprise


I like you, I have never heard of this Posicore shit until now, and I know the dropkicks wouldn't either(the dropkicks got a shout out in the back of one of their CDs to my mom and dad!).
Member
Posts: 22,360
Joined: Feb 20 2008
Gold: 600.69
Warn: 100%
Nov 29 2010 07:50pm
Quote (Anthraxinsoup @ Nov 29 2010 05:48pm)
Minor threat had many violent shows. Hardcore is called HARDcore for a reason, not fagcore, or posicore.


hardcore is mainly called hardcore because of D.O.A.
Member
Posts: 1,814
Joined: Jan 14 2007
Gold: 270.00
Nov 29 2010 07:51pm
Someone once spoke to me about Have Heart saying something along the lines of "Have Heart is a band you take your girlfriend to. They're not much as far as hardcore goes, but they're good to see."
Member
Posts: 12,617
Joined: Jan 26 2010
Gold: 320.52
Warn: 60%
Nov 29 2010 07:51pm
Quote (HookedOnLSD @ 29 Nov 2010 18:49)
go look up the lyrics to that song and then tell me its not a positive message song.


have heart is one of the best hardcore bands in my book. now would i prefer something hard as nails with more balls? fuck yeah.


I know the reason behind not doing drugs is positive, But they were about violence too, they had violent shows, they wanted violent shows. Have heart talks about gay shit and doesn't support violence.
Go Back To Favorite Songs & Bands Topic List
Prev1134135136137138224Next
Closed New Topic New Poll