best newly airing anime of the season would be best... you cant really do that for old animes

Agreed, since its anime of the month, you cant have like 10 old animes ie, Trigun 10x times in a row. It should be like maybe 1 year old max maybe something like that? Or maybe newly airing Anime series only, idk, just a suggestion.

Good idea

I'd participate.

The problem with newly airing animes is that they're still in session and will most likely be shown for several months, 1 episode per week. This will turn the event of Anime of the Month to a confusion, as people will be at best looking/downloading several animes at the same time. As for animes that have been recently finished, isn't it the same as older ones?

thats why you do best anime(s) of the season.

It wouldn't be mandotory to watch it, it would just be opitional, if people didn't watch it, then they wouldn't post in the discussion i guess

1 anime per month isn't much :|

Like, I can watch full One Piece in a week, and thats almost 200 episodes now ( I only watch Kaizoku Fansubs, )

we all know one anime isnt much per month but this anime will be differnt from the series we are courently watching also i made a post about which anime to watch once we have 10 suggestion we'll do poll

What if two or more suggest the same anime? Will that be ignored or will be have a poll with less choices?

My guess I would probably be a poll with less choices.