d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Diablo > Diablo 4 > D4 Discussion >
Poll > Diablo 4 Vs Baldur's Gate 3
Prev12345Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
  Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.
Member
Posts: 56,582
Joined: Sep 26 2005
Gold: 14,050.05
Aug 2 2023 10:09am
Quote (jackherer @ Aug 2 2023 12:03pm)
Anyone honest says bg3 better the games a masterpiece.

Its not a good comparison though as a game should be compared to its contemporaries.

Its like comparing fifa to red dead redemption.


So comparing RPG to aRPG is the same as comparing a sports game to an RPG? Last I checked both are still rpgs. What a moronic comparison
Member
Posts: 37,029
Joined: Jun 1 2006
Gold: 59,761.00
Aug 2 2023 10:11am
Quote (VickIsSick07 @ Aug 2 2023 05:09pm)
So comparing RPG to aRPG is the same as comparing a sports game to an RPG? Last I checked both are still rpgs. What a moronic comparison


How is baldurs gate remotely like d4?

They are isometric they both have a story thats where it ends lol.

Maybe provide an actual argument next time bud just end up with egg on your face.

This post was edited by jackherer on Aug 2 2023 10:12am
Member
Posts: 56,582
Joined: Sep 26 2005
Gold: 14,050.05
Aug 2 2023 10:13am
Quote (jackherer @ Aug 2 2023 12:11pm)
How is baldurs gate remotely like d4?

They are isometric they both have a story thats where it ends lol.

Maybe provide an actual argument next time bud just end up with egg on your face.


It's much closer than that stupid hypothetical you presented.
Member
Posts: 37,029
Joined: Jun 1 2006
Gold: 59,761.00
Aug 2 2023 10:13am
Quote (VickIsSick07 @ Aug 2 2023 05:13pm)
It's much closer than that stupid hypothetical you presented.


Explain how?

You dont know how to make an argument?
Member
Posts: 11,332
Joined: Mar 23 2017
Gold: 12,692.00
Warn: 10%
Aug 2 2023 10:17am
Quote (jackherer @ Aug 2 2023 06:03pm)
Anyone honest says bg3 better the games a masterpiece.

Its not a good comparison though as a game should be compared to its contemporaries.

Its like comparing fifa to red dead redemption.


im also in the bg3> d4 camp, its just that i feel it will go the esg way and thats not good :cry:

and red dead redemption > fifa for me ^_^
Member
Posts: 56,582
Joined: Sep 26 2005
Gold: 14,050.05
Aug 2 2023 10:18am
Quote (jackherer @ Aug 2 2023 12:13pm)
Explain how?

You dont know how to make an argument?


It doesn't need explaining. Notice how both genres have RPG in them?? You cannot be serious. The only difference between the two is the type of combat and the fact that one game comes to a finite end. You're still building a character, you're still collecting items. Now tell me how your stupid fucking fifa to red dead comparison makes sense.
Member
Posts: 37,029
Joined: Jun 1 2006
Gold: 59,761.00
Aug 2 2023 10:19am
Quote (Snyft2 @ Aug 2 2023 05:17pm)
im also in the bg3> d4 camp, its just that i feel it will go the esg way and thats not good :cry:

and red dead redemption > fifa for me ^_^


Haha can agree with that but fifa and ufc and fight night are the best couch co op games ever
Member
Posts: 2,474
Joined: Aug 10 2013
Gold: 2,420.00
Aug 2 2023 10:21am
Quote (jackherer @ Aug 2 2023 12:03pm)
Anyone honest says bg3 better the games a masterpiece.

Its not a good comparison though as a game should be compared to its contemporaries.

Its like comparing fifa to red dead redemption.


dudes on the jack he knows whats up
Member
Posts: 11,332
Joined: Mar 23 2017
Gold: 12,692.00
Warn: 10%
Aug 2 2023 10:23am
Quote (jackherer @ Aug 2 2023 06:19pm)
Haha can agree with that but fifa and ufc and fight night are the best couch co op games ever


ah true, they are better when friends visit! but well, im horrible at them so not very enjoyable for me :cry:
Member
Posts: 37,029
Joined: Jun 1 2006
Gold: 59,761.00
Aug 2 2023 10:28am
Quote (VickIsSick07 @ Aug 2 2023 05:18pm)
It doesn't need explaining. Notice how both genres have RPG in them?? You cannot be serious. The only difference between the two is the type of combat and the fact that one game comes to a finite end. You're still building a character, you're still collecting items. Now tell me how your stupid fucking fifa to red dead comparison makes sense.


Lol what are you talking about how is a hack and slash with a linear story anything like baldurs gate tactical turn based story driven multiple choice role playing game.

Maybe i exagerated slightly but only to make the point that these games are nothing like each other. Anyone whos played bg3 will confirm this.

This post was edited by jackherer on Aug 2 2023 10:32am
Go Back To D4 Discussion Topic List
Prev12345Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll