Poe Trophy Room - Topic

Member

Posts: 74,728

Joined: Oct 15 2004

Gold: 4,463.00

Jul 14 2015 07:04pm

Quote (Lamperouge @ 14 Jul 2015 20:57)

I'm not sure where I stand on this....

I can appreciate godly items that fellow players make, and it'll be good for the community, but most of the time, I'd just rather not link items on jsp because of reddit scumbag witch hunts / Ban hammers.

"you can link / use jsp forum" Yeah, but it doesn't take a genius to look through our jsp history and see a wtb / wts forum post.

If this were a thing, I suggest no Mirrored items, Orginals are fine, but its very very risky and have it NEVER be up on poe.trade etc.

but if you have somewhat of a public appearance in PoE, Posting ANY of your times / builds is basically Suicide.

Personally, I wouldn't use it... and in many ways it could be used against us.

This

I don't want you to die :cry:

lxpandaxl

Member

Posts: 6,036

Joined: Nov 15 2012

Gold: 130.00

#42

Jul 14 2015 07:37pm

I think sharing a thread of Poe site wouldn't be too bad.

No one will know who posted what item and we can all admire the JSP community-made items.
I like trophy rooms

I would love it if you all died :3
I'd eat chu all up~

This post was edited by lxpandaxl on Jul 14 2015 07:38pm

Metagel

Member

Posts: 1,539

Joined: Mar 2 2010

Gold: 21,575.00

#43

Jul 14 2015 08:03pm

It's pretty easy to find good items on the forum if you want to see them. A thread dedicated to bragging about items that are likely not even that great seems like a bad idea.

IsolationYears

Member

Posts: 3,398

Joined: Oct 30 2012

Gold: 680.00

#44

Jul 14 2015 08:06pm

i want to see cool items ill never have in hardcore

GlowSticks

Member

Posts: 41,011

Joined: Mar 18 2006

Gold: 11,500.00

#45

Jul 14 2015 08:51pm

I was thinking about this today...

"Why does this game not have a trophy room?"
Maybe because "D2"Jsp, and frown on such a thing. Rofl.

TheGreatJohnJohn

Member

Posts: 8,579

Joined: Apr 27 2008

Gold: 75,596.23

#46

Jul 14 2015 10:06pm

Now that they got rid of eternals I think this would be very interesting.

Quote (Morbid. @ Jul 14 2015 11:55am)

I would be up for it but I personally wouldn't do it out of safety for my account. It still would be cool to see.

To get around that we could have a single person post all screenshots for the trophy room. Or you could just say it was linked in global/trade.

This post was edited by TheGreatJohnJohn on Jul 14 2015 10:27pm

Poorjoys

Member

Posts: 8,445

Joined: Dec 31 2014

Gold: Locked

#47

Jul 14 2015 11:18pm

Yes, only on new leagues though

Standard already has mirrored stuff that is nothing new

On new leagues, there are no eternal orbs = every item that is unique will remain unique

I vote for yes but only for league items, items that are mirrored/standard/hardcore items should be banned, just like 08 items etc on diablo 2 trophy room

on the bad site, and which makes this kinda a bad idea too, rare items that are posted are tracked easily by GGG members and risk of getting accounts banned is to high

This post was edited by Poorjoys on Jul 14 2015 11:21pm

sir_lance_bb

Member

Posts: 37,613

Joined: May 3 2007

Gold: 119,903.34

#48

Jul 15 2015 12:13am

historically poe trophy forums have 20% relevant posting and 60% people trying to downplay what people post and then 10% posting absolute dog shit cause they are new or bad at the game and don't know what a good item is and the other 10% +1ing.

If you are able to accept that what the thread will be, then make it. But don't expect much.

I voted yes as I like looking at good items. And agree with Poorjoys that it should be mainly attached to temp leagues because there's just so much mirror'd stuff out there but let people post what they want. It's too hard to draw the line.

This post was edited by sir_lance_bb on Jul 15 2015 12:15am

Dot_Com

Member

Posts: 16,572

Joined: Dec 11 2005

Gold: 9.04

#49

Jul 15 2015 01:41am

I voted no

Reasons being, the d2 Trophy room, is a joke, its full of people +1 and trash talking every post made.
I dont think jsp can have a good Trophy room, to many haters on here.

After that being said, i wish we could have something like this, but i really dont think it be a good idea

cowding

Member

Posts: 22,735

Joined: Apr 30 2011

Gold: 122.92

#50

Jul 15 2015 03:57am

Yes but only for leagues
No care about mirror crafter/ itemshop items took 5k$$ to craft

Go Back To Path of Exile Topic List