I could support that, but I feel like if Paul got around to implementing that (which I don't know how likely and feasible that would be) it could just end up being similar to a reddit circlejerk.

Not a bad idea at all, but I think it'll need a little bit of work before you could post it in the site suggestions. My biggest complain though is if it's between 5-8ish out of 10 on average, is it really a trophy?

Yea just what we need, reddit vote system here

Mirrored items makes a trophy room obsolete.
so does eternal orbs

If an item is a real trophy then it's uncommon enough for it to be locatable on XYZ/ingame via chats. I suppose it's all optional though.

Definitely need a strict no uniques policy. Banning Jewels and non rare items entirely would probably be good.

But...the real problem is that what is an insane trophy in a temp league is dirt compared to mirrored stuff.

This post was edited by RaveTheGo on Jul 14 2015 12:33pm

Eternal orbs no longer drop, and eventually will be no more.
Mirrored items are a mirrored version of what most (Correct me if I am wrong) were created from an item that would be a model of what a trophy would be.

Do not get 100% caught up in mirrored items, etc.




Could rare jewels not potentially be trophies?

This post was edited by bodierox on Jul 14 2015 12:33pm

If i find/craft some item with 4 new T1 mods would it be considered as trophy?

rare jewels are definately trophy material given the right stats

theres a thread now with some nice stuff in it

im sure burns would appreciate it

1. - Would this forum be used? Yes

2. - Would the forum be used correctly No

3. - What are the upsides/downsides you see? Trophy worthy items will be mirrored and the forums will just be mirrored versions so not worth imo

Anything not mirrored but mirror worthy will just be a giant witch hunt for the person who owns it

Good idea, yes but won't cannot be properly implemented on a site like this since witch hunt = people getting banned

Based on the beta, the amount of investment to get a 100% perfect jewel for a specific build is minimal. This is because not only do Jewels only have one tier of affixes, as opposed to 6+ for other items, but they only have 4 mods, as opposed to 6. Also, that one tier is like a 1-3% variance, as opposed to ranges of 20+ in other items.

I crafted a lot of Jewels in the beta and I had multiple jewels with max % life and three damage mods within 1-2% of max, just from 2 weeks of play between wipes. I also saw a lot more good ones out there.

This post was edited by RaveTheGo on Jul 14 2015 12:40pm

Maybe if it was moderated by someone who has a vast knowledge about the game, plays actively and isn't afraid to enforce the rules.

There could be rules that only allow rare non mirrored items or whatever people think is the best way.
Legacy items could have their own thread or whatever.

I don't see why it wouldn't work with correct amount tweaking.