d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Culinary Arts > Presentation > Important Or Not
123Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 21,264
Joined: May 18 2005
Gold: 0.00
Nov 19 2013 09:15pm
What are your thoughts about the importance of presentation?

Does it matter to you at all, only in certain settings (cooking for others, for a special events) or at all times?
Member
Posts: 24,802
Joined: Mar 7 2010
Gold: 22,202.22
Nov 20 2013 12:04am
presentation is very important. if you just slop some food on a plate its not very appetizing. how you perceive the food affects how it will taste to you. now, just how far you take presentation can vary, but it definitely shouldnt be just slopped down on the plate.
Member
Posts: 12,755
Joined: Jan 29 2011
Gold: 7,395.00
Nov 20 2013 03:38am
Nope, I don't do anything more than clean drips off the edge of the plate, regardless of whether I cook just for myself or guests. I think my food looks fine looking exactly like what it is: food.

If you cook professionally and have to justify your wages and the restaurant's prices, then you can be as pretentious as you want to be, of course.
Member
Posts: 10,780
Joined: Jul 22 2011
Gold: 655.00
Nov 20 2013 04:19am
it could be said that a meal is 80% experience and 20% food.

when you are planning a meal that you hope people will remember for years to come, presentiation can really make or break that.
Member
Posts: 2,595
Joined: Feb 7 2007
Gold: Locked
Trader: Scammer
Warn: 30%
Nov 20 2013 01:02pm
Quote (Ylem122 @ Nov 20 2013 06:19am)
it could be said that a meal is 80% experience and 20% food.

when you are planning a meal that you hope people will remember for years to come, presentiation can really make or break that.


It could also be said the other way around :P

IMO food quality is way more important than presentation. As long as it doesn't look aweful, i'm happy. Although some of my favorite foods look just terrible.
Member
Posts: 24,802
Joined: Mar 7 2010
Gold: 22,202.22
Nov 20 2013 03:01pm
Quote (amahumahaba @ Nov 20 2013 02:02pm)
It could also be said the other way around  :P

IMO food quality is way more important than presentation. As long as it doesn't look aweful, i'm happy. Although some of my favorite foods look just terrible.


nice looking crap will still taste like crap.

but you could take the same good quality food, and on one plate just plop it down haphazardly and on another arrange it nicely, and not only will people prefer to eat the one that tastes nice, if they tasted both, they would probably perceive it as tasting better than the other, even though they are actually exactly the same. its similar to feeding kids and getting them to try new things. if you tell them 'here, have some of these yucky vegetables', theyre not as likely to like it, if they are even willing to try it at all. give them the same vegetables and tell them 'mmm, yummy, here try some of this' and not only are they more likely to try it, theyre more likely to like it.

like i said previously, though, how far you take presentation depends on your purpose in eating. if youre just eating for sustenance, just the basics like wiping the plate and not throwing things on randomly is enough. if you really want to wow your senses, then its going to take more than just that.
Member
Posts: 12,755
Joined: Jan 29 2011
Gold: 7,395.00
Nov 20 2013 08:14pm
Quote (Ylem122 @ Nov 20 2013 03:19am)
it could be said that a meal is 80% experience and 20% food.


That pretty much sums up much of the american "cuisine", aka 'food is an afterthought.' It's working out splendidly...

Quote (Ylem122 @ Nov 20 2013 03:19am)
when you are planning a meal that you hope people will remember for years to come, presentiation can really make or break that.


I don't know how many meals you have cooked in your life, but I've cooked quite a few and 'experience' or 'memorability' have never even entered my mind. Taste, nutrition and frugality are the values that I learned to cook by, but I learned cooking from my mother, who learned cooking from my grandmother, who learned cooking from my great-grandmother, and so on.

I've been very fortunate to have had delicious, nutritious, home cooked food to eat virtually every day of my life but you know what? I don't remember any particular meal, why would I?

Well, except maybe that one time when my uncle got fed up with the neighbor's pigeons eating all the chicken feed in my great-aunt's backyard, so he set up some cages... The following Sunday, the extended family got together at my grandma's for roasted pigeons... Yeah, that was truly memorable. I was just a little kid then and I still remember that, but you just can't manufacture that kind of experience...

This post was edited by aliquis on Nov 20 2013 08:40pm
Member
Posts: 10,780
Joined: Jul 22 2011
Gold: 655.00
Nov 20 2013 11:57pm
Quote (aliquis @ Nov 20 2013 10:14pm)
That pretty much sums up much of the american "cuisine", aka 'food is an afterthought.' It's working out splendidly...


experience, not presentation

Quote (amahumahaba @ Nov 20 2013 03:02pm)
It could also be said the other way around :P

IMO food quality is way more important than presentation. As long as it doesn't look aweful, i'm happy. Although some of my favorite foods look just terrible.


experience, not presentation


presentation is a part of ones experience, but so is whether or not the person liked what they ate.
Member
Posts: 24,802
Joined: Mar 7 2010
Gold: 22,202.22
Nov 21 2013 09:21am
Quote (Ylem122 @ Nov 21 2013 12:57am)
experience, not presentation



experience, not presentation


presentation is a part of ones experience, but so is whether or not the person liked what they ate.


when you differentiate between 'experience' and 'food', that takes food part out of the experience. otherwise whats the difference? it should just be 100% experience then.
Member
Posts: 15,514
Joined: Nov 28 2008
Gold: 8,754.00
Nov 21 2013 10:56am
Quote (ReturnFormer @ Nov 20 2013 02:01pm)
nice looking crap will still taste like crap. 

but you could take the same good quality food, and on one plate just plop it down haphazardly and on another arrange it nicely, and not only will people prefer to eat the one that tastes nice, if they tasted both, they would probably perceive it as tasting better than the other, even though they are actually exactly the same.  its similar to feeding kids and getting them to try new things.  if you tell them 'here, have some of these yucky vegetables', theyre not as likely to like it, if they are even willing to try it at all.  give them the same vegetables and tell them 'mmm, yummy, here try some of this' and not only are they more likely to try it, theyre more likely to like it.

like i said previously, though, how far you take presentation depends on your purpose in eating.  if youre just eating for sustenance, just the basics like wiping the plate and not throwing things on randomly is enough.  if you really want to wow your senses, then its going to take more than just that.


Agreed, alot of times people eat with there eyes
Go Back To Culinary Arts Topic List
123Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll