d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Culinary Arts > Americans And Cups...
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 32,004
Joined: Jun 24 2010
Gold: 81.17
Jul 30 2011 11:24am
I've just had to convert everything into grams for a recipe. Not only is a cup different for each ingredient, for example, 1 Cup of Flour is equal to 128g and 1 Cup of Sugar is equal to 201g. But there's also conflicting conversions!? Another site tells me 1 Cup of Flour is equal to 110g!

What's the deal? Why not just have a universal weight and weigh every thing in grams for example! What if you need 1 and 5/6 Cups!?

God damn it's complicated!
Member
Posts: 13,403
Joined: Dec 25 2010
Gold: 0.00
Jul 30 2011 11:41am
Cup = volume, not weight
Member
Posts: 33,156
Joined: Apr 8 2006
Gold: 737.50
Jul 30 2011 11:46am
It really isn't complicated if you are familiar with it, 1 cup is not a measurement of weight so converting it into weight is going to be a little different, depending on the density of the ingredient. First off, if we consider that the difference in a few grams of flour or sugar really ISN'T going to impact the dish greatly, we have a better idea of the flexibility we have. If you think about it in terms of what it is, and not what it translates into, it makes a lot more sense. A cup of sugar may weigh 201 grams, but it also takes up a certain amount of space. Volume is Mass / Density.

I imagine if I were trying to measure 2 pounds of ground beef in milliliters, I'd be a little frustrated too.
Member
Posts: 32,004
Joined: Jun 24 2010
Gold: 81.17
Jul 31 2011 02:20am
Quote (MNhockey @ Jul 30 2011 06:41pm)
Cup = volume, not weight


Well I never! :o

Quote (hedonism @ Jul 30 2011 06:46pm)
It really isn't complicated if you are familiar with it, 1 cup is not a measurement of weight so converting it into weight is going to be a little different, depending on the density of the ingredient. First off, if we consider that the difference in a few grams of flour or sugar really ISN'T going to impact the dish greatly, we have a better idea of the flexibility we have. If you think about it in terms of what it is, and not what it translates into, it makes a lot more sense. A cup of sugar may weigh 201 grams, but it also takes up a certain amount of space. Volume is Mass / Density.

I imagine if I were trying to measure 2 pounds of ground beef in milliliters, I'd be a little frustrated too.


I think that could be the problem. I'm just not used to it! I take it you have standard sized cups in the US? So much easier to just use scales and weigh everything in grams in my opinion :P
Member
Posts: 6,858
Joined: Apr 16 2010
Gold: 0.20
Jul 31 2011 09:38am
Quote (MNhockey @ Jul 30 2011 01:41pm)
Cup = volume, not weight


ya
Member
Posts: 17,073
Joined: Oct 1 2005
Gold: 140.00
Jul 31 2011 11:07pm
Quote (JoeNTMY @ Jul 31 2011 04:20am)
Well I never! :o



I think that could be the problem. I'm just not used to it! I take it you have standard sized cups in the US? So much easier to just use scales and weigh everything in grams in my opinion :P


what takes me a few seconds to toss in a cup and see its right, is the same to get out the scale and weigh everything?

bottom line, time = money. it may not be perfect, but its fast.
Member
Posts: 32,004
Joined: Jun 24 2010
Gold: 81.17
Aug 1 2011 01:26pm
Quote (FloraFreak @ Aug 1 2011 06:07am)
what takes me a few seconds to toss in a cup and see its right, is the same to get out the scale and weigh everything?

bottom line, time = money. it may not be perfect, but its fast.


I take it there are standard cup sizes in America? Butter most be a problem to measure it's volume as a solid, no?
Member
Posts: 33,156
Joined: Apr 8 2006
Gold: 737.50
Aug 1 2011 01:32pm
Quote (JoeNTMY @ Aug 1 2011 03:26pm)
I take it there are standard cup sizes in America? Butter most be a problem to measure it's volume as a solid, no?


Most sticks of butter, commercial and restaurant size, come with lines measuring out each tablespoon (each stick is 8 tablespoons). One cup is 16 tablespoons, although most recipes will list butter measurements in tablespoons.
Member
Posts: 17,073
Joined: Oct 1 2005
Gold: 140.00
Aug 1 2011 01:47pm
Quote (JoeNTMY @ Aug 1 2011 03:26pm)
I take it there are standard cup sizes in America? Butter most be a problem to measure it's volume as a solid, no?


Not really, it's measured into lbs, which makes two perfect cup measurements. So if I need a cup, just cut in half. A half cup, cut off a forth. Obviously some things require a more presses measurement, but for the most part I can go without a scale.

A cup here is 8 ounces, or 226 grams if you like

This post was edited by FloraFreak on Aug 1 2011 01:50pm
Go Back To Culinary Arts Topic List
Add Reply New Topic New Poll