d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Culinary Arts > Need A New Knife Or > A Whetstone
Prev1234
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 24,802
Joined: Mar 7 2010
Gold: 22,202.22
Apr 3 2013 11:42am
Quote (HeavonHand @ Apr 3 2013 12:17am)
I didn't read the three pages, but as a Chef, I feel entitled to answer the question.

Don't waste your money on anything that you haven't held in your hand.  All (quality) knives will take care of you just as well as you take care of them.  You should make your decision based upon how the knife feels in your hand, i.e. how heavy the blade is, how comfortable you are with the length, and lastly - the aesthetic qualities that might encourage you to regularly use it.

I love my knife, and I could never replace it.  I steel it regularly, during and after use.  I sharpen it on a wet stone, and I keep the edge as thin as a razor.  Spend a little extra if you have to, but don't settle for something that doesn't feel perfect in your hand.  Only you can know whats right.  Find it, and take care of it.


the only problem with that is that most shops ive been to dont have 'floor models' for you to hold before you buy it. kinda hard to tell the feel if its in a plastic package.

otherwise good advice.
Member
Posts: 21,868
Joined: Aug 29 2005
Gold: 10,500.00
Apr 3 2013 06:38pm
Quote (ReturnFormer @ Apr 3 2013 12:42pm)
the only problem with that is that most shops ive been to dont have 'floor models' for you to hold before you buy it.  kinda hard to tell the feel if its in a plastic package. 

otherwise good advice.


you must not be going to proper kitchen supply stores then.

when I just went to buy my new Global knives they would let you try every knife and even provided some veggies to cut.

I know of 2 other stores in my area that do the same.
Member
Posts: 24,802
Joined: Mar 7 2010
Gold: 22,202.22
Apr 3 2013 08:31pm
Quote (Tylenol @ Apr 3 2013 07:38pm)
you must not be going to proper kitchen supply stores then.

when I just went to buy my new Global knives they would let you try every knife and even provided some veggies to cut.

I know of 2 other stores in my area that do the same.


ah, cool. none of the ones around here do...

do they do that for the cheaper knives too or only the higher end ones?
Member
Posts: 2,122
Joined: Jan 17 2010
Gold: 70.00
Apr 4 2013 05:59am
Quote (ReturnFormer @ Apr 3 2013 09:31pm)
ah, cool.  none of the ones around here do... 

do they do that for the cheaper knives too or only the higher end ones?


i went to williams sonoma to take a look and they only mentioned testing the higher end knives they keep in the glass, but they have some cheap ones sitting in bins that i guess they would let you try if you asked.
Member
Posts: 14,932
Joined: Oct 5 2006
Gold: 8,224.05
Apr 4 2013 11:27am
For your budget i would go with victorinox, henckel, MAC or global... although personnaly i don't like using global, i don't like the handle. As for Global being extremely high quality, i don't think that's quite right.. good quality yes, but they are pretty much the lowest end of high end japanese knives (that's if they even qualify for being high end japanese knifes)
Also don't forget that most manufacturer (such as victorinox, henckel,MAC...) offers different quality series, depending on ur budget and needs...

This post was edited by hofx2 on Apr 4 2013 11:31am
Go Back To Culinary Arts Topic List
Prev1234
Add Reply New Topic New Poll