d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Diablo II > Diablo 2 Discussion > Legit Dueling > Nl Melee Lader Discussions And Suggestions > Thnks For The Inputs :)
Prev19899100101102353Next
Add Reply New Topic
Views: 58110Replies: 3529Track Topic
Member
Posts: 22,828
Joined: Jan 27 2009
Gold: 1,490.00
#991
Jun 30 2010 10:46pm
Quote (Meatyy @ Jun 30 2010 11:43pm)
even if it's the person who challenged can't complete it? that doesn't seem fair to the person who got challenged

but then i can challenge someone and say we cant meet up, it gets neer the end of deadline so i jus wait till it's over and I win?


I dont think you understand the scenario he says the Challenger was trying to make it happen and the challengee couldn't do it. Your thinking of another scenario, which does make sense. I agree its a little BM to challenge someone and not be able to do it.
Member
Posts: 20,138
Joined: Oct 3 2008
Gold: 4,271.99
#992
Jun 30 2010 10:47pm
Quote (Meatyy @ Jul 1 2010 12:43am)
even if it's the person who challenged can't complete it? that doesn't seem fair to the person who got challenged

but then i can challenge someone and say we cant meet up, it gets neer the end of deadline so i jus wait till it's over and I win?


edit:
If you think it's right that it was cancelled, then idk wth is wrong with you.
Because if i was that person in rank 3. ill abuse that and keep on doing it. because i know the result will always be a nulled. and this will result in me keeping my rank ad preventing rank 4 and you from taking it. not to mention it also gives me the chance to always have a shot at rank 2

This post was edited by JAYZONE on Jun 30 2010 10:49pm
Member
Posts: 20,138
Joined: Oct 3 2008
Gold: 4,271.99
#993
Jun 30 2010 10:48pm
Quote (Biglouy @ Jul 1 2010 12:46am)
I dont think you understand the scenario he says the Challenger was trying to make it happen and the challengee couldn't do it. Your thinking of another scenario, which does make sense. I agree its a little BM to challenge someone and not be able to do it.


People dont understand that such action can be taken advantage of.
Member
Posts: 22,828
Joined: Jan 27 2009
Gold: 1,490.00
#994
Jun 30 2010 10:49pm
Quote (JAYZONE @ Jun 30 2010 11:47pm)
edit:
If you think it's right that it was cancelled, then idk wth is wrong with you.
Because if i was that person in rank 3. ill abuse that and keep on doing it. because i know the result will always be a nulled. and this will result in me keeping my rank. and also give me the chance to always have a shot at rank 2


Yeah Meatty is talking about abusing it the other way.... Say I challenge you and you want to get it done.. but then I cant do it and you get a dodge even though you tried.
Member
Posts: 19,729
Joined: Apr 7 2010
Gold: 100.23
#995
Jun 30 2010 10:50pm
Quote (JAYZONE @ Jul 1 2010 12:44am)
Cancelled?

So you if you were rank 5 and challenged rank 3
You try your best to make the duel to happen.
But he is busy.
And since he is running out of time. he requests for an extension.
Base on the book. if the challenged oponent requests for an extension, (it is assumed that both players want to make the duel to happen) but since after the 48 hour has passed and the duel hasn't been done.
YOU, the person who issued the challenged. wasted 5 days. because the challenge has been nulled.

Do you think that's ethical/right?


then i misread your scenario, I was under the impression that you said:

person A challenges person B

they both cant do it in 3 days, 48 hours awarded

person A cannot make it in the extra 2 days even though person B is ready and trying

this would be a dodge? even though the person who challenged can't make it?
Member
Posts: 20,138
Joined: Oct 3 2008
Gold: 4,271.99
#996
Jun 30 2010 10:51pm
Quote (Meatyy @ Jul 1 2010 12:50am)
then i misread your scenario, I was under the impression that you said:

person A challenges person B

they both cant do it in 3 days, 48 hours awarded

person A cannot make it in the extra 2 days even though person B is ready and trying

this would be a dodge? even though the person who challenged can't make it?


I would say dodge. why?

read my previous post in red
Member
Posts: 103,224
Joined: Jun 6 2006
Gold: 15,410.01
#997
Jun 30 2010 10:52pm
unless..we rechanged rules back to 24 hours..for top 3 which it's really stupid lol.
Member
Posts: 22,828
Joined: Jan 27 2009
Gold: 1,490.00
#998
Jun 30 2010 10:53pm
Quote (Meatyy @ Jun 30 2010 11:50pm)
then i misread your scenario, I was under the impression that you said:

person A challenges person B

they both cant do it in 3 days, 48 hours awarded

person A cannot make it in the extra 2 days even though person B is ready and trying

this would be a dodge? even though the person who challenged can't make it?


Personally I've never seen this problem. Most people are GM and don't abuse this. If it ever did happen it would be quite clear and it should be the challengee's responsibility to post and report that the other person has been unreachable...
Member
Posts: 19,729
Joined: Apr 7 2010
Gold: 100.23
#999
Jun 30 2010 10:53pm
Quote (JAYZONE @ Jul 1 2010 12:51am)
I would say dodge. why?

read my previous post in red


but it isn't the challenged persons fault? If the challenger truly wants to do the duel then they will make it work within 5 days, if the person challenged truly doesn't want it to work then they will truly be dogeing ofc, and dodge rule takes place

if challenged person tries to do it within 5 days, and person who challenged truly doesn't wanna duel then they can jus wait 5 days and auto win?

how is this fair?

Quote (Biglouy @ Jul 1 2010 12:53am)
Personally I've never seen this problem. Most people are GM and don't abuse this. If it ever did happen it would be quite clear and it should be the challengee's responsibility to post and report that the other person has been unreachable...


but in obviouos cases like my above scenario why would it be dodge?

bolded this, if most are gm then what about the few bm?

This post was edited by Meatyy on Jun 30 2010 10:55pm
Member
Posts: 103,224
Joined: Jun 6 2006
Gold: 15,410.01
#1000
Jun 30 2010 10:54pm
Quote (Biglouy @ Jun 30 2010 09:53pm)
Personally I've never seen this problem. Most people are GM and don't abuse this. If it ever did happen it would be quite clear and it should be the challengee's responsibility to post and report that the other person has been unreachable...

agree.
Quote (Meatyy @ Jun 30 2010 09:53pm)
but it isn't the challenged persons fault? If the challenger truly wants to do the duel then they will make it work within 5 days, if the person challenged truly doesn't want it to work then they will truly be dogeing ofc, and dodge rule takes place

if challenged person tries to do it within 5 days, and person who challenged truly doesn't wanna duel then they can jus wait 5 days and auto win?

how is this fair?



but in obviouos cases like my above scenario why would it be dodge?


it's challenged person fault mostly.

it's not really fair..it's pretty much bm :/

This post was edited by LilNeko on Jun 30 2010 10:56pm
Go Back To Legit Dueling Topic List
Prev19899100101102353Next
Add Reply New Topic

© 2003-2024 d2jsp  Contact