d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Diablo II > Diablo 2 Discussion > Legit Dueling > Nl Melee Lader Discussions And Suggestions > Thnks For The Inputs :)
Prev1979899100101353Next
Add Reply New Topic
Member
Posts: 103,224
Joined: Jun 6 2006
Gold: 15,410.01
Jun 30 2010 10:34pm
Quote (Meatyy @ Jun 30 2010 09:33pm)
ah, agreed, misread it sorry Jay :bonk:

if only 1 extension is allowed then the match should be cancel as to not hold the ladder up


it was 1 extension thats it. it had 48 hours joe stil had 3: 27 to finish it or 4: 27 bruno's time.

i know jay saying but..bruno asked for extension and it should be cancel. we been trying to say this...lol i've been trying to say this pervious pages.. god lol. -_-

This post was edited by LilNeko on Jun 30 2010 10:37pm
Member
Posts: 19,729
Joined: Apr 7 2010
Gold: 100.23
Jun 30 2010 10:39pm
Quote (LilNeko @ Jul 1 2010 12:34am)
it was 1 extension thats it. it had 48 hours joe stil had 3: 27 to finish it or 4: 27 bruno's time.

i know jay saying but..bruno asked for extension and it should be cancel. we been trying to say this...lol i've been trying to say this pervious pages.. god lol. -_-


my post was towards jay's scenario

and stevo always tries to give 30min leway to makeup timezones
Member
Posts: 20,138
Joined: Oct 3 2008
Gold: 4,271.99
Jun 30 2010 10:40pm
Quote (LilNeko @ Jul 1 2010 12:32am)
Quote
Quote (LilNeko @ Jul 1 2010 12:27am)
Quote (JAYZONE @ Jul 1 2010 12:25am)
Jess you didnt get my statement.
I wasn't reffering to their case. Im speaking generally.

Look.

Challenger challenges
the "challengee" and the challenger runs out of time.
the challenger has been trying to make it happen.
BUt the "challengee" requests for an extention.
The "challengee" couldn't do it in the alloted time.

What case would this result in jess?
Dodge or cancelled.
Remember the "challengee" requested for an extention


as dodge but the defender still have time left right? It has 48 hours thats good 3 days or so? right?


how can the defender have time.

If you read correctly
"The "challengee" couldn't do it in the alloted time."
Meaning he can't even do the duel in the time of the extension.

Why would it be a dodge if the challengee is the one who requested for an extention?
I thought if the person who is being challenged requests for an extension, chances are the duel will end up as a dodge


bruno asked for a extention he cant just CANCEL it or talked to one of admins and enforcing it? because hes not responding and he's admin?thats just obusing or not or talking behind the admins back and try cheat to win? Or no?

it's pretty much bming tbh lol.


man. i dont think you understand the scenario

BLOCK OUT THE ISSUE AT HAND. This does not concern joe's or bruno's case

im asking you what would you do in this case.
dodge or null?

This post was edited by JAYZONE on Jun 30 2010 10:41pm
Member
Posts: 103,224
Joined: Jun 6 2006
Gold: 15,410.01
Jun 30 2010 10:40pm
Quote (Meatyy @ Jun 30 2010 09:39pm)
my post was towards jay's scenario

and stevo always tries to give 30min leway to makeup timezones


not on this ladder. :unsure: maybe on hes lol.

he shouldve give it on us also..joe was on that time also..waiting for bruno to pm him. -_-
Quote (JAYZONE @ Jun 30 2010 09:40pm)
man. i dont think you understand the scenario

BLOCK OUT THE ISSUE AT HAND. This does not concern joe's or bruno's case


i can't really block out the issue til tmr. :/ head still thinking about and stuff...

we trying to drop subject and now it went into drama. -_-

This post was edited by LilNeko on Jun 30 2010 10:42pm
Member
Posts: 22,828
Joined: Jan 27 2009
Gold: 1,490.00
Jun 30 2010 10:41pm
Quote (Meatyy @ Jun 30 2010 11:39pm)
my post was towards jay's scenario

and stevo always tries to give 30min leway to makeup timezones


I'd say easiest thing to do is use eastern time as the standard.. since the majority of us are on east. The people in other time zones should just make note of eastern time.
Member
Posts: 19,729
Joined: Apr 7 2010
Gold: 100.23
Jun 30 2010 10:41pm
I understand it Jay, was my answer what you were thinking of?

Quote (LilNeko @ Jul 1 2010 12:40am)
not on this ladder. :unsure: maybe on hes lol.

he shouldve give it on us also..joe was on that time also..waiting for bruno to pm him. -_-


I think since it's a council system that he didn't wanna impose that on people

Quote (Biglouy @ Jul 1 2010 12:41am)
I'd say easiest thing to do is use eastern time as the standard.. since the majority of us are on east. The people in other time zones should just make note of eastern time.


ya, but 30min leway isn't gonna kill anyone

This post was edited by Meatyy on Jun 30 2010 10:42pm
Member
Posts: 22,828
Joined: Jan 27 2009
Gold: 1,490.00
Jun 30 2010 10:42pm
Quote (JAYZONE @ Jun 30 2010 11:40pm)
man. i dont think you understand the scenario

BLOCK OUT THE ISSUE AT HAND. This does not concern joe's or bruno's case

im asking you what would you do in this case.
dodge or null?


Dodge cut and dry refer to my post earlier...

here;

Well imo thats not fair to the challenger... the challenger wants to advance in the ladder and take a higher rank, so if the duels are canceled because they simply cant meet, thats not fair. It should be the defenders obligation and show up, giving the challenger an opportunity at his spot. If they can't make it in the alloted time, they should loose that spot.

This post was edited by Biglouy on Jun 30 2010 10:44pm
Member
Posts: 19,729
Joined: Apr 7 2010
Gold: 100.23
Jun 30 2010 10:43pm
Quote (Biglouy @ Jul 1 2010 12:42am)
Dodge cut in dry refer to my post earlier...


even if it's the person who challenged can't complete it? that doesn't seem fair to the person who got challenged

but then i can challenge someone and say we cant meet up, it gets neer the end of deadline so i jus wait till it's over and I win?

This post was edited by Meatyy on Jun 30 2010 10:44pm
Member
Posts: 20,138
Joined: Oct 3 2008
Gold: 4,271.99
Jun 30 2010 10:44pm
Quote (Meatyy @ Jul 1 2010 12:41am)
I understand it Jay, was my answer what you were thinking of?



Cancelled?

So you if you were rank 5 and challenged rank 3
You try your best to make the duel to happen.
But he is busy.
And since he is running out of time. he requests for an extension.
Base on the book. if the challenged oponent requests for an extension, (it is assumed that both players want to make the duel to happen) but since after the 48 hour has passed and the duel hasn't been done.
YOU, the person who issued the challenged. wasted 5 days. because the challenge has been nulled.

Do you think that's ethical/right?


This post was edited by JAYZONE on Jun 30 2010 10:47pm
Member
Posts: 103,224
Joined: Jun 6 2006
Gold: 15,410.01
Jun 30 2010 10:46pm
Quote (Biglouy @ Jun 30 2010 09:41pm)
I'd say easiest thing to do is use eastern time as the standard.. since the majority of us are on east. The people in other time zones should just make note of eastern time.


i've always put my computer 3 hours ahead..but i live west time or i look at jsp time lol.

Quote (Meatyy @ Jun 30 2010 09:41pm)
I understand it Jay, was my answer what you were thinking of?



I think since it's a council system that he didn't wanna impose that on people



about extention problem i always think about 48 hours. when 48 hours is done the person whos updating it should know what to do rather it ruled cancel or dodge or whatever and not enforcing it right away or enforcing it behind the admins back w/ only giving 2 options and not others.

Quote (JAYZONE @ Jun 30 2010 09:44pm)
Cancelled?

So you if you were rank 5 and challenged rank 3
You try your best to make the duel to happen.
But he is busy.
And since he is running out of time. he requests for an extension.
Base on the book. if the challenged oponent requests for an extension, (it is assumed that both players want to make the duel to happen) but since after the 48 hour has passed and the duel hasn't been done.
YOU, the person who issued the challenged. wasted 5 days. because the challenge has been nulled.

Do you think that's ethical/right?


it should be ruled as dodge..because the person is PASTED the 48 hours and haven't duel yet.

This post was edited by LilNeko on Jun 30 2010 10:50pm
Go Back To Legit Dueling Topic List
Prev1979899100101353Next
Add Reply New Topic