d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Diablo II > Diablo 2 Discussion > Legit Dueling > Nl Melee Lader Discussions And Suggestions > Thnks For The Inputs :)
Prev19596979899353Next
Add Reply New Topic
Views: 58103Replies: 3529Track Topic
Member
Posts: 22,828
Joined: Jan 27 2009
Gold: 1,490.00
#961
Jun 30 2010 10:11pm
Quote (JAYZONE @ Jun 30 2010 11:11pm)
So you're saying, the challenger doesn't have a guaranteed advancement even if he issued the challenge? even if he tried to make the duel to happen? but because the other player extended the duel and didnt show up 48 hours after the extention was requested.
IT's still  up to the admins to decide whether that person who issued the challenge advance or not?

That's unethical.


Agreed. We gotta be fair and stick to the rules.
Member
Posts: 103,224
Joined: Jun 6 2006
Gold: 15,410.01
#962
Jun 30 2010 10:12pm
Quote (JAYZONE @ Jun 30 2010 09:11pm)
So you're saying, the challenger doesn't have a guaranteed advancement even if he issued the challenge? even if he tried to make the duel to happen? but because the other player extended the duel and didnt show up 48 hours after the extention was requested.
IT's still up to the admins to decide whether that person who issued the challenge advance or not?

That's unethical.


if user didn't show up 48 hours it should be ruled as dodge BUT they still had time right?

he still had 3 hours and 32 mins or so. soo they had ENOUGH time to finish it.

if came worse the the admins have to make right choice and get enough proof before ruling it.
Quote (Bruno @ Jun 30 2010 04:28pm)
Steve told me via pm that I should not even have asked for an extension of this challenge since this is up to the challenged to do that. And since mrdrumman hasnt posted in this topic at all, Steve and I agree it should have been ruled as dodge last night with the no-show.

I now challenge:

02. Beingly/desouza/Buddah_blessU—Zeal

pmd




This post was edited by LilNeko on Jun 30 2010 10:15pm
Member
Posts: 18,396
Joined: May 24 2006
Gold: 0.00
Trader: Trusted
#963
Jun 30 2010 10:15pm
Quote (Meatyy @ 1 Jul 2010 00:10)
it's simple, he couldn't make it, cut and dry, that does not mean that the deadline was last night.

the deadline was still midnight tonight, no iffs ands or buts about it...


You're right. Stuff happens. But when that stuff that happens ruins the evening of your opponent who showed up and waited for hours to duel, in vain, you have to take responsibility for this. As a challenger, I had other things to do than waiting a whole evening for mrdrumman to show up like he said he would and realize he was not coming.
Member
Posts: 19,729
Joined: Apr 7 2010
Gold: 100.23
#964
Jun 30 2010 10:15pm
Quote (JAYZONE @ Jul 1 2010 12:11am)
So you're saying, the challenger doesn't have a guaranteed advancement even if he issued the challenge? even if he tried to make the duel to happen? but because the other player extended the duel and didnt show up 48 hours after the extention was requested.
IT's still  up to the admins to decide whether that person who issued the challenge advance or not?

That's unethical.


agreed, challenger should always advance unless there's an obvious unfixable problem for the two people to meet up

Quote (uqbar98 @ Jun 29 2010 04:58pm)
ya Steve np cancel it its impossible to  coincide online i was until round 4am east and still didnt coincide hehe


this is from ladder melee ladder, aleph and his opponent could not meet up cause of massive timezone differences

Quote (Bruno @ Jul 1 2010 12:15am)
You're right. Stuff happens. But when that stuff that happens ruins the evening of your opponent who showed up and waited for hours to duel, in vain, you have to take responsibility for this. As a challenger, I had other things to do than waiting a whole evening for mrdrumman to show up like he said he would and realize he was not coming.


you honestly sat there for 3 hours doing nothing? if you'd already made time you can always do other stuff while waiting, I do not see a problem with this, and it's already been stated that this has happened to other people.

however unfortunate it is, it does not change the fact that the deadline was midnight tonight

This post was edited by Meatyy on Jun 30 2010 10:17pm
Member
Posts: 18,396
Joined: May 24 2006
Gold: 0.00
Trader: Trusted
#965
Jun 30 2010 10:17pm
Quote (Meatyy @ 1 Jul 2010 00:15)
agreed, challenger should always advance unless there's an obvious unfixable problem for the two people to meet up



this is from ladder melee ladder, aleph and his opponent could not meet up cause of massive timezone differences


Two different timezones is extremely different. This is not anyone's fault if the challenge can't take place.

mrdrumman did not do anything in the topic and he did not show up to our meeting. That's not something you can overlook when deciding whether to cancel or rule as dodge.
Member
Posts: 103,224
Joined: Jun 6 2006
Gold: 15,410.01
#966
Jun 30 2010 10:18pm
Quote (Bruno @ Jun 30 2010 09:17pm)
Two different timezones is extremely different. This is not anyone's fault if the challenge can't take place.

mrdrumman did not do anything in the topic and he did not show up to our meeting. That's not something you can overlook when deciding whether to cancel or rule as dodge.


only 1 hour behind..that's nothing. -_- if was like Hengsters time or ALEPHS time. :rofl:

joe lives east, you live cen? not that big problem. it just gives joe extra hour lol.

This post was edited by LilNeko on Jun 30 2010 10:19pm
Member
Posts: 19,729
Joined: Apr 7 2010
Gold: 100.23
#967
Jun 30 2010 10:19pm
Quote (Bruno @ Jul 1 2010 12:17am)
Two different timezones is extremely different. This is not anyone's fault if the challenge can't take place.

mrdrumman did not do anything in the topic and he did not show up to our meeting. That's not something you can overlook when deciding whether to cancel or rule as dodge.


read my edit, I still don't see how you can't get this

THE DEADLINE WAS TONIGHT AT MIDNIGHT

regardless of if he missed your "date" or not
Member
Posts: 18,396
Joined: May 24 2006
Gold: 0.00
Trader: Trusted
#968
Jun 30 2010 10:20pm
Quote (Meatyy @ 1 Jul 2010 00:19)
read my edit, I still don't see how you can't get this

THE DEADLINE WAS TONIGHT AT MIDNIGHT

regardless of if he missed your "date" or not


I am done arguing about this. You think I don't understand your point and I think you don't understand mine.

This will lead to no good, so I am done.
Member
Posts: 19,729
Joined: Apr 7 2010
Gold: 100.23
#969
Jun 30 2010 10:21pm
Quote (Bruno @ Jul 1 2010 12:20am)
I am done arguing about this. You think I don't understand your point and I think you don't understand mine.

This will lead to no good, so I am done.


I understand your point fine, but sadly your point is irrelevent due to the fact that there was still time to complete the challenge, sorry to be so blunt but that's the truth
Member
Posts: 103,224
Joined: Jun 6 2006
Gold: 15,410.01
#970
Jun 30 2010 10:22pm
Quote (Bruno @ Jun 30 2010 09:20pm)
I am done arguing about this. You think I don't understand your point and I think you don't understand mine.

This will lead to no good, so I am done.


You don't understand our point.. only thing you're saying that you belive what steve said and that extention was in 12 hours..which it was 48 hours.....which he had enough time it.
Quote (Meatyy @ Jun 30 2010 09:21pm)
I understand your point fine, but sadly your point is irrelevent due to the fact that there was still time to complete the challenge, sorry to be so blunt but that's the truth


brad going post lol extention is 48 hours NOT 12 hours. soo he pretty much got easy win or free win. :/ w/o talking to brad or me which im always on lol.

steve said something giving people free win and it's wrong to do so and etc? he just give someone free win. :/

This post was edited by LilNeko on Jun 30 2010 10:24pm
Go Back To Legit Dueling Topic List
Prev19596979899353Next
Add Reply New Topic

© 2003-2024 d2jsp  Contact