d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Diablo II > Diablo 2 Discussion > Legit Dueling > Ferdia's 1st Lld Level 30 Melee Only Tournament > D2:R
Prev12345613Next
Add Reply New Topic
Member
Posts: 4,000
Joined: Jun 1 2015
Gold: 4,721.74
Dec 7 2021 10:26am
in that case pull me out of the tournament, no point if people just target the spirit...

next time I guess
Member
Posts: 37,982
Joined: Jul 8 2008
Gold: 10,636.50
Dec 7 2021 10:27am
webbynator 5 - deafviking 0
he missunderstood something
Member
Posts: 56,269
Joined: Jan 19 2007
Gold: 574,605.03
Dec 7 2021 10:29am
Quote (vertster123 @ Dec 7 2021 04:26pm)
in that case pull me out of the tournament, no point if people just target the spirit...

next time I guess


I cant chat until later. can you please not be hasty.

Quote (Webbynator @ Dec 7 2021 04:27pm)
webbynator 5 - deafviking 0
he missunderstood something


he did not misunderstand anything. the rules were not clear in this aspect.

Member
Posts: 37,982
Joined: Jul 8 2008
Gold: 10,636.50
Dec 7 2021 10:30am
Quote (vertster123 @ Dec 7 2021 05:26pm)
in that case pull me out of the tournament, no point if people just target the spirit...

next time I guess


you have to bring it to the end pls. you started now you need to end it pls.
people allready fought you and have points for tourney would be real unfair to dodge me now.
Member
Posts: 9,878
Joined: Jul 30 2021
Gold: 1,661.91
Warn: 30%
Dec 7 2021 10:32am
Quote (ferdia @ Dec 7 2021 11:29am)
I cant chat until later. can you please not be hasty.



he did not misunderstand anything. the rules were not clear in this aspect.


yeah i was joking about the "zealer bonesnap" comment hahah, my bad, truly!
gl to everyone and see y'all next time. Guess I gotta make a real melee LLD :) haha
Member
Posts: 56,269
Joined: Jan 19 2007
Gold: 574,605.03
Dec 7 2021 10:34am
Webbynator, for Melee only typically one player starts on one end, and another starts on another end and typically the players alternate positions between duels. this was not clearly stated in the rules but is common practice. I appreciate that you might not have been aware of this.

He is not dodging you, he has queried an action. can you both please hold off until I can discuss this further.
Member
Posts: 4,000
Joined: Jun 1 2015
Gold: 4,721.74
Dec 7 2021 10:35am
Quote (Webbynator @ Dec 7 2021 10:30am)
you have to bring it to the end pls. you started now you need to end it pls.
people allready fought you and have points for tourney would be real unfair to dodge me now.


no dodging here, will just give everyone 5-0 victories if I can't use the spirit though it may be addressed - we will see

just gotta wait for a bit I guess
Member
Posts: 4,000
Joined: Jun 1 2015
Gold: 4,721.74
Dec 7 2021 10:51am
If things need to be explicitly written then you should also say exactly how the duel is to be performed.

For example, what is stopping someone from running all around the bloodmoor halfway through the battle with 22liferep until they are back to full health to continue slapping?

Or, for that matter, they could run around all of act1 leeching life from monsters when they're close to death from the duel.

Would rabies be allowed in the melee tournament since it's not explicitly restricted? Someone could bite-and-run, bite-and-run,according to the rules of this melee tournament.

Of course people would agree none of this should be allowed in melee duels. Just because it's not explicitly stated doesn't mean it's not an understood rule.


I'm sorry if this comes off as confrontational, I am just trying to prove a point here. I know you are trying to be as fair as possible with explicit rules, but I'm saying it will be hard to have everything explicitly written down because many things are just common sense that should not have to be written.

Member
Posts: 9,878
Joined: Jul 30 2021
Gold: 1,661.91
Warn: 30%
Dec 7 2021 10:52am
Quote (Webbynator @ Dec 7 2021 11:27am)
webbynator 5 - deafviking 0
he missunderstood something


yeah my bad give him the 5-0 i got this confused with the other tournament

i dont have a melee 30 character yet, only my charger. My bad, I won't mess up again in the future
Quote (ferdia @ Dec 7 2021 11:34am)
dont even know what i'd respec into, this the only LLD weapon i have atm, the eth bonesnap lmfao
and no shield haha

i feel bad haha, next time i'll be ready



^^^^^ woops weird formatting lul

This post was edited by DeafViking on Dec 7 2021 10:53am
Member
Posts: 37,982
Joined: Jul 8 2008
Gold: 10,636.50
Dec 7 2021 10:55am
Quote (vertster123 @ Dec 7 2021 05:51pm)
If things need to be explicitly written then you should also say exactly how the duel is to be performed.

For example, what is stopping someone from running all around the bloodmoor halfway through the battle with 22liferep until they are back to full health to continue slapping?

Or, for that matter, they could run around all of act1 leeching life from monsters when they're close to death from the duel.

Would rabies be allowed in the melee tournament since it's not explicitly restricted? Someone could bite-and-run, bite-and-run,according to the rules of this melee tournament.

Of course people would agree none of this should be allowed in melee duels. Just because it's not explicitly stated doesn't mean it's not an understood rule.


I'm sorry if this comes off as confrontational, I am just trying to prove a point here. I know you are trying to be as fair as possible with explicit rules, but I'm saying it will be hard to have everything explicitly written down because many things are just common sense that should not have to be written.


this things you listened up are quite a diffrent story.
i did not do any of these.
i just killed you after i killed youre spirit.


im sorry for all that mess but i followed the rules 100%

This post was edited by Webbynator on Dec 7 2021 10:58am
Go Back To Legit Dueling Topic List
Prev12345613Next
Add Reply New Topic