d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Diablo II > Diablo 2 Discussion > Legit Dueling > 1v1 Non Fpk Tournament > Brackets Up, Signups Closed
Prev1252627282952Next
Add Reply New Topic
Member
Posts: 41,350
Joined: Apr 16 2008
Gold: 0.00
Jan 5 2016 05:27am
Quote (WatcherOfTheSkies @ Jan 5 2016 02:53am)
D/Q me

don't have time for more duels nonetheless 2 more

remove me



Thanks for being honest and saving everyone time.
Group B is complete. Even though Jeet was DQd and Watcherofskies/Canttouchthis both dropped, there was only two points separating 3rd and 1st.

Group B Results:
LucAA advancing with 1st Seed
Negro advancing with 2nd Seed
Member
Posts: 465
Joined: Jan 4 2016
Gold: 0.00
Jan 5 2016 05:42am
Quote (LucAA @ Jan 4 2016 09:25am)
Jeet DQ'd, forfeits all matches.


Sad af...



This post was edited by 1v1pK on Jan 5 2016 05:43am
Member
Posts: 465
Joined: Jan 4 2016
Gold: 0.00
Jan 5 2016 11:53am
Quick question...
Say no other duels take place in group A...


do the two top records move onto next round?

Would seem kind of unfair to award everyone free points for not dueling?
Member
Posts: 34,936
Joined: Jan 21 2012
Gold: 1,090.50
Jan 5 2016 11:56am
GL
Member
Posts: 41,350
Joined: Apr 16 2008
Gold: 0.00
Jan 5 2016 12:01pm
Quote (1v1pK @ Jan 5 2016 01:53pm)
Quick question...
Say no other duels take place in group A...


do the two top records move onto next round?

Would seem kind of unfair to award everyone free points for not dueling?


Forfeiting has resulted in 3-0 for this tournament so far.
We can discuss a different system for drops but for the remainder of this one, it'll stay that way. Since the tournament is based on points, it's only fair to reward the full 3 points to everyone that person was supposed to duel. Someone shouldn't be penalized because someone else couldn't make their duels.
Member
Posts: 465
Joined: Jan 4 2016
Gold: 0.00
Jan 5 2016 12:05pm
Quote (LucAA @ Jan 5 2016 01:01pm)
Forfeiting has resulted in 3-0 for this tournament so far.
We can discuss a different system for drops but for the remainder of this one, it'll stay that way. Since the tournament is based on points, it's only fair to reward the full 3 points to everyone that person was supposed to duel. Someone shouldn't be penalized because someone else couldn't make their duels.


Yea. Someone shouldn't be penalized by losing their spot based off free wins either tho?

This post was edited by 1v1pK on Jan 5 2016 12:05pm
Member
Posts: 41,350
Joined: Apr 16 2008
Gold: 0.00
Jan 5 2016 12:41pm
Quote (1v1pK @ Jan 5 2016 02:05pm)
Yea. Someone shouldn't be penalized by losing their spot based off free wins either tho?



Correct, which is why there is only a discrepancy when the person dropping has already played matches. Otherwise, everyone gets the same amount of points. But, if we're looking at a per match basis, if X dueled Y, and won 3-1, then dropped before getting to W or Z, Y had every chance to earn their points but failed to. X is still obligated to duel W/Z and they have every right to the 3 full the points they were suppose to have the chance to earn if X wouldn't duel them.
Member
Posts: 465
Joined: Jan 4 2016
Gold: 0.00
Jan 5 2016 12:48pm
Quote (LucAA @ Jan 5 2016 01:41pm)
Correct, which is why there is only a discrepancy when the person dropping has already played matches. Otherwise, everyone gets the same amount of points. But, if we're looking at a per match basis, if X dueled Y, and won 3-1, then dropped before getting to W or Z, Y had every chance to earn their points but failed to. X is still obligated to duel W/Z and they have every right to the 3 full the points they were suppose to have the chance to earn if X wouldn't duel them.


I gotta say man..even though I see how you did it. still bs that guys get awarded free points for not dueling. which is going to end of securing their spot in top 2. that's the flaw in this whole round Robin thing


if you weren't giving free wins out, the standings for B bracket would still be the same?

This post was edited by 1v1pK on Jan 5 2016 12:54pm
Member
Posts: 12,061
Joined: May 21 2013
Gold: 0.00
Jan 5 2016 12:53pm
Rick is not pleased
Member
Posts: 41,350
Joined: Apr 16 2008
Gold: 0.00
Jan 5 2016 01:00pm
Quote (1v1pK @ Jan 5 2016 02:48pm)
I gotta say man..even though I see how you did it. still bs that guys get awarded free points for not dueling. which is going to end of securing their spot in top 2. that's the flaw in this whole round Robin thing


if you weren't giving free wins out, the standings for B bracket would still be the same?



I told you via PM already.
If Drew drops, you all get 3. How is that favoring someone LOL.
If Austin wins against Blizz and Drew drops, you will be third because all 3 of you will be 5-1 but they both earned more points in their loss than you did. (Austin loss to you 1-3, Max loss to Austin 1-3, you lost to Max 0-3). If you miss finals it's because you let Austin squeeze out a win, it has nothing to do with "free points".

There's no flaw in round robin ROFL. There's a flaw in users signing up and not playing, completely out of my control.

This post was edited by LucAA on Jan 5 2016 01:01pm
Go Back To Legit Dueling Topic List
Prev1252627282952Next
Add Reply New Topic