Escl Gm Melee Ladder - Topic

Member

Posts: 22,589

Joined: May 2 2013

Gold: 12,770.00

Feb 24 2014 10:17pm

If y'all wanna take a vote to decide if we should allow winners to challenge immediately after winning under any circumstance, here's your chance.
Here's my view on the matter:
Case 1: You are in 5th place, and you challenge someone in 3rd place. In this situation you should wait 12 hours before challenging #2, to allow #4 the chance to challenge you.
Case 2: You are in 6th place, and you challenge someone in 4th place. In this situation you are not skipping anyone that will be able to challenge you once you finish the duel, and therefore you should be allowed to challenge whomever you like.

Short version (for BeSh): If you win against someone right above you in rank, you should be able to challenge again right afterward. If you are dueling 2 spots above you, you have to give the person you just skipped the chance to challenge you before placing your next challenge (12 hours)
Refer to the bottom of the post for the official wording of the vote.

<Challenging>

1) You are allowed to challenge up to 2 ranks above you until you get to #3 then you must duel #2, then #1.
2) You must PM the other party about the challenge FIRST then post challenge in this topic.
3) Challenge will be best 2/3 sets. The winner of each set will be the first to six. You must win each set by atleast 2 duels.
4) All GM Melee Rules apply (as can be viewed in post #106 of this thread)
5) If you issued the Challenge you must wait 12 hours after it's completion to issue another Challenge.
6) If you lose a Challenge you must wait 48 Hours to re-challenge the same person.
7) 3-Day Dodge Rule (Afk, no-reply, no-show = auto-loss) 2 consecutive "dodges" = removed from Ladder.
8) If you cannot complete your Challenge on time it is your responsibility to PM your Challenger to inform them.
Once you've informed them, post in this Topic and ask for an extension. If you fail to do this Dodge Rule will be enforced.
¥ annotates a single dodge

Standings:

#1 Drottning : Sean (Drottning) - Level 99 Zealer

#2 inobi : KAAR (inobi) - Level 96 Conc

#3 IcestormChimp : Chimpy (Chimpy) - Level 95 Conc

#4 CMSgt : PWNT (osi) - Level 96 Conc

#5 Vapo1 : Vaipo (Vapo1) - Level 94 Zealer**

#6 bdawg3 : AfroCircus (2nd02nun) - Level 96 Zealer**

#7 Bigal22 : CAPSLOCK (Bigal) - Level 94 Zealer**

#8 Questions : Douglas (Bobandy) - Level 96 Zealer**

#9 Rucus : Marley (Marley) - Level 98 Zealer**

#10 BeSh : Il (BeSh) - Level 95 Zealer**

#11 Hasto : hastened (nsaneklown) - Level 97 Zealer

#12 kirsten86 : Blessed_Hammers (LiLbIt2010) - Level 96 Zealer

#13 Juventus : mIschia (Juventus) - Level 89 Jab

Times defended #1:

Drottning : Sean (Drottning) - Level 99 Zealer - 1

Vacation Status List:

There are currently no users on Vacation Status.

Pending Challenges:

#10 BeSh : Il (BeSh) - Level 95 Zealer challenged #8 Questions : Douglas (Bobandy) - Level 96 Zealer - February 24th

#9 Rucus : Marley (Marley) - Level 98 Zealer challenged #7 Bigal22 : CAPSLOCK (Bigal) - Level 94 Zealer February 23rd

#6 bdawg3 : AfroCircus (2nd02nun) - Level 96 Zealer challenged #5 Vapo1 : Vaipo (Vapo1) - Level 94 Zealer February 23rd

Calling a vote:
Pick the letter that best describes how you feel about the issuing of challenges:
A. You should always have to wait 12 hours after finishing a challenge to challenge someone else.
B. As long as you are dueling everyone in your path, you should be able to challenge immediately after winning a challenge.
C. You should always be able to place your next challenge immediately after winning a challenge, regardless of who you just won against.
Lmk what y'all think

This post was edited by Drottning on Feb 24 2014 10:18pm

BeSh

Member

Posts: 57,513

Joined: Jun 24 2006

Gold: 900.00

#232

Feb 24 2014 10:49pm

Lolol @ short version for BeSh!

Obv I vote FOR winner being able to challenge ahead immediately!

BeSh

Member

Posts: 57,513

Joined: Jun 24 2006

Gold: 900.00

#233

Feb 25 2014 12:15am

C*

B makes no sense..what if someone is in a challenge...u'd have to wait for them...

ps: I'm lvl 96* not 95! just lvled...

Vrael

Member

Posts: 22,589

Joined: May 2 2013

Gold: 12,770.00

#234

Feb 25 2014 12:22am

Quote (BeSh @ 25 Feb 2014 00:15)

C*

B makes no sense..what if someone is in a challenge...u'd have to wait for them...

ps: I'm lvl 96* not 95! just lvled...

B Translation for BeSh: Dueling everyone in your path.. as long as they aren't in a challenge.. if they are you'll have to skip them, and wait your 12 hours with the B rule.

BeSh

Member

Posts: 57,513

Joined: Jun 24 2006

Gold: 900.00

#235

Feb 25 2014 12:32am

Quote (Drottning @ Feb 25 2014 01:22am)

B Translation for BeSh: Dueling everyone in your path.. as long as they aren't in a challenge.. if they are you'll have to skip them, and wait your 12 hours with the B rule.

It's either A or C...don't go for half assed measures. That's utterly retarded...

Man really, I'm going to stop criticizing Sean but if u want to build something that will last, you need to stop complicating things.
There's a reason why no one is voting, because your shit is long and painful.

Even your updates are heavy man.

Like:

Code

#9 Rucus : Marley (Marley) - Level 98 Zealer challenged #7 Bigal22 : CAPSLOCK (Bigal) - Level 94 Zealer February 23rd

WTF is that?!

There man:
Simple, efficient.

Code

#9 Rucus vs #7 Bigal22 ~ Feb 23rd

I hope you're not taking this the wrong way...

Vrael

Member

Posts: 22,589

Joined: May 2 2013

Gold: 12,770.00

#236

Feb 25 2014 12:34am

Simple: Copy + paste..
That's what I did.

ToughGuy_TJ

Member

Posts: 81,244

Joined: Oct 9 2007

Gold: 242,155.61

#237

Feb 25 2014 12:34am

UGML has been going on for 4+ years, rules are pretty strongly built on experience

probably shouldnt fuck with it much

This post was edited by ToughGuy_TJ on Feb 25 2014 12:38am

Vrael

Member

Posts: 22,589

Joined: May 2 2013

Gold: 12,770.00

#238

Feb 25 2014 12:35am

Quote (ToughGuy_TJ @ 25 Feb 2014 00:34)

UGML been going on for 4+ years, rules are pretty strongly built on experience

probably shouldnt fuck with it much

This post was edited by Drottning on Feb 25 2014 12:48am

Rucus

Member

Posts: 25,496

Joined: Jun 13 2008

Gold: 20,004.00

#239

Feb 25 2014 12:36am

I don't really mind either way both of my duels have taken like 48 hours to happen so shit is slow anyways. and yea copy/past brah

BeSh

Member

Posts: 57,513

Joined: Jun 24 2006

Gold: 900.00

#240

Feb 25 2014 12:44am

Quote (ToughGuy_TJ @ Feb 25 2014 01:34am)

UGML been going on for 4+ years, rules are pretty strongly build on experience

probably shouldnt fuck with it much

Yeah yeah...
And my ladder was here since 2008... http://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=25541066&f=147
and that was also built on experience...and all of these other ladders

http://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=61118108&f=147 that ladder uses a similar rule to what I'm suggesting.

http://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=42448063&f=147 - If you lost the match, will have to wait for 24h before challenging anyone (this way lower ranks will have an opportunity to challenge you).

http://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=54454490&f=147

http://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=50156436&f=147

FIND ME ONE LADDER OTHER THAN THE EAST NL MELEE LADDER that uses that stupid rule.

Use your head peeps -_-

This post was edited by BeSh on Feb 25 2014 12:44am

Go Back To Legit Dueling Topic List