d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Diablo II > Diablo 2 Discussion > Legit Dueling > East N-l Gm Ww Barbvsbarb > By Besh
Prev1197919801981198219833439Next
Add Reply New Topic
Member
Posts: 13,143
Joined: Jun 3 2010
Gold: 13,878.50
Nov 20 2014 07:04pm
I wish to propose a vote to amend one of the rules AND to add one other:
Majority vote wins per item (each one has a chance to be applied separately)
This vote is open to the current 15 accounts on the ladder. (1 vote per account)
Votes are final and will not be changed (please consider both sides prior to voting)
Please vote on both issues at the same time in this format: #1: Yes/No #2: Yes/No
This poll will close 11/30/14 @ 12:00 midnight.
If you do not vote, your vote will be nulled.

#1 Amendment:
Current rule: "5) If you lose a Challenge you must wait 24 Hours to re-challenge the same person."
Proposed Amendment: If you lose a Challenge you must wait 12 Hours before posting another challenge and 24 Hours to re-challenge the same person.
Reasoning: This would reward the winner with the chance to duel +1 or +2 places above him (whichever is open) and other winners under him to challenge up the ladder. (this is more of a reward of winning). The winner should have the right to challenge for whichever position he wants (within range of 2) first.

#2 New Rule:
New Rule: In the case that you own more than 1 barb on the ladder (max of 2), You are unable to challenge yourself.
Reasoning: In the case that you were able to challenge yourself it would 1) tie up the ladder and 2) become a free place swap for 1 of your barbs. Essentially challenging yourself would be as if u challenged +4. (example: you own barbs #10 and #8, you challenge yourself awarding a position swap and then go on to challenge +2. This would be the same as #10 vs #6 (+4). I propose the you are unable to challenge yourself and must challenge around your other barb. (example: You own #10 and #8, In order to advance your #10 above your #8 you would have to challenge positions #9 and then #7 (as would be in accordance to the +2 rule).

Rebekah: Arthos: #1: Yes #2: Yes

Besh: BULL: #1: Yes #2: Yes

Braum: Gohan:

millerhighlife: OhPieceOfCandy: #1: Yes #2: Yes

Transplant: XAxeX:

Lacapitale: Rios:

Killermcknight76: Rolltide: #1: No #2: Yes

Baldbastard: Copenhagen:

Cjarvis: Gmbvb:

mick1507: Steroids:

Zidesef: Charles_manson: #1: Yes #2: Yes

1nceaday: Soulthief:

Busta_nutz: Busta_nutz:

Juventus: Etruscan:

Darksnipe: Arnie:

This post was edited by Rebekah on Nov 20 2014 07:12pm
Member
Posts: 13,143
Joined: Jun 3 2010
Gold: 13,878.50
Nov 20 2014 07:06pm
<< UPDATED LADDER>>

#1 Rebekah: Arthos

#2 Besh: BULL

#3 Braum: Gohan

#4 millerhighlife: OhPieceOfCandy

#5 Transplant: XAxeX

#6 Lacapitale: Rios

#7 Killermcknight76: Rolltide

#8 Zidesef: ZIDESEF

#9 Baldbastard: Copenhagen

#10 Cjarvis: Gmbvb

#11 mick1507: Steroids

#12 Zidesef: Charles_manson

#13 Baldbastard: Blessed_mother

#14 1nceaday: Soulthief

#15 Busta_nutz: Busta_nutz

#16 Juventus: Etruscan

#17 Darksnipe: Arnie

Challenging (Read this before you issue any challenge):

1) You are allowed to challenge up to 2 ranks above you.
2) You must PM the other party about the challenge.
3) Challenge will be first to 7.
4) The winner of the challenge is allowed to challenge immediately after winning.
5) If you lose a Challenge you must wait 24 Hours to re-challenge the same person.
6) 3-Day Dodge Rule (Afk, no-reply, no-show = auto-loss) 2 consecutive "dodges" = removed from Ladder. Post in this thread if you need an extension (of 48 hours max).
7) It is your responsibility to keep the admins up to date on the status of your duel by posting here (Win/Lose/Null/Dodge/Request Extension).
8) If you are experiencing trouble meeting up with a challenge, please pm an admin and inform them (if we don't know that you have worked something out with...Arthos to duel in 4 days, we are going to invoke dodge/null rules).

Current/Last updated/ Old Rules Located Here -->http://s13.postimage.org/n8lmg35hz/BvBRules.jpghttp://s13.postimage.org/n8lmg35hz/BvBRules.jpg9

Pending Challenges:

#10 Cjarvis: Gmbvb Vs #8 Zidesef: ZIDESEF (11/16/14)(7:42pm)(48 hour extension)
#16 Juventus: Etruscan Vs #15 Busta_nutz: Busta_nutz (11/18/14)(12:44am)
#2 Besh: BULL Vs #1 Rebekah: Arthos (11/19/14)(4:01pm)
#6 Lacapitale: Rios Vs #4 millerhighlife: OhPieceOfCandy (11/19/14)(10:32pm)
#9 Baldbastard: Copenhagen Vs #7 Killermcknight76: Rolltide (11/19/14)(9:59pm)
#5 Transplant: XAxeX Vs #3 Braum: Gohan (11/20/14)(11:54am)

Tournaments:
^^Accepting donations for tournament prizes!^^
All tournaments will be announced accordingly as public posts. Please check here for future tournament updates.
2014 Gladiator Challenge
^Sign up NOW! Only accepting the first 32 applicants. ^
Registration ends 11/22/14.

☆★Previous Tournament Winners★☆
Winner of Tournament #4: Eth: Arreat / Runner up: Klax12 / Third place: Rebekah: Arthos
Winner of Tournament #3: Klax12: XII_two / Runner up: Rebekah: Arthos
Winner of Tournament #2: Evil_plots: Butcher / Runner up: Eth: Arreat
Winner of Tournament #1: Rebekah: Arthos / Runner up: Bingtu: MrBingles

Inactive Barbs:
Nede: Ugoh
Bizzar: Williambowers
evil_plots: Butcher
Peen: Balrog
Blazen: Crazy
sickoflifeale: Ba-Sickoflife
Eros: Gangster
K_3_N: Free_Porn
Toughguy_TJ: TJ
Bingtu: MrBingles
Klax12: XII_two

Current Admins:

Rebekah
Besh
Member
Posts: 589
Joined: Mar 4 2013
Gold: 68.00
Nov 20 2014 07:11pm
#1 hell yes #2 Yes, imo shouldn't have two barbs on ladder.
Member
Posts: 4,053
Joined: Oct 5 2003
Gold: 987.00
Nov 20 2014 07:19pm
Quote (millerhighlife @ Nov 20 2014 09:11pm)
#1 hell yes #2 Yes, imo shouldn't have two barbs on ladder.



This. 1x barb is enough. Also waiting 12h after you lose when you are challenging someone is a great idea. However if someone challenge you and you drop of one or two ranks, the 12h should not be apply since you droped and youre not the one who challenged the other person

This post was edited by Braum on Nov 20 2014 07:23pm
Member
Posts: 13,143
Joined: Jun 3 2010
Gold: 13,878.50
Nov 20 2014 07:41pm
Quote (Braum @ Nov 20 2014 08:19pm)
This.  1x barb is enough.  Also waiting 12h after you lose when you are challenging someone is a great idea.  However if someone challenge you and you drop of one or two ranks, the 12h should not be apply since you droped and youre not the one who challenged the other person


a valid point but what if you the loser then challenged +2 above you (+1 above whom you just lost to) and that leaves the winner unable to advance up? (+2 is tied up in a duel with someone higher)
/e I'm not sure if this was you voting either so if it was please just repost with your votes.

This post was edited by Rebekah on Nov 20 2014 07:43pm
Member
Posts: 4,053
Joined: Oct 5 2003
Gold: 987.00
Nov 20 2014 08:13pm
Just vote yes for 1 & 2. Anyways the winner should have the adv.

This post was edited by Braum on Nov 20 2014 08:24pm
Member
Posts: 22,297
Joined: Jul 3 2009
Gold: 15.00
Nov 20 2014 08:17pm
I think having 2 barbs on the ladder is retarded tbh..

I understand wanting to have different barbs for different gear set ups, but I think it just ties up the advancement process. If im #10, and Mr. X is #9 and #8, and I challenge #8, and win, he can just challenge me twice in a row, once with #9 and now #10, slowing my process to the top.

although ive been gone long enough for my opinion to not matter much lol.

This post was edited by Sopranos on Nov 20 2014 08:18pm
Member
Posts: 20,409
Joined: Feb 5 2010
Gold: 3,140.99
Nov 20 2014 08:48pm
Quote (Sopranos @ Nov 20 2014 06:17pm)
I think having 2 barbs on the ladder is retarded tbh..

I understand wanting to have different barbs for different gear set ups, but I think it just ties up the advancement process. If im #10, and Mr. X is #9 and #8, and I challenge #8, and win, he can just challenge me twice in a row, once with #9 and now #10, slowing my process to the top.

although ive been gone long enough for my opinion to not matter much lol.


That.

This post was edited by Transplant on Nov 20 2014 08:49pm
Member
Posts: 589
Joined: Mar 4 2013
Gold: 68.00
Nov 20 2014 08:55pm
7-6 Candy Gds Rios
Member
Posts: 12,256
Joined: Sep 18 2011
Gold: 0.00
Nov 20 2014 08:56pm
Quote (millerhighlife @ Nov 20 2014 10:55pm)
7-6 Candy Gds Rios


Gds Candy

#1 yes #2 No

I would prefer that there would a second category for barb with 2 axes for news challenge vs bvc haha
Go Back To Legit Dueling Topic List
Prev1197919801981198219833439Next
Add Reply New Topic