1v1 All Class World Ladder Chat Thread - Topic

Withdrawling/dropping a challenge counts as a loss, as was discussed on the old ladder. Doing so is allowed but you must wait 6 hours before making another challenge, therefore this challenge technically is invaild.

I will update again after i get home from class in 5 hours or so.

That's not the same thing
You gave me your spot
I challenged young from below and then changed to challenge Kurt.. I didn't forfeit my spot to some one challenging from below.

It's not a loss..

Moreover the rules say nothing about withdrawing from challenge counting as a loss.

This post was edited by KungPeriodFu on Feb 5 2015 09:10am

legen

Member

Posts: 12,712

Joined: Nov 7 2006

Gold: 1,328.00

#164

Feb 5 2015 10:14am

This goes without saying but just so its clear to everyone:

"Dropping" or "withdrawling" from a challenge is the same as forfeiting that challenge. Forfeiting a challenge is allowed, but you will be subject to the 6 hour challenge rule due having lost the challenge you forfeited.

Dont need anymore pm's like this regarding the matter ~.~

Quote (KungPeriodFu @ Feb 5 2015 11:09am)

Quote (legen @ Feb 5 2015 10:56am)

Quote (KungPeriodFu @ Feb 5 2015 10:53am)

Quote (legen @ Feb 5 2015 10:50am)

Quote (KungPeriodFu @ Feb 5 2015 10:47am)

Quote (legen @ Feb 5 2015 10:43am)

Quote (KungPeriodFu @ Feb 5 2015 10:03am)

That's not the same thing
You gave me your spot
I challenged young from below and then changed to channel he Kurt..

It's not a loss..

And the rules don't say anything about withdraw being a loss.

Nulling a challenge is the same as lossing it. This prevents someone from making a challenge just to avoid being challenged so they could drop it and challenge up a head, which clearly is intentionally holding up the ladder.

I withdrew from the challenge
I didn't lose and it wasn't nulled.

The rules don't cover this

At the least I should be given the same opportunity you were given in that this appears to be a new rule and so after this incident the rule should be enforced.

But as of right now you are creating a new rule and enforcing it on me without any prior knowledge.

I even said myself when that happened it shouldnt have.. you read threw and have read through all the old threads and rules before so ignorance is not an excuse. We plan on doing the duel in 3 hours.. if you cant sit tight until then you need to see a docter about adhd medication.

Nah dude I read page 1 of this new ladder thoroughly
There is nothing about withdraws count as null or losses.

I am capable of waiting however long it takes but that isn't the point. The point is you are enforcing a nonexistent rule.

.. it doesnt count as a null... Use some logic:
The ways to get out of a duel are winning, lossing, or nulling.

Was the duel won? No.
Was the duel nulled due to time expiring? No.
Leaving you must forfeit the duel, aka losing, which you much wait 6 hours to challenge.

Logic is irrelevant. Amend the rules so it's clear to people withdrawal is defined as a loss.

Anyway good luck with your duels.

StriferZer0

Member

Posts: 12,050

Joined: May 21 2013

Gold: 580.00

#165

Feb 5 2015 10:16am

Quote (KungPeriodFu @ Feb 5 2015 10:03am)

You shouldn't be allowed to drop challenges once made should be set in stone till a duel dodge or null is done because it's kind of lame to hold someone up then withdraw. Even if it took a second to do so a challenge is a challenge especially on an all class ladder where you could drop challenge once another Is complete to avoid someone from behind and gain a more favorable matchup

Mstrforce

Member

Posts: 11,068

Joined: Apr 13 2005

Gold: 3,101.37

#166

Feb 5 2015 10:29am

If you withdraw your challenge, it's a forfeit... How's that not clear? What if you're opponent accepts your challenge and wants to get the duel done, you drop and expect there not to be a penalty? You held up the people below you who could have challenged you (or possibly your opponent as well), as well as holding up your opponent from challenging up. If you withdraw that's the same as saying the person who you challenged gets the win, thus you get a loss.

This isn't rocket science

LucAA

Member

Posts: 41,350

Joined: Apr 16 2008

Gold: 0.00

#167

Feb 5 2015 10:32am

You can reinstate his challenge to me if you'd like LOL

Kurtchack

Member

Posts: 11,911

Joined: Mar 30 2007

Gold: 25.00

Warn: 60%

#168

Feb 5 2015 10:34am

Quote (young2093 @ Feb 5 2015 12:32pm)

You can reinstate his challenge to me if you'd like LOL

LucAA

Member

Posts: 41,350

Joined: Apr 16 2008

Gold: 0.00

#169

Feb 5 2015 10:43am

I mean he literally held me up from challenging ahead just to drop the challenge. Not sure how he thinks that's ok.
"Logic is irrelevant" explains everything..

Mstrforce

Member

Posts: 11,068

Joined: Apr 13 2005

Gold: 3,101.37

#170

Feb 5 2015 10:46am

Quote (young2093 @ Feb 5 2015 12:43pm)

I mean he literally held me up from challenging ahead just to drop the challenge. Not sure how he thinks that's ok.
"Logic is irrelevant" explains everything..

That was my point.

Go Back To Legit Dueling Topic List