Quote (Meatyy @ Jul 1 2010 12:53am)

but it isn't the challenged persons fault? If the challenger truly wants to do the duel then they will make it work within 5 days, if the person challenged truly doesn't want it to work then they will truly be dogeing ofc, and dodge rule takes place

if challenged person tries to do it within 5 days, and person who challenged truly doesn't wanna duel then they can jus wait 5 days and auto win?

how is this fair?

Quote (LilNeko @ Jul 1 2010 12:54am)

agree.


it's challenged person fault mostly. 

it's not really fair..it's pretty much bm :/

Quote (JAYZONE @ Jul 1 2010 12:57am)

But if the person that was challenge requested for an extension, there is a chance that the duel will be nulled.
because of the request for an extention

Quote (JAYZONE @ Jun 30 2010 10:00pm)

http://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=39504244&p=298018202

Here it is.
And if i was that person you issued a challenge to.
I can post for an extension and i will likely get the challenge nulled.
Now i can also post in the thread stating i pm'd you on times you were off. and vice versa. because we both want the duel to happen but we ran out of time.
The duel is considered nulled.

Quote (LilNeko @ Jul 1 2010 01:01am)

A person that is challenged and have requested for a 48 hour extension and the duel does not occur, the duel is considerd "null" or "cancelled"


i was right. i know joe had time..to finsh hes match...

Quote (LilNeko @ Jul 1 2010 01:01am)

A person that is challenged and have requested for a 48 hour extension and the duel does not occur, the duel is considerd "null" or "cancelled"

Recap.
If you issue a challenge make sure you post in the ladder thread that you are waiting for the duel to happen.
IF YOU DONT, then the duel will be mark as "null" or "cancelled"




i was right. i know joe had time..to finsh hes match...it shouldve been cancelled or null'd.

Quote (JAYZONE @ Jun 30 2010 10:04pm)

and this is why the null or cancelled should be enforced.
Because this causes the person who issued the challenge have no chance

Quote (Meatyy @ Jun 30 2010 10:03pm)

well, looks like we got concrete evidence that a missruling occured, i think that a 48 hour grace period should be awarded where the duel should occur in, to right this ship and allow joe his chance to duel

Quote (LilNeko @ Jul 1 2010 01:05am)

agree~


ehh..little late for that. :\ he removed himself cuz of this.. i know i was right about it but i don't mind aruging or anything about it lol.

bruno thought he was right and steve well..he's getting old or didn't know what's going on

Quote (Meatyy @ Jun 30 2010 10:07pm)

imo bruno took the easy way out, once many people said it was 48 hours and there was still time left he should have manned up and dueled

Quote (SirSteve1 @ Jun 30 2010 08:55pm)

I distinctly remember having this discussion very early in ladder and extensions were to be 24 hours unless somebody specifically requested more time. I dont really feel like going back through 8K pages of mostly spam to find it but I know its there, so if /when it got changed to 48 hours it was without my knowledge.
but either way this could have all been avoided by mrdruman taking 10 seconds to post in thread saying they were having issues hooking up.
I really dont want to see him leave ladder over this, but sometimes shit like this happens, its only one spot on ladder if he's so confident of his zealot he should just fight for his spot back

Quote (Meatyy @ Jul 1 2010 01:07am)

imo bruno took the easy way out, once many people said it was 48 hours and there was still time left he should have manned up and dueled