Quote (SirSteve1 @ Mar 11 2010 08:37pm)

thats pretty much why I bought it I liked the premise but it was very inactive and most of the people that were active didnt "melee"
I have room for 100 people in that guild and there were like 90 in it when I first took over.
Alot of them got booted. I dont really care how many people I have in it I just want them to be active and at least try GM Melee
I turn people down every day that ask to join... you wouldnt believe how many "I have a SMiter" or "I have WW Barb" I get .. I always check peoples Char in game and track thier posts for a couple of days to make sure they arent Morons  before i let them in.

But anyway we are getting off topic here I just wanted to show how much the rules have evolved since the begining of the ladder

Quote (joshchx @ Apr 16 2008 10:31pm)

For one, You don`t use a coa.
raven/angelic combo >
3) Max blessed aim not sacrifice(passive ar bonus)

Quote (joshchx @ Aug 23 2008 11:38pm)

had one last lad then gave up cause melee dueling is boring imo.

ask anyone who has zealots in my guild. higher chance to hit>500dmg

Quote (SirSteve1 @ Mar 15 2010 12:02am)

This Challenge has been left on list for now. I have a real problem with people just forfieting their ranks on ladder I think it compromizes the Integrity of the Ladder when people dont "earn" their spots. I also think if you dont have time to complete your challenges you should not be on the Ladder.
However this is an Issue that comes up alot and it appears isn't going to go away so the other council members and myself are going to have to dicuss it.

Quote (dark-soul @ Mar 15 2010 12:31am)

I don't really like forfeits either but it kind of just punishes the challenger if they aren't aloud. I think forfeit should be allowed but it counts as a dodge. No point in really making the challenger wait the full 3 days when the challenged has no intention on doing the match. I also agree that people should be active if they're going to be on a ladder so this does punish them since they only get the 2 dodges before being removed. Not to mention that forfeits don't even make sense to me. I mean if someone can take the time to get on jsp they really can't be all that busy.

Quote (hengster @ Mar 15 2010 12:47am)

The last time we voted on the forfeiting result was a NO to allow forfeits, but forfeits will count as x1 Dodge. Imo the 3 days is not really a punishment but a time period to encourage the one being challenged to find 15 mins of their time to get the Challenge done instead of letting it rule as dodge after three days. If there are more complaints about the long 3 day wait we might have to do another vote soon

Anyway guys please use the suggestion page for further suggestions thanks! Link:http://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=39504244&f=147&o=100

Quote (scorpxxxx @ Mar 15 2010 01:22pm)

IT became 2 easy to just forfit on the old ladder

but it was nice for the challenger as they could rechallenge immediatly or get a auto doge if away from jsp over 3 days

If the 2x doge rule was a permenent thing and you dont get it removed on successfuly completing your next challenge but only after a length of time it would serve as further deterent not to forfit and to stay active.

I feel asking for extensions also holds up the ladder alot, its nice to be able to extend for people with life besides D2 but this should also be limited.

Quote (hengster @ Mar 15 2010 12:27am)

Point taken, extension can be abused easily to protect your spot, i.e. get your friend to challenge u and extend endlessly.

Currently the x1 dodge count will get removed once u complete a challenge successfully after a previous dodge, so far been working good

The forfeit rule will have to be voted again, since i suggested to allow forfeit and count it as a dodge x1 but it was rejected in last time's voting.

Quote (SirSteve1 @ Mar 15 2010 12:39am)

IMO its pretty stupid to outright forfiet a match anyway. If somebody knows they arent going to be able to duel they should just let  it ride out for the 3 days and take the dodge . Otherwise  if they forfiet somebody else could challenge them 5 minutes later and  what are they going to do ... fofiet again and be removed.

Quote (SirSteve1 @ Mar 15 2010 01:39pm)

IMO its pretty stupid to outright forfiet a match anyway. If somebody knows they arent going to be able to duel they should just let it ride out for the 3 days and take the dodge . Otherwise if they forfiet somebody else could challenge them 5 minutes later and what are they going to do ... forfiet again and be removed.

Quote (hengster @ Mar 15 2010 12:45am)

Maybe we should have a rule that says 2 forfeits and you are BANNED from the ladder, instead of just being removed.

Quote (dark-soul @ Mar 15 2010 01:40am)

Yeah I agree that it's pretty dumb. Again I just don't understand how someone can take the time to be on jsp but not have enough time to get on d2 and complete the match.