d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Sports Coliseum > Motor Sports & Cars > Evo Vs Sti Vs Rs Vs Mustang > Forever Battle
Prev1234567Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 13,703
Joined: Mar 30 2007
Gold: 0.00
Aug 1 2015 07:37am
http://jalopnik.com/2016-cadillac-cts-v-a-glorious-640-hp-exercise-in-over-1721258796

Check that 2016 Cadi out :drool:

This post was edited by bta44 on Aug 1 2015 07:38am
Member
Posts: 48,261
Joined: Aug 1 2008
Gold: 1,819.09
Aug 1 2015 08:22am
Quote (bta44 @ Aug 1 2015 09:37am)


And it's priced like the E63, M5, S7 etc. (the 640 HP CTS-V is other $85,000 before options) Cadillac hasn't had much luck convincing people their cars are worth that much yet, even if the raw performance matches the price tag. The focus on getting the raw power up also means Cadillac is lagging behind on two important things, transmission and steering/handling. They still use outdated, regular automatics, and there's a reason the car isn't competing with imports that have similar power but twice the MSRP (because those cars have DCTs and handle like a small sports car). Not sure how much the new one has changed, the reviews don't seem to say it has, but the last gen CTS V handled like the full-sized sedan it was.

Quote (bta44 @ Aug 1 2015 07:48am)
Wow awesome advice man, thanks. I cant drive the RS yet because it doesnt hit showrooms until spring 2016, plus there is a limited amount! I bet those cars are going to be very $$ and be snatched up quick. Plus I have learned not to buy brand new things in my past haha wait till patch/batch #2 come out


Ah yes I forgot. So it'll just be like the R, you have to order them because they won't be sitting in showrooms.

This post was edited by Caedus on Aug 1 2015 08:22am
Member
Posts: 8,671
Joined: Jul 9 2007
Gold: 11,961.01
Aug 1 2015 08:53am
Quote (bta44 @ Aug 1 2015 01:36pm)
Shit man I would love a Cadi... How much are they going for? I havent even looked because I know they are outrageous


Could easily get a used one under 40k. But it sounds like you want a 4 cyl that goes PSHHHHHHHH
Retired Moderator
Posts: 22,130
Joined: Nov 20 2006
Gold: 20.00
Trader: Trusted
Aug 1 2015 11:02am
Quote (bta44 @ Aug 1 2015 07:50am)
I still want to hit like 400+ WHP though no doubt. Which means replacing the full exhaust, headers, and maybe converting to e85. But Idk im no car expert, just getting into the scene



His dyno'd at like 348 or 349. I forget which
He was pissed he couldn't get that extra few to get him to 350+

Right at 350 its very fast. I don't see the need for much more then that
Member
Posts: 17,247
Joined: Oct 19 2007
Gold: 484.02
Aug 1 2015 11:26am
Quote (Caedus @ Aug 1 2015 09:22am)
And it's priced like the E63, M5, S7 etc. (the 640 HP CTS-V is other $85,000 before options) Cadillac hasn't had much luck convincing people their cars are worth that much yet, even if the raw performance matches the price tag. The focus on getting the raw power up also means Cadillac is lagging behind on two important things, transmission and steering/handling. They still use outdated, regular automatics, and there's a reason the car isn't competing with imports that have similar power but twice the MSRP (because those cars have DCTs and handle like a small sports car). Not sure how much the new one has changed, the reviews don't seem to say it has, but the last gen CTS V handled like the full-sized sedan it was.



Ah yes I forgot. So it'll just be like the R, you have to order them because they won't be sitting in showrooms.


Blah blah


Very little thought had to be devoted to adding power to the V. The engine already existed in the lineup. It was a decision that required a finger snap. GM has decided to forgo the expensive DCT setup for now. The new 8 speed auto is insane. You should read up on it a little
Member
Posts: 48,261
Joined: Aug 1 2008
Gold: 1,819.09
Aug 1 2015 12:02pm
Quote (FMX_89 @ Aug 1 2015 01:26pm)
Blah blah


Very little thought had to be devoted to adding power to the V. The engine already existed in the lineup. It was a decision that required a finger snap. GM has decided to forgo the expensive DCT setup for now. The new 8 speed auto is insane. You should read up on it a little


Certainly was not as simple as dropping a Corvette engine in the CTS V.

It's a still a traditional automatic in a car that is going to approach $100,000 with options. To attract the crowd Caddy wants to get to buy the CTS V, it needs a DCT. People who were already buying Caddy have been complaining that the prices have skyrocketed in recent years. How many of those people are willing to drop $85,000 at the very least? Not many. No, they want people who are looking at the E63, S6, M5, S7, etc. And those type of people you're going to have to really convince to buy an American car. The CTS V was selling about 5500 cars at its peak in 2011. It was down to about 2200 in 2014. And the car wasn't as expensive as it is now.

If GM wants to sell Caddys like the Germans, they've got to appeal to what the buyers of German cars are looking at. GM claimed the 8L90 shifted faster than the PDK couple years ago, but I don't see anything substantiated that claim since. It doesn't really matter if the car is as good, it matters if people will buy it. And it's going to be a tough sell. Caddy needs to start making a DCT, as the technology is poised to make all conventional automatics extinct. The future of automatics will likely be CVTs and DCTs.

This post was edited by Caedus on Aug 1 2015 12:03pm
Member
Posts: 18,699
Joined: Apr 24 2007
Gold: 0.00
Aug 1 2015 12:25pm
Quote (Caedus @ Aug 1 2015 06:02pm)
Certainly was not as simple as dropping a Corvette engine in the CTS V.

It's a still a traditional automatic in a car that is going to approach $100,000 with options. To attract the crowd Caddy wants to get to buy the CTS V, it needs a DCT. People who were already buying Caddy have been complaining that the prices have skyrocketed in recent years. How many of those people are willing to drop $85,000 at the very least? Not many. No, they want people who are looking at the E63, S6, M5, S7, etc. And those type of people you're going to have to really convince to buy an American car. The CTS V was selling about 5500 cars at its peak in 2011. It was down to about 2200 in 2014. And the car wasn't as expensive as it is now.

If GM wants to sell Caddys like the Germans, they've got to appeal to what the buyers of German cars are looking at. GM claimed the 8L90 shifted faster than the PDK couple years ago, but I don't see anything substantiated that claim since. It doesn't really matter if the car is as good, it matters if people will buy it. And it's going to be a tough sell. Caddy needs to start making a DCT, as the technology is poised to make all conventional automatics extinct. The future of automatics will likely be CVTs and DCTs.



Dual clutch transmission, don't get me wrong, is fun and I've always enjoyed driving it "except in toyotas, slowest shifting transmission ever...", but that 8l90 transmission is sick dude.. I got to ride in the ATS-V, and it shifts so fucking smooth, and it is SOOOO responsive... And when I say responsive, I literally am saying that there aren't very many people who are buying these categories of cars "as you listed" that can respond that fast to shifting.. The car knows more than you do when you drive that type of car... I personally feel that a strict DCT would destroy the line, and all the r&d they've done with the 8l90..

Make it an option MAYBE, but sorry like the Corvette market, the Cadillac market is hardly filled with auto enthusiasts.. More like middle-old aged men that want to have some fun.
Member
Posts: 17,247
Joined: Oct 19 2007
Gold: 484.02
Aug 1 2015 01:17pm
Quote (Caedus @ Aug 1 2015 01:02pm)
Certainly was not as simple as dropping a Corvette engine in the CTS V.

It's a still a traditional automatic in a car that is going to approach $100,000 with options. To attract the crowd Caddy wants to get to buy the CTS V, it needs a DCT. People who were already buying Caddy have been complaining that the prices have skyrocketed in recent years. How many of those people are willing to drop $85,000 at the very least? Not many. No, they want people who are looking at the E63, S6, M5, S7, etc. And those type of people you're going to have to really convince to buy an American car. The CTS V was selling about 5500 cars at its peak in 2011. It was down to about 2200 in 2014. And the car wasn't as expensive as it is now.

If GM wants to sell Caddys like the Germans, they've got to appeal to what the buyers of German cars are looking at. GM claimed the 8L90 shifted faster than the PDK couple years ago, but I don't see anything substantiated that claim since. It doesn't really matter if the car is as good, it matters if people will buy it. And it's going to be a tough sell. Caddy needs to start making a DCT, as the technology is poised to make all conventional automatics extinct. The future of automatics will likely be CVTs and DCTs.


What leads you to think it wasn't that easy? It is a modular engine system.

If people don't buy it because it doesn't have a DCT that is their fault. They should do a little more independent research and stop being sheeple.
Member
Posts: 48,261
Joined: Aug 1 2008
Gold: 1,819.09
Aug 1 2015 04:04pm
Quote (ozzyarmy3 @ Aug 1 2015 02:25pm)
Dual clutch transmission, don't get me wrong, is fun and I've always enjoyed driving it "except in toyotas, slowest shifting transmission ever...", but that 8l90 transmission is sick dude.. I got to ride in the ATS-V, and it shifts so fucking smooth, and it is SOOOO responsive... And when I say responsive, I literally am saying that there aren't very many people who are buying these categories of cars "as you listed" that can respond that fast to shifting.. The car knows more than you do when you drive that type of car... I personally feel that a strict DCT would destroy the line, and all the r&d they've done with the 8l90..

Make it an option MAYBE, but sorry like the Corvette market, the Cadillac market is hardly filled with auto enthusiasts.. More like middle-old aged men that want to have some fun.


Smooth sure, but that's the hall mark of auto tranny's. They're supposed to be smooth, I just don't see the point in investing so much money into technology that will all but be eliminated by CVTs and DCTs. I get that GM created a really good auto tranny, and even more kudos to them considering most automakers don't design their own transmissions. DCTs (especially the really goods one, PDK and DSG) already outperform automatics, and the technology is only going to get better. In fairness GM started designing 8I90 8-9 years ago before the DCT revolution in sports cars formally took place.

Quote (FMX_89 @ Aug 1 2015 03:17pm)
What leads you to think it wasn't that easy? It is a modular engine system.

If people don't buy it because it doesn't have a DCT that is their fault. They should do a little more independent research and stop being sheeple.


Because it's not that easy lol. Easy decision maybe but easy to do? Cadillac surely spent millions adjusting the Corvette engine to work with what they wanted to do with the CTS V.

It's not those peoples problem, it's Caddys problem. The cars are still very much American, yet they're aggressively targeting the German luxury market.

Member
Posts: 17,247
Joined: Oct 19 2007
Gold: 484.02
Aug 1 2015 04:58pm
Quote (Caedus @ Aug 1 2015 05:04pm)
Smooth sure, but that's the hall mark of auto tranny's. They're supposed to be smooth, I just don't see the point in investing so much money into technology that will all but be eliminated by CVTs and DCTs. I get that GM created a really good auto tranny, and even more kudos to them considering most automakers don't design their own transmissions. DCTs (especially the really goods one, PDK and DSG) already outperform automatics, and the technology is only going to get better. In fairness GM started designing 8I90 8-9 years ago before the DCT revolution in sports cars formally took place.



Because it's not that easy lol. Easy decision maybe but easy to do? Cadillac surely spent millions adjusting the Corvette engine to work with what they wanted to do with the CTS V.

It's not those peoples problem, it's Caddys problem. The cars are still very much American, yet they're aggressively targeting the German luxury market.


Do you think they built the CTS platform for the V6 and later decided to throw in a V8? No.

In the V2 the LSA is nothing more than an LS9 with a smaller blower and cast pistons. You are trying to fool the wrong guy. All LSX or LTX are interchangeable. The V was designed to carry them. Pretty derp worthy there.


Edit: did the guy at the dealer tell you it was an extensive redesign to make it work? Did he use buzzwords and sensationalism?

This post was edited by FMX_89 on Aug 1 2015 05:00pm
Go Back To Motor Sports & Cars Topic List
Prev1234567Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll