call wawanesa, they offered my the best coverage for the cheapest price. Geico screwed me for years and year due to an identity issue (father has same name and had accidents when error was figured out they refused to drop my rate or refund me any overages)

state farm

This. When something fucks up do you want to call the big guy or the discount 1-800 number? I will never understand people who cheap out on things like insurance. (not saying you, just in general)