Hey so your issue is that there are many different formats in mtga
like magic the gathering now
new cards can be played in old formats but old cards cannot be played in new formats
so there is
Standard: Last two years worth of cards, basically hearthstone.
Alchemy: MTGA only version with cards that have abilities you wouldnt be able to do in real life more or less. Like hearthstone abilities pumping your hand with +1+1 n shit
HIstoric: Historic is all cards in mtga
explorer: Explorer is the same as the paper version for Modern which is all sets after October 2012
commander: you get a commander card and can have 60 or 100 cards but no two cards can be the same except for basic lands. fun format
Your issue exactly is that you are trying to use old cards in a new deck. You can choose whatever setting you want before playing shown below:

you can choose between the ranked or not games and commander, and you can choose the format from the list then play.
If you want to make sure you only get cards that are cards that will work you do this:

when looking at cards select the triple meter button aka settings, then:

select the format you want at the top right,
you can also check the boxes as you go, for example to see all cards in mtga then make sure you check off the box for 'not collected' cards to show
This post was edited by Crunkt on Sep 23 2022 07:08pm