d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Guild Chat & Recruiting > Melee And Friends Guild Chat And Recruiting > Includes Are East Ladder Melee Ladder
Prev1519520521522523739Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 36,253
Joined: Mar 24 2008
Gold: 17,000.00
Nov 29 2009 11:52pm
Quote (hsc420 @ Nov 29 2009 05:56pm)
"Thou shall not buy an item out from under a fellow guildie"


Again Steve, imma have to request this gets written into charter. Maybe vote onit? I think once a guild member has bidded on something they have first right, and should not have to worry about getting into a bidding war with a guild mate.


I happen to agree I make it a point not to outbid guildies and i find it annoying when they do it to me ...
but there are exceptions to everything.. If its some random runeword/unique/charm you shoudl just move on and find another one... but in the case of some GfG Rare/ Perf item you really need. I dont think it would be fair to say you cant bid on it ... as long as it remained GM and respectful
Member
Posts: 9,502
Joined: Aug 13 2008
Gold: 127.00
Nov 30 2009 12:01am
Quote (SirSteve1 @ Nov 30 2009 12:52am)
I happen to agree I make it a point not to outbid guildies and i find it annoying when they do it to me ...
but there are exceptions to everything.. If its some random runeword/unique/charm you shoudl just move on and find another one... but in the case of some GfG Rare/ Perf item you really need. I dont think it would be fair to say you cant bid on it ... as long as it remained GM and respectful


vouch!
Member
Posts: 20,153
Joined: Oct 15 2006
Gold: 0.01
Nov 30 2009 12:13am
Quote (SirSteve1 @ Nov 29 2009 11:52pm)
I happen to agree I make it a point not to outbid guildies and i find it annoying when they do it to me ...
but there are exceptions to everything.. If its some random  runeword/unique/charm you shoudl just move on and find another one... but in the  case of some GfG Rare/ Perf item you really need. I dont think it would be fair to say you cant  bid on it ... as long as it remained GM and respectful


amen on that sir
I think trivial items are one thing but if it is an item you have been iso or will USE I don't think it should be considered bm to bid against a guildy.
But if you are just bidding to make profit from resell or it is something like a SC or torch that is commonly up then yeah that is understandable.

But just because someone posted first does not mean they should get it over other guildies, say for instance guildya bids on 20/15/15 gloves for 500 but is only bidding because he wants to resell them for 1500 and guildyb wants to bid 1000 to use them but sees guildya already bid 500... not fair at all for b to pass up the item.
Member
Posts: 17,789
Joined: Aug 16 2008
Gold: 260.00
Nov 30 2009 12:30am
I dont dodge -.-

Member
Posts: 3,276
Joined: Feb 15 2009
Gold: 3.06
Nov 30 2009 12:54am
Quote (iskandar09 @ Nov 30 2009 01:30am)
I dont dodge -.-

http://i538.photobucket.com/albums/ff350/joeiskandar/ffff.jpg


owned
Member
Posts: 28,130
Joined: Jun 6 2006
Gold: 1.00
Nov 30 2009 03:32am
Quote (hsc420 @ Nov 29 2009 04:56pm)
"Thou shall not buy an item out from under a fellow guildie"


Again Steve, imma have to request this gets written into charter. Maybe vote onit? I think once a guild member has bidded on something they have first right, and should not have to worry about getting into a bidding war with a guild mate.


somehow i think i know what this pertains 2.

/agreed.
Member
Posts: 17,544
Joined: Aug 28 2005
Gold: 1.00
Nov 30 2009 07:40am
yo any1 needing a better alma, shoot me a pm

2/60/68/198 alma, bryan (hsc420) gave me a better one soo ill pass it down as long as they arent gonna just resell it
Member
Posts: 9,502
Joined: Aug 13 2008
Gold: 127.00
Nov 30 2009 07:51am
Quote (Krt_eclipse @ Nov 30 2009 08:40am)
yo any1 needing a better alma, shoot me a pm

2/60/68/198 alma, bryan (hsc420) gave me a better one soo ill pass it down as long as they arent gonna just resell it


ill let ya know about this but im not sure how good/bad mine is... ill check in a few
Member
Posts: 7,173
Joined: Mar 28 2007
Gold: 1,011.00
Nov 30 2009 08:26am
Quote (SirSteve1 @ Nov 30 2009 01:52am)
I happen to agree I make it a point not to outbid guildies and i find it annoying when they do it to me ...
but there are exceptions to everything.. If its some random runeword/unique/charm you shoudl just move on and find another one... but in the case of some GfG Rare/ Perf item you really need. I dont think it would be fair to say you cant bid on it ... as long as it remained GM and respectful


I glad you agree to a certain extent. But I don't think it a question of being fair, it a question of respect.

Quote (bones0187 @ Nov 30 2009 02:13am)
amen on that sir
I think trivial items are one thing but if it is an item you have been iso or will USE I don't think it should be considered bm to bid against a guildy.
But if you are just bidding to make profit from resell or it is something like a SC or torch that is commonly up then yeah that is understandable.

But just because someone posted first does not mean they should get it over other guildies, say for instance guildya bids on 20/15/15 gloves for 500 but is only bidding because he wants to resell them for 1500 and guildyb wants to bid 1000 to use them but sees guildya already bid 500... not fair at all for b to pass up the item.


thats when a simple pm comes in handy " do you really need them because ive been looking forever" and any honorable guildie would let the other buy out of need not profit.

Quote (Conc @ Nov 30 2009 05:32am)
somehow i think i know what this pertains 2.

/agreed.


I don't really know what happened but I think it was similar :o , it has happened to me before as well Chris and I almost booted the guild member but stupid me asked Steve first! I should have just booted him. :D

Anyway if you don't want to vote on it its cool, but I think we should.
Member
Posts: 17,544
Joined: Aug 28 2005
Gold: 1.00
Nov 30 2009 08:29am
hope that lma helps ya jj

dont think i outbidded a guildie, so i dont know what the above is about

btw i now have jj's old alma 53/61/187 or something if another guildie needs

This post was edited by Krt_eclipse on Nov 30 2009 08:35am
Go Back To Guild Chat & Recruiting Topic List
Prev1519520521522523739Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll