d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Other Games > Archived Games > Heroes of Newerth > Determining Tier 1 Picks From Tier 2 > Debate On Which Heroes Are Fp Material
Prev1234Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 16,993
Joined: Sep 18 2010
Gold: 28,044.60
Mar 4 2011 11:52am
Quote (dude150 @ Mar 4 2011 06:47pm)
basically what smacktrickz said
in terms of disables, DW really has nothing useful when you're in a team fight, whereas pebbles can use his chuck creatively and has an AoE stun
and yeah, he's pretty much just a herp derp hero
(edit: blood hunter as well, many people lose a lane because they don't know how to stop a blood hunter who is just ignoring enemy hero presence and last hitting creeps)
you can't carry any games with him, just stomp pubs
same deal with thunderbringer, doesn't take much to get chalice/ring/bottle/whatever and spam bolts from level 5 and onward
i see many people who don't know how to deal with it and shit
like hags that will keep returning to the lane to get insta gib combo'd by a tb instead of moving around or doing whatever it takes to minimize tb's effectiveness

it also is no where near as simple as hellflower and gg to doc
most repulsors get hellflower as a part of his build, and ulting in + hellflowering the guy with the hellflower completely solves that problem
etc etc etc
imo, repulsor is definitely one of the hardest heroes to stop once he has his nullstone/hellflower/sheep/harkon's compared to most agility carries with the same amount of farm
his infinite mobility definitely puts him over the heroes you stated


Y

4 User(s) are reading this topic (0 Guests and 0 Anonymous): sMACKTRiCKz, UndeadGad, dude150, IgNiTe

HELLO MR PESTILENCE
Member
Posts: 48,520
Joined: Mar 17 2006
Gold: 207,463.50
Mar 4 2011 12:04pm
tier 1
andro, strong stun, insane carry boosting ability, and insane initiate/save, can easily be ran in a standard 2 man lane or a trilane or even roam, even decent for pushing
hb, all he need is level 6 to start fucking the game up, strong ulti for initiate/counter initiate and can also be used as pushing tool
dr, a mid hero which can beat alot of heroes, pebbles/devo/dw which are known to fucking pretty much anything mid will get so stomped by a decent dr it's not even funny, not to mention dr is the best carry ingame
myrmidon, a support with x2 stuns no other support have such a high laning presence from ability
bomb, fits with any lineup, global ulti, good anti trilane, insanely strong solo mid
tb, pretty much the same as bomb all though i'd say he is weaker than bomb mid, but his ulti is a sick initiate/counter initiate tool, like if they have more than 1 pk and you ulti straight after their first hero blink in, he stands there alone for 3 seconds getting murdured by your team
bubbles, strong solo mid / solo longlane hero, insane surviveability, sick initiate/gank potencial
chipper, strong mid hero but can also be used as support, high burst damage synergize pretty good with lots of heroes
pharaoh, well wall of mummies is pretty much the anti melee carry spell of the game and it also fucks up teamfights, not to mention he is the best initiator ingame and can solo longlane pretty much without a problem
witch, synergize with any team you make overall good support/mid hero

all these heroes are worthy firstpicks because these heroes can synergize from almost any pick,

Quote (sMACKTRiCKz @ 4 Mar 2011 18:52)
Y

4 User(s) are reading this topic (0 Guests and 0 Anonymous): sMACKTRiCKz, UndeadGad, dude150, IgNiTe

HELLO MR PESTILENCE


hilo mister karma

This post was edited by UndeadGad on Mar 4 2011 12:04pm
Member
Posts: 315
Joined: Mar 2 2011
Gold: 5.00
Mar 4 2011 03:14pm
You've convinced me on the Deadwood, good reasoning. As for TB though, I see him in competitive play a lot and banned a lot. My play level is 1900+ so I hope that gives me some credibility ^^
So if you were to play against yourself DW versus Pebbles, do you think yourself would win as pebbles or DW? I think DW would definitely win, so maybe DW ran against melee solo mid is very effective because you gain something; leverage. So yes his cd's seem long, stun not really a stun so less team efficient as pebbles so if played by a REALLY good good player, pebbles > DW in overall sense, but in the laning phase what do you guys think?

Cheers
-JaySongs
Member
Posts: 16,993
Joined: Sep 18 2010
Gold: 28,044.60
Mar 4 2011 03:25pm
Quote (JaySongs @ Mar 4 2011 10:14pm)
You've convinced me on the Deadwood, good reasoning. As for TB though, I see him in competitive play a lot and banned a lot. My play level is 1900+ so I hope that gives me some credibility ^^
So if you were to play against yourself DW versus Pebbles, do you think yourself would win as pebbles or DW? I think DW would definitely win, so maybe DW ran against melee solo mid is very effective because you gain something; leverage. So yes his cd's seem long, stun not really a stun so less team efficient as pebbles so if played by a REALLY good good player, pebbles > DW in overall sense, but in the laning phase what do you guys think?

Cheers
-JaySongs


TB is definitely a top tier hero. Against trilanes, which any competent team runs nowadays, he can get to level 7 and burst down the enemy trilane heroes who would be level 3 or 4 at best at that time.

As for DW vs Pebb mid, technically DW should win, but it all comes down to skill. The -armor from grasp totally crushes Pebbles as it gives him negative armor. However, the burst from Pebbles can hurt a DW quite alot, especially if Pebbles has rune control and DW is unable to stay at 100% all the time. Overall, I think the matchup could go either way depending on whose team has better support that can help their mid heroes with rune control. If I were running a Pebbles mid and saw a DW counterpick however, I would pick up a nymph or glacius or witch or any other high range harass support hero and send him mid with Pebbles to just keep DW completely shutdown. DW doesn't have as good farm ability as pebbles and if he gets gimped early he's almost useless. Running him is pretty high risk, and the reward isn't as high as running something more reliable such as a pebbles or even chipper
Member
Posts: 315
Joined: Mar 2 2011
Gold: 5.00
Mar 4 2011 03:30pm
Okay thanks for the explanation. I think chipper is tier 1 pick for sure. I mean a bit bias after seeing chu play him in the finals, but his magic armor shield seems actually kind of OP if used correctly. Storm spirits old Magic barrier, good times.
Also, you have to keep in consideration, but running another hero mid, you'd need another hero on bottom, and picks would really have to work out for you. Are there no competitive games with DW in it? I'm sure, if match up is picked right, he can be very viable for the team. Just not as efficient as pebbles in most cases.

Cheers
-JaySongs
Member
Posts: 16,993
Joined: Sep 18 2010
Gold: 28,044.60
Mar 4 2011 03:37pm
Quote (JaySongs @ Mar 4 2011 10:30pm)
Okay thanks for the explanation. I think chipper is tier 1 pick for sure. I mean a bit bias after seeing chu play him in the finals, but his magic armor shield seems actually kind of OP if used correctly. Storm spirits old Magic barrier, good times.
Also, you have to keep in consideration, but running another hero mid, you'd need another hero on bottom, and picks would really have to work out for you. Are there no competitive games with DW in it? I'm sure, if match up is picked right, he can be very viable for the team. Just not as efficient as pebbles in most cases.

Cheers
-JaySongs


Yeah Chipper is an amazing hero overall, the amount of damage he puts out if played right is ridiculous.

As for competitive DW, I've only seen him run in a trilane before. The goal was obviously to get him an early PK. The trilane kind of failed though. DW's grasp is pretty worthless at a low lvl in a trilane, since all it does is stop people from moving, not from casting spells and attacking. On top of that, with trilane DW you need a very long time to get level 6, which is the point at which you become useful. Of course, with good play and ganks from mid, you could trilane DW and get him a fast pkey and some levels and he might even take over the game. The problem is however, matched up against a conventional trilane such as behemoth / myrmi / flint, you would have absolutely no chance whatsoever. On top of that, if you ran into a 1v3 situation, getting farm on a DW would be nowhere near as useful as the farm that your enemy team's carry would be getting in their trilane. Overall, DW is a hero that relies so much on bad play from enemies and an easy early game to dominate. This is pretty common in pubs, but in high-level people will counter it almost effortlessly, making the hero fairly useless compared to his many substitutes

This post was edited by sMACKTRiCKz on Mar 4 2011 03:37pm
Member
Posts: 315
Joined: Mar 2 2011
Gold: 5.00
Mar 4 2011 03:51pm
This makes me sad because it reminds me of how much competitive HoN doesn't live up to competitive DotA. In DotA, you have SEA players who do unconventional builds that dominate and give them an edge because players haven't practiced against a unique lineup where as in HoN, I feel like, some heroes are just never attempted to be played in competitive games. No one is daring enough to create builds that seem awful at first but with thought into it, is extremely overpowered against certain lineups. If you have any unconventional replays of HoN where a team does a unique build against a good team, please link me (:

Cheers
-JaySongs
Member
Posts: 6,777
Joined: Jun 30 2008
Gold: 1,110.60
Mar 4 2011 03:53pm
Quote (JaySongs @ Mar 4 2011 05:14pm)
You've convinced me on the Deadwood, good reasoning. As for TB though, I see him in competitive play a lot and banned a lot. My play level is 1900+ so I hope that gives me some credibility ^^
So if you were to play against yourself DW versus Pebbles, do you think yourself would win as pebbles or DW? I think DW would definitely win, so maybe DW ran against melee solo mid is very effective because you gain something; leverage. So yes his cd's seem long, stun not really a stun so less team efficient as pebbles so if played by a REALLY good good player, pebbles > DW in overall sense, but in the laning phase what do you guys think?

Cheers
-JaySongs


i didn't say he wasn't a good hero, just saying he's one that many people seem to not know how to deal with, and is one with a relatively low skill curve (not ceiling)
imo, i'd take the pebbles over the DW in a heartbeat
assuming no ganks and a strict 1v1 lane situation, the only way the DW could come close to killing pebbles is by initiating with punch after chipping some health off him
with grasp first, pebbles can wait for the wind up on willowmaker, or before (depends how far away when grasp was casted, etc) and either avalanche and chuck DW to potentially kill him, or if low enough just stun and then chuck him to his ranged creep and allow some breathing space

i just dislike DW because of how asymptotic his effectiveness curve is
if you're with a competent team, i can see it working out
regardless of the team, though, there are much better options out there imo

This post was edited by dude150 on Mar 4 2011 03:54pm
Member
Posts: 31,880
Joined: Dec 1 2010
Gold: 0.69
Mar 4 2011 05:14pm
Sadly i would have to say peb wpuld beat DW 90% of the time if both players are decent enough to land grips and stuns. Since dw has to either be close enough to initate with his ult or get pebs with his stun down. But theres a high chance that peb will just chuck dw away when hes within range. While the peb could just wait out the grasp and counter with a combo to make dw either play defensively or stop him competely. If peb has total rune control it will force dw to play defensively and make sure he has 75% or more hp. Both players can have rune control so that once again makes it come down to skill on how and when to use stuns/grasp to have rune control. Imho I say peb would win hands down against a dw.
Member
Posts: 315
Joined: Mar 2 2011
Gold: 5.00
Mar 4 2011 06:18pm
Thanks for the input Lazyakira. I forgot that DW's chance to kill is much less likely than pebbles since pebbles could just immediately counter by stunning or tossing DW back when he tries for a punch.

Cheers
-JaySongs
Go Back To Heroes of Newerth Topic List
Prev1234Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll