d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Christian Fellowship > A Querie About Excommunication
Closed New Topic
Member
Posts: 2,761
Joined: Oct 24 2011
Gold: 47.00
Apr 18 2012 12:25pm
If you're excommunicated from the church, christian church. Can you have a funeral or last rites?
Imo, if you couldn't have last rites that's pretty fucked up.

Thanks in advance
Member
Posts: 17,713
Joined: Apr 8 2008
Gold: 0.00
Apr 18 2012 02:23pm
Quote (Muppers @ Apr 18 2012 02:25pm)
If you're excommunicated from the church, christian church. Can you have a funeral or last rites?
Imo, if you couldn't have last rites that's pretty fucked up.

Thanks in advance


First off Last rights is mainly used in the Catholic beliefs, not Christian. Despite what is said Christian and Catholic beliefs differ (although Catholics can be saved).

It was a nice attempt at a troll though, try harder next time, don't give up buddy!

This post was edited by Silenced_Matrix on Apr 18 2012 02:28pm
Member
Posts: 52,315
Joined: Mar 25 2007
Gold: 6,487.40
Apr 18 2012 04:36pm
Quote (Muppers @ 18 Apr 2012 13:25)
If you're excommunicated from the church, christian church. Can you have a funeral or last rites?
Imo, if you couldn't have last rites that's pretty fucked up.

Thanks in advance



No you can't but its only institutional. God is above the institution so who cares ?
Member
Posts: 7,038
Joined: Mar 23 2008
Gold: 46,915.91
Apr 30 2012 03:10pm
Quote (Silenced_Matrix @ Apr 18 2012 04:23pm)
First off Last rights is mainly used in the Catholic beliefs, not Christian.  Despite what is said Christian and Catholic beliefs differ (although Catholics can be saved).

It was a nice attempt at a troll though, try harder next time, don't give up buddy!


i understand the difference between Catholics and say baptist and Pentecostal and other christian groups

but dont understand why they are not considered christian
Member
Posts: 2,311
Joined: Dec 19 2006
Gold: 40.00
May 12 2012 01:04pm
Quote (Silenced_Matrix @ Apr 18 2012 03:23pm)
First off Last rights is mainly used in the Catholic beliefs, not Christian.  Despite what is said Christian and Catholic beliefs differ (although Catholics can be saved).

It was a nice attempt at a troll though, try harder next time, don't give up buddy!


This post makes you seem both arrogant and damning. The word you were grasping for was "Protestant." It's either Catholic or Protestant. Both belong to Christianity. It's really hard to take people seriously when they have no idea whatsoever about their own belief.

I suspect atheists and agnostics use examples like you in in defense of their beliefs. I don't blame them.

To answer the OP, this is one is of the problems dogmatic institutions encounter. The Catholic Church, for example, if they had excommunicated you (not sure how frequently this happens any more) then no, you would be denied the sacrament of Last Rites (or Anointing of the Sick) as it's sometimes called. The idea is that to have been cast out of the Faith the Church have assumed you've turned your back on God, and they rightly, turn their back on you.

I think most people in modern civilization, except for the born-again crusaders like the one I quoted, generally except that contrition is the way to Salvation. In other words, should you reconcile your sins with Gods, you shall be absolved as was promised by Christ.

Hope that helps.
Member
Posts: 17,713
Joined: Apr 8 2008
Gold: 0.00
May 15 2012 10:54pm
Quote (Ghosts_Lament @ May 12 2012 03:04pm)
This post makes you seem both arrogant and damning. The word you were grasping for was "Protestant." It's either Catholic or Protestant. Both belong to Christianity. It's really hard to take people seriously when they have no idea whatsoever about their own belief.

I suspect atheists and agnostics use examples like you in in defense of their beliefs. I don't blame them.

To answer the OP, this is one is of the problems dogmatic institutions encounter. The Catholic Church, for example, if they had excommunicated you (not sure how frequently this happens any more) then no, you would be denied the sacrament of Last Rites (or Anointing of the Sick) as it's sometimes called. The idea is that to have been cast out of the Faith the Church have assumed you've turned your back on God, and they rightly, turn their back on you.

I think most people in modern civilization, except for the born-again crusaders like the one I quoted, generally except that contrition is the way to Salvation. In other words, should you reconcile your sins with Gods, you shall be absolved as was promised by Christ. 

Hope that helps.


Christian
Noun:
A person who has received Christian baptism or is a believer in Jesus Christ and his teachings.

Most Catholics are not as most would call "saved". They have a different belief system although they do not deny Jesus Christ, most put their faith in works and ritualism.

Now the OP was trolling, notice he forgot he even made this post. Second, if my post was "condemning", my apologies.

Thanks though :)
Member
Posts: 4,265
Joined: Jan 1 2009
Gold: Locked
Trader: Scammer
May 16 2012 01:36am
nope
Go Back To Christian Fellowship Topic List
Closed New Topic