d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Christian Fellowship > Critique On A New Page I Added Christian Site
Prev1234Next
Add Reply New Topic
Admin
Posts: 24,837
Joined: Sep 24 2002
Gold: 43,367.72
Trader: Trusted
Mar 17 2012 08:27am
According to John MacArthur regarding Hebrews 6:6 -

"There is no possibility of these verses referring to losing salvation. Many Scripture passages make unmistakably clear that salvation is eternal (cf. Jn 10:27-29; Ro 8:35,38,39; Php 1:6; 1Pe 1:4,5). Those who want to make this verse mean that believers can lose salvation will have to admit that it would then also says that one could never get it back again."

It has much more proceeding content before this line that talks about the proceeding verses. A quick summary is that in order for this scenario to be true of a person, they must already have full knowledge and not be able to learn anything further, and if they then turn away, they are siding with the enemy, and nothing can bring them back, because they have nothing further to learn or experience and have already made their choice. So, if you turn away and come back, it is because you have experienced or learned something new, which makes these verses not applicable to you.

I do stand corrected regarding maturity not having any bearing on this, as it obviously does, but I think the key distinction is that one who turns away in this fashion literally cannot come back, as there is nothing further for them to experience or learn that is new to "change their mind", so it's not a matter of one trying, but a matter of them not possibly being able to. (Hence the impossible part).
Member
Posts: 17,713
Joined: Apr 8 2008
Gold: 0.00
Mar 17 2012 10:39am
Quote (njaguar @ Mar 17 2012 10:27am)
According to John MacArthur regarding Hebrews 6:6 -

"There is no possibility of these verses referring to losing salvation. Many Scripture passages make unmistakably clear that salvation is eternal (cf. Jn 10:27-29; Ro 8:35,38,39; Php 1:6; 1Pe 1:4,5). Those who want to make this verse mean that believers can lose salvation will have to admit that it would then also says that one could never get it back again."

It has much more proceeding content before this line that talks about the proceeding verses. A quick summary is that in order for this scenario to be true of a person, they must already have full knowledge and not be able to learn anything further, and if they then turn away, they are siding with the enemy, and nothing can bring them back, because they have nothing further to learn or experience and have already made their choice. So, if you turn away and come back, it is because you have experienced or learned something new, which makes these verses not applicable to you.

I do stand corrected regarding maturity not having any bearing on this, as it obviously does, but I think the key distinction is that one who turns away in this fashion literally cannot come back, as there is nothing further for them to experience or learn that is new to "change their mind", so it's not a matter of one trying, but a matter of them not possibly being able to. (Hence the impossible part).


First off, I didn't mean to point you out specifically about not wanting to research or anything, cause I don't know how you go about it. I was just stating in general (I am just as guilty).

We should let Holy Spirit guide us to what scripture means as well. (this also means instead of taking my word you should pray on it yourself).

It does say you could never get it back again, there is 1 unforgivable sin (do you agree on that?) (impossible= unforgivable). The proceeding verses are just showing how mature the Christian must be (blasphemy is not a task that is easily said or done, like I said the Christian is very mature!

But to me the Bible states 1 unforgivable sin, impossible=unpardonable (unforgivable). I actually talked this over with a pastor in Ghana I met and he said he never knew Christians thought that the unforgivable sin was something a non-Christian can commit. Every google search proves otherwise it seems but I feel if we pray and ask the Holy Spirit he would explain anything we are in question to. :)

I'm not trying to convert your belief, as it has no bearing on me or you going to heaven (I don't know if I'll ever reach that maturity although it would be awesome and I hope I do!)

This post was edited by Silenced_Matrix on Mar 17 2012 10:39am
Admin
Posts: 24,837
Joined: Sep 24 2002
Gold: 43,367.72
Trader: Trusted
Mar 17 2012 12:21pm
Quote (Silenced_Matrix @ 17 Mar 2012 11:39)
First off, I didn't mean to point you out specifically about not wanting to research or anything, cause I don't know how you go about it. I was just stating in general (I am just as guilty).

We should let Holy Spirit guide us to what scripture means as well. (this also means instead of taking my word you should pray on it yourself).

It does say you could never get it back again, there is 1 unforgivable sin (do you agree on that?) (impossible= unforgivable). The proceeding verses are just showing how mature the Christian must be (blasphemy is not a task that is easily said or done, like I said the Christian is very mature!

But to me the Bible states 1 unforgivable sin, impossible=unpardonable (unforgivable). I actually talked this over with a pastor in Ghana I met and he said he never knew Christians thought that the unforgivable sin was something a non-Christian can commit. Every google search proves otherwise it seems but I feel if we pray and ask the Holy Spirit he would explain anything we are in question to. :)

I'm not trying to convert your belief, as it has no bearing on me or you going to heaven (I don't know if I'll ever reach that maturity although it would be awesome and I hope I do!)


Do not conflate impossible with unforgivable. Impossible in this context refers to the impossibility of a mature Christian who turned away from returning, because there is nothing more for them to return to, they have experienced everything that might sway them, and learned all there is to know, yet they still decided to side with the enemy. That is what impossible in those verses means.

Most likely the blasphemy of the Holy Spirit is tied to this, that only a complete mature Christian could commit this sin. But that's another debatable subject as well.
Member
Posts: 9,764
Joined: Oct 9 2010
Gold: 125.02
Mar 17 2012 12:27pm
Quote (njaguar @ Mar 17 2012 11:21am)
Do not conflate impossible with unforgivable. Impossible in this context refers to the impossibility of a mature Christian who turned away from returning, because there is nothing more for them to return to, they have experienced everything that might sway them, and learned all there is to know, yet they still decided to side with the enemy. That is what impossible in those verses means.

Most likely the blasphemy of the Holy Spirit is tied to this, that only a complete mature Christian could commit this sin. But that's another debatable subject as well.


Most biblical scholars i've heard conclude that blasphemy of the holy spirit is an ongoing process by the unbeliever who will never be saved.
Member
Posts: 17,713
Joined: Apr 8 2008
Gold: 0.00
Mar 17 2012 12:27pm
Quote (njaguar @ Mar 17 2012 02:21pm)
Do not conflate impossible with unforgivable. Impossible in this context refers to the impossibility of a mature Christian who turned away from returning, because there is nothing more for them to return to, they have experienced everything that might sway them, and learned all there is to know, yet they still decided to side with the enemy. That is what impossible in those verses means.

Most likely the blasphemy of the Holy Spirit is tied to this, that only a complete mature Christian could commit this sin. But that's another debatable subject as well.


The Bible promises us that no matter what we do (as long as it isn't blasphemy) that we can be forgiven. Therefore, if it is impossible for one to come back, is has to be the unforgivable sin, if not they could come back to Christ.

This post was edited by Silenced_Matrix on Mar 17 2012 12:28pm
Member
Posts: 9,764
Joined: Oct 9 2010
Gold: 125.02
Mar 17 2012 02:51pm
Quote (Silenced_Matrix @ Mar 17 2012 11:27am)
The Bible promises us that no matter what we do (as long as it isn't blasphemy) that we can be forgiven. Therefore, if it is impossible for one to come back, is has to be the unforgivable sin, if not they could come back to Christ.


You shouldn't have to come back to Christ imo. Once you're saved, you're saved.

There should be something that happens at the moment of salvation.
Member
Posts: 17,713
Joined: Apr 8 2008
Gold: 0.00
Mar 17 2012 05:21pm
Quote (Torm1 @ Mar 17 2012 04:51pm)
You shouldn't have to come back to Christ imo. Once you're saved, you're saved.

There should be something that happens at the moment of salvation.


Quote (Torm1 @ Mar 17 2012 02:27pm)
Most biblical scholars i've heard conclude that blasphemy of the holy spirit is an ongoing process by the unbeliever who will never be saved.


Pray and ask the holy spirit to guide you, go read my "article" on the previous page.
Member
Posts: 54,033
Joined: Jun 1 2010
Gold: 1.74
Mar 20 2012 12:31pm
Quote (Silenced_Matrix @ 14 Mar 2012 20:33)
Read mine and contemplate it. No one EVER becomes sinless, everyone sins. Do you get to a point where you barely sin? I'm sure you do.  The flesh is always trying to take over, the way we create the opposite of that is by spending time with God, reading the Bible, ect. Your right we are not born again, it only happens once, and you can sin a ton (like I did and still be saved), but if you become a mature Christian and lose your salvation (blasphemy) you can not become saved again. Salvation is a one time thing, and if you lose it, it is impossible to regain.


It never says that getting saved is a one time deal, as it also doesn't say that once you saved you forever are, but from what Jesus says it seems that you are.
Member
Posts: 17,713
Joined: Apr 8 2008
Gold: 0.00
Mar 20 2012 05:38pm
Quote (ChrisKz @ Mar 20 2012 02:31pm)
It never says that getting saved is a one time deal, as it also doesn't say that once you saved you forever are, but from what Jesus says it seems that you are.


Quote (Torm1 @ Mar 17 2012 04:51pm)
You shouldn't have to come back to Christ imo. Once you're saved, you're saved.

There should be something that happens at the moment of salvation.


So you think Hebrews 6:4 is a lie, and accidentally placed in scripture bro? Makes it quite clear to me. Nonetheless, let's just agree to disagree. Once saved always saved doctrine vs the opposite isn't something worth debating over cause its going no where. God Bless all! :)
Member
Posts: 576
Joined: Mar 21 2012
Gold: 0.00
Mar 22 2012 07:48am
Quote (Dune1 @ Mar 14 2012 10:44am)
Sinner's prayer and "once saved always saved" in the same article?! You must be baptist... :P

Looks good overall! Nice work


very nice, god bless you my son
Go Back To Christian Fellowship Topic List
Prev1234Next
Add Reply New Topic