d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Christian Fellowship > A Question For Christians > I'm Catholic...
Prev123Next
Add Reply New Topic
Member
Posts: 6,689
Joined: Sep 13 2008
Gold: 156.00
Apr 29 2011 08:41am
ok, here is somthing i never had an answer to...

at the last super, when jesus broke the bread, and served the wine/blood he said

"do this in memory of me"
catholics do why dont christians? seems simply put to me, but is there a different way christians inturpert this?
Retired Moderator
Posts: 10,292
Joined: Jun 5 2003
Gold: 35.00
Trader: Trusted
Apr 29 2011 09:05am
Quote (DViolent @ Apr 29 2011 09:41am)
ok, here is somthing i never had an answer to...

at the last super, when jesus broke the bread, and served the wine/blood he said

"do this in memory of me"
catholics do why dont christians? seems simply put to me, but is there a different way christians inturpert this?


I've been to several evangelical churches where they eat bread and drink wine as part of the service. The difference is that Catholics believe in transubstantiation.
Member
Posts: 32,093
Joined: Oct 11 2008
Gold: 18.00
Apr 29 2011 10:09am
Quote (DViolent @ Apr 29 2011 10:41am)
ok, here is somthing i never had an answer to...

at the last super, when jesus broke the bread, and served the wine/blood he said

"do this in memory of me"
catholics do why dont christians? seems simply put to me, but is there a different way christians inturpert this?


Not all churchs do, I go to a non-denominational church and we still do it.

its not only catholics that do it though.
Member
Posts: 9,764
Joined: Oct 9 2010
Gold: 125.02
Apr 29 2011 01:19pm
Quote (darkfire @ Apr 29 2011 08:05am)
I've been to several evangelical churches where they eat bread and drink wine as part of the service. The difference is that Catholics believe in transubstantiation.


Exactly. Christians do the bread/wine too, but see it as a symbol of remembrance, rather than it actually turning into actual physical flesh and blood when you consume it. Catholicism is more of a "religion" with rituals, etc...

This post was edited by Torm1 on Apr 29 2011 01:19pm
Member
Posts: 1,236
Joined: Jan 3 2010
Gold: 0.01
May 2 2011 10:36am
Quote (DViolent @ Apr 26 2011 03:41pm)
do christians have prayers?

or is it more like, make it up has you go kinda thing?


i mean no disrespect by this at all btw....


i'm just saying because i'll say an our father before i eat, and my christian friends never join me, idk if its because they dont know it or what but ya....

also i went to a catholic school for 8 years so most prayers come to me naturally and when i say them they seem to have more meaning everytime and i just think its a great way to express you love for god.

list of fav prayers:
Apostles greed
our father
hail mary
and of course, the rossary


anyone else say these prayers? or know of them? lol i hope some at least knows them :P


I pray every day TO the FATHER in the name of JESUS and that my prayer be in accordance with His "Father's" will. I am a Christian, a follower of Christ.
Member
Posts: 1,161
Joined: Dec 25 2010
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 30%
May 6 2011 10:26pm
The Lords Prayer..
Member
Posts: 3,199
Joined: Feb 10 2006
Gold: 6,831.00
May 9 2011 01:02am
non-denominational Christians unlike Catholics have no leader. We are not corruptable as a whole.
Strike one of us down then u might as well strike all of us down.



Member
Posts: 7,869
Joined: Nov 23 2006
Gold: 614.00
May 9 2011 01:37am
As far as Protestantism goes, I would recommend the words of E.M. Bounds, Andrew Murray, Charles Spurgeon, and R.A. Torrey.

Studying prayer is probably one of the most rewarding things I have done.

I agree with an above poster, who said that either Catholic or Protestant, you can pray as much as you like and miss out of having relationship with God.
Member
Posts: 21,075
Joined: Apr 4 2007
Gold: 0.00
May 9 2011 01:59am
Just say what you feel. God listens.
Member
Posts: 5,901
Joined: Dec 13 2005
Gold: 2,508.53
May 11 2011 03:22am
Quote (Lifesong @ May 9 2011 03:37am)
I agree with an above poster, who said that either Catholic or Protestant, you can pray as much as you like and miss out of having relationship with God.


Quote (Torm1 @ Apr 29 2011 03:19pm)
Exactly. Christians do the bread/wine too, but see it as a symbol of remembrance, rather than it actually turning into actual physical flesh and blood when you consume it. Catholicism is more of a "religion" with rituals, etc...


Quote (darkfire @ Apr 29 2011 11:05am)
I've been to several evangelical churches where they eat bread and drink wine as part of the service.  The difference is that Catholics believe in transubstantiation.


Prayer is speaking with and listening to God.

I get the spiritual ritual, started by Jesus, is the physical action that has a spiritual response. It is similar to how the Ark of the Covenant, was a physical representation of the one in His throne and now we, who follow Him are living, breathing representatives of His presence. In any case, ultimately semantics means little, when we have a clear illustration from Him.

The time of remembrance, is directly out of the Passover Seder. In it's context we can glean understanding but out of our freedom in Christ, we can celebrate our thankfulness to Him as the redeemed, in any moment we are led to embrace Him.

If you study a bit, you will find Messianic Jews change their Seder to incorporate what Yeshua(Jesus) said there. You will also find the early Church leaders remembered Him, every time they met. I think I recall Mother Teresa partaking of the Lord's table every morning!

What if we all started our day in such a manner!?

Shalom <3
Go Back To Christian Fellowship Topic List
Prev123Next
Add Reply New Topic