Quote (Legacy_Tangent @ Sep 9 2010 11:40pm)
I disagree. There was a study backed by the Templeton foundation that observed what happened to different patients recovering from a coronary bypass surgery, that were prayed for and not prayed for( 1,802 patients). The people praying of course were from three different churches in Minnesota, Massachusetts, and Missouri. Of the two groups of patients (neither of which knew they were being prayed for), there was no difference between those that were prayed for, and those that were not.
Interestingly, those that KNEW they were being prayed for "suffered significantly more complications than those who did not."
first off, to do a test like that would mean God himself is on trial... I remember in one passage in the bible when Jesus was in the wilderness being tempted by Satan, Jesus said, "do not tempt the Lord thy God"
this "test" or "temptation" is wrong and shouldn't be performed, it is like God being judged by humans when we know right off the bat there is no judge that is more loving and has more justice
secondly, we are not god, so we cant take a single result as the final answer, i'll give you a testimony of my mother who died of cancer 6 years ago
she had been a testimony to many people, she had many friends both saved and unsaved, and she had been struggling with cancer for a few years prior to her death
she died the same year that i was going to go to college and at the time i didn't know what i wanted to do or "major" in
i guess you can say that her death involved me desiring to become a doctor and help those that have cancer, because of that, God's ultimate will might be to answer another individual's prayer that has not even been spoken yet because i someday helped that person's family member or friend be able to recover from cancer
God knows what he is doing even if he says no your prayers, i wasn't the only person affected by my mother's death, countless friends of hers who were unbelievers couldn't understand why our family could have such perfect peace at the day of her funeral so they asked us, we relayed them to the pastor after talking with them for a little, because of this, many of my mother's friends accepted christ as their saviour
my mother would be proud as she looks down on heaven on what her life AND DEATH have accomplished here on earth
thirdly, there is a huge inconsistency with "knowing they are being prayed for", there is a huge variety of "Christians" out there, i'm not going to go into too much detail but there are many hypocrites that do not truly know Christ as their personal saviour
for example, if you asked me if i was a 6'6 200 lbs of pure muscle and i told you through here on the internet that i was, would you believe me? maybe maybe not, you can't tell if someone is what they say they are over the internet just like you can't tell if someone is truly saved or not, only God can know if they are or not, now i know you can take a picture and post it on the internet to prove it is really me but that was a bad analogy but i hope you get my point that people can say they are christians but not truly