d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > One Of 10 Comandments
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 16,258
Joined: Dec 27 2019
Gold: 69.69
Jan 21 2021 05:13pm
Thou shalt not kill. This has been embedded in just about every part of the world as the a basic guiding principle and law.

There are grey areas in this though. One I wanted to explore what about self defense and how far is a reasonable self defense. For instance you are being held at a gun point by a mugger or robber goes into your house and you are faced with either the kill or be killed situations.

Then another scenario lets say you have been put on a hit list by a mafia or some gang and you go out with a rifle and shoot up their entire gang like John Wick and say it was in self defense.

A third scenario is when you hear the lord speak to you and gives you holy crusade mandate to take out the opposition

A fourth scenario is when you are stranded on a boat or an island and in order to survive you must kill the other guy and eat him.

A fifth scenario you sell people cigarettes knowingly they will kill someone but over a long time or at least shorten their life
Member
Posts: 9,499
Joined: Feb 3 2005
Gold: 6,969.69
Warn: 20%
Jan 21 2021 05:18pm
1. Okay
2. Okay but try to start with the top and see if the rest crumbles ya know
3. Not okay
4. Okay (more like delicious)
5. Okay

It’s more “thou shall not murder” in society.

Does the commandment specify a species? I am unaware of any line claiming the Bible only applies to humans.

I would like to add a sixth scenario

Your pet is miserable in the throes of death, you can end end it’s suffering with a vet visit (put down) or a bullet or you can follow the word of god(?) and watch it suffer needlessly.

Praise the lord

This post was edited by DrFaGgIt on Jan 21 2021 05:20pm
Member
Posts: 33,927
Joined: Oct 9 2008
Gold: 2,528.52
Jan 21 2021 05:48pm
Quote (addone @ Jan 21 2021 06:13pm)
Thou shalt not kill. This has been embedded in just about every part of the world as the a basic guiding principle and law.

There are grey areas in this though. One I wanted to explore what about self defense and how far is a reasonable self defense. For instance you are being held at a gun point by a mugger or robber goes into your house and you are faced with either the kill or be killed situations.

Then another scenario lets say you have been put on a hit list by a mafia or some gang and you go out with a rifle and shoot up their entire gang like John Wick and say it was in self defense.

A third scenario is when you hear the lord speak to you and gives you holy crusade mandate to take out the opposition

A fourth scenario is when you are stranded on a boat or an island and in order to survive you must kill the other guy and eat him.

A fifth scenario you sell people cigarettes knowingly they will kill someone but over a long time or at least shorten their life


The original Hebrew text states "Thou shalt not murder"

Seeing this and how Jesus himself underwent capital punishment, there is no absolute restriction on facilitated death.

The bible gives passages for specific situations, like if a robber is in your home at night then you kill him.. and if during the day, you make him a slave.
Member
Posts: 43,761
Joined: Aug 27 2009
Gold: 63,142.89
Jan 21 2021 06:29pm
This is why it's important for people to interpret the Bible's message rather than parsing the language and hanging on every literal translation.
Member
Posts: 22,440
Joined: Mar 3 2007
Gold: 96.11
Jan 21 2021 10:57pm
Why would it choose? this is extremely unlikely scenario in the first place? Which makes me wonder why would anyone engage in astronomically unlikely what ifs in the first place other then sheer boredom of their lives
Member
Posts: 38,671
Joined: Apr 1 2007
Gold: 8.21
Jan 21 2021 11:07pm
Quote (EndlessSky @ Jan 21 2021 03:48pm)
The original Hebrew text states "Thou shalt not murder"

Seeing this and how Jesus himself underwent capital punishment, there is no absolute restriction on facilitated death.

The bible gives passages for specific situations, like if a robber is in your home at night then you kill him.. and if during the day, you make him a slave.


damn that sounds dope

Quote (DrFaGgIt @ Jan 21 2021 03:18pm)
1. Okay
2. Okay but try to start with the top and see if the rest crumbles ya know
3. Not okay
4. Okay (more like delicious)
5. Okay

It’s more “thou shall not murder” in society.

Does the commandment specify a species? I am unaware of any line claiming the Bible only applies to humans.



it says "man" etc like 160,000 times
Member
Posts: 16,258
Joined: Dec 27 2019
Gold: 69.69
Jan 22 2021 01:34am
Quote (Handcuffs @ Jan 22 2021 05:57pm)
Why would it choose? this is extremely unlikely scenario in the first place? Which makes me wonder why would anyone engage in astronomically unlikely what ifs in the first place other then sheer boredom of their lives


stay mad bro your feeling have been hurt

better question would be is it okay to program a robot to kill or should ai be held accountable to same standards men would

This post was edited by addone on Jan 22 2021 01:38am
Member
Posts: 9,499
Joined: Feb 3 2005
Gold: 6,969.69
Warn: 20%
Jan 22 2021 02:25am
Quote (Handcuffs @ Jan 21 2021 06:57pm)
Why would it choose? this is extremely unlikely scenario in the first place? Which makes me wonder why would anyone engage in astronomically unlikely what ifs in the first place other then sheer boredom of their lives



They could be trying to figure out who to hit with a robot car 🤷‍♂️
Member
Posts: 66,666
Joined: May 17 2005
Gold: 17,384.69
Jan 22 2021 04:29am
Democrat party won.
Regarding topic; shit bigots who can't understand hollie bible is nothing new here, in pard.
Member
Posts: 66,666
Joined: May 17 2005
Gold: 17,384.69
Jan 22 2021 05:41am
Holie bible, my bad

Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Add Reply New Topic New Poll