Quote (thundercock @ 10 Jan 2021 07:33)
Having said all that, to compare BLM to what happened at the Capitol is bat shit insane. Symbols matter. There's a reason Al-Qaeda chose the WTC, Pentagon, and the Capitol for the 9/11 attacks. In addition, more people died at this event than any BLM protest (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Violence_and_controversies_during_the_George_Floyd_protests#Deaths). The genesis for the two is also entirely different. I think a lot of people on the right are trying to create a false equivalence because they don't want to admit fault. If "both sides" do it, you level the playing field from a moral perspective.
That's where I have to disagree. The way I see it, and the way I read Weiss' op-ed, is that there had been a long trend of norm erosion and gradually losing contact with reality on both sides, a trend which had been going on for many many years. The iconic CNN screenshot with the reporter in front of a burning building and the "fiery but mostly peaceful protests"-chyron was just the temporary climax of this long-standing development.
My argument is not that BLM and the Capitol storming should be compared directly. What happened at the Capitol was batshit insane and a huuuuuge escalation. It was a quantum leap of norm breaking, delusion and intellectual abandoning of democracy. And like you said, the symbolism couldnt be any worse. The point is not that the storming of the Capitol is equivalent in any way, shape or form to the BLM protests. No, the point is that both types of riots share a common genesis once we look at the greater picture. Wednesday's escalation did not come completely out of the blue, and neither was it the sad end point of a radicalization limited exclusively to the political right.
Simply put, the "Cold Civil War" in America had been festering, brewing and heating up for a long time, and on Wednesday, it finally boiled over in an openly violent, undemocratic episode.
Quote
Her conclusion at the end is correct but it makes sense why people feel that way. They live in completely separate realities and the opposition is an existential threat to those realities.
Well said, and that's what's so disillusioning about it all: the attack on the Capitol indicates that this Cold Civil War might indeed be impossible to resolve peacefully and democratically. Until this week, I, for my part, remained fairly confident that these tensions could be reduced and ultimately disarmed with better politics and better policy. Not anymore.
This post was edited by Black XistenZ on Jan 10 2021 11:49am