d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Should We Shame Fat People?
Prev196979899100174Next
Closed New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 9,060
Joined: May 15 2010
Gold: 18,470.03
May 12 2016 07:30am
I went to the doctor yesterday and he told me he had good news and bad news. He tells me the good news is that I have AIDS. I say WTF? THAT'S THE GOOD NEWS? He says the bad news is, you're so fucking fat there's no way that it will matter.
Member
Posts: 24,556
Joined: Mar 2 2008
Gold: 14,346.41
May 12 2016 07:37am
Quote (duffman316 @ May 11 2016 09:06pm)
personally i just have respect for persistence, i have a certain respect for people i see regularly at the gym these days
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8svuSIYQu74


the question is is this kind of thinking common amongst the morbidly obese? if so i might have offended two coworkers of mine numerous times over the past 2 years simply in talking about the kind of food i cook :/


I wonder how much those skin removal surgeries cost, he has a lot.
Member
Posts: 41,259
Joined: Apr 14 2006
Gold: 2,738.71
May 12 2016 07:45am
I read up to page 15 and up to then objective evidence was provided that negative reinforcement encourages a long term lifestyle modification. Was something provided in this thread in the 75 pages that followed?
Member
Posts: 57,901
Joined: Dec 3 2008
Gold: 286.00
May 12 2016 07:55am
Quote (hATemOnkEy @ May 11 2016 09:17pm)
Actually I'd applaud their willpower to actively make their lives better. I don't care if they do it for health or beauty or both.


I was overweight and I dropped 40 pounds due to severe depression and just not enjoying food (or life). Sadly, I think most people would take that trade :lol:

But it wasn't will, or dieting, it was incidental. A lot of weight gain and loss is incidental, based on age and metabolism, and genetics. People are built differently. When I joined the army I was considered extremely overweight, but since I had a 30 inch waist and a 20 inch neck and was as strong as a bull they used a BMI waiver....

But so many of these measurements just consider percentage of body fat, or height vs weight, and don't consider health at all.

This is a side note and tangential, but this is why looking and appearing healthy is so important in the gay male community....because the appearance of health makes people believe they are healthy, because people believe what they see. When disease is so prevalent, looking healthy is important.

When we are talking about shaming fat people, is the social stigma there because we care about their health? No, of course not. It is schadenfreude, one of the most despicable things we all tend to engage in.

Quote (nineinchnailz @ May 12 2016 08:30am)
I went to the doctor yesterday and he told me he had good news and bad news. He tells me the good news is that I have AIDS. I say WTF? THAT'S THE GOOD NEWS? He says the bad news is, you're so fucking fat there's no way that it will matter.


TIL: excess lipids will replace an autoimmune response.

What a bad joke.

Quote (Bazi @ May 12 2016 08:45am)
I read up to page 15 and up to then objective evidence was provided that negative reinforcement encourages a long term lifestyle modification. Was something provided in this thread in the 75 pages that followed?


I don't believe humans can be objective. Even science is relativistic.

This post was edited by Skinned on May 12 2016 07:57am
Member
Posts: 14,319
Joined: Jun 19 2010
Gold: 7,271.48
May 12 2016 07:57am
Quote (Bazi @ May 12 2016 07:45am)
I read up to page 15 and up to then objective evidence was provided that negative reinforcement encourages a long term lifestyle modification. Was something provided in this thread in the 75 pages that followed?



Some discussion on diet and the extra effort required to avoid a macdonalds and 12 hour a day tv life style

Some sporadic examples of regressive left / pc fat acceptances and healthy people hate.
Member
Posts: 41,259
Joined: Apr 14 2006
Gold: 2,738.71
May 12 2016 08:00am
Quote (Skinned @ May 12 2016 08:55am)
I was overweight and I dropped 40 pounds due to severe depression and just not enjoying food (or life). Sadly, I think most people would take that trade :lol:

But it wasn't will, or dieting, it was incidental. A lot of weight gain and loss is incidental, based on age and metabolism, and genetics. People are built differently. When I joined the army I was considered extremely overweight, but since I had a 30 inch waist and a 20 inch neck and was as strong as a bull they used a BMI waiver....

But so many of these measurements just consider percentage of body fat, or height vs weight, and don't consider health at all.

This is a side note and tangential, but this is why looking and appearing healthy is so important in the gay male community....because the appearance of health makes people believe they are healthy, because people believe what they see. When disease is so prevalent, looking healthy is important.

When we are talking about shaming fat people, is the social stigma there because we care about their health? No, of course not. It is schadenfreude, one of the most despicable things we all tend to engage in.



TIL: excess lipids will replace an autoimmune response.

What a bad joke.



I don't believe humans can be objective. Even science is relativistic.


Sure but you can aim to investigate/report in an empirical manner. Often times that provides a basis to start the conversation
Member
Posts: 9,060
Joined: May 15 2010
Gold: 18,470.03
May 12 2016 08:01am
Quote (Skinned @ May 12 2016 08:55am)
I was overweight and I dropped 40 pounds due to severe depression and just not enjoying food (or life). Sadly, I think most people would take that trade :lol:

But it wasn't will, or dieting, it was incidental. A lot of weight gain and loss is incidental, based on age and metabolism, and genetics. People are built differently. When I joined the army I was considered extremely overweight, but since I had a 30 inch waist and a 20 inch neck and was as strong as a bull they used a BMI waiver....

But so many of these measurements just consider percentage of body fat, or height vs weight, and don't consider health at all.

This is a side note and tangential, but this is why looking and appearing healthy is so important in the gay male community....because the appearance of health makes people believe they are healthy, because people believe what they see. When disease is so prevalent, looking healthy is important.

When we are talking about shaming fat people, is the social stigma there because we care about their health? No, of course not. It is schadenfreude, one of the most despicable things we all tend to engage in.



TIL: excess lipids will replace an autoimmune response.

What a bad joke.



I don't believe humans can be objective. Even science is relativistic.


The joke is that a heart attack will get you before AIDS will.
Member
Posts: 41,259
Joined: Apr 14 2006
Gold: 2,738.71
May 12 2016 08:07am
Quote (Bazi @ May 12 2016 08:45am)
I read up to page 15 and up to then NOobjective evidence was provided that negative reinforcement encourages a long term lifestyle modification. Was something provided in this thread in the 75 pages that followed?



Lmao I'm on a roll today

This should read NO objective evidence was provided. I and others provided articles demonstrating the non impact negative reinforcement has across several areas including lifestyle modifications

Member
Posts: 57,901
Joined: Dec 3 2008
Gold: 286.00
May 12 2016 08:11am
Quote (nineinchnailz @ May 12 2016 09:01am)
The joke is that a heart attack will get you before AIDS will.


I'm slow today lol. I really thought it was in reference to AIDS being "the skinny disease" in Africa, considering your past posting patterns ;)

Quote (Bazi @ May 12 2016 09:07am)
Lmao I'm on a roll today

This should read NO objective evidence was provided. I and others provided articles demonstrating the non impact negative reinforcement has across several areas including lifestyle modifications


Lol okay. That makes way more sense :p

This post was edited by Skinned on May 12 2016 08:12am
Member
Posts: 28,258
Joined: Jan 29 2004
Gold: 2,000.00
May 12 2016 09:25am
Quote (Bazi @ May 12 2016 07:45am)
I read up to page 15 and up to then objective evidence was provided that negative reinforcement encourages a long term lifestyle modification. Was something provided in this thread in the 75 pages that followed?


http://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=74143671&f=119&p=502859913

There's a great summary on that page

This post was edited by dark-soul on May 12 2016 09:26am
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev196979899100174Next
Closed New Topic New Poll