Quote (Black XistenZ @ Jul 8 2022 12:39am)
Democrats actually have a decent chance of holding the Senate this fall. They will get wiped out in the Senate in 2024, when the "lucky class of senators" (who ran in three consecutive strong years for Democrats, 2006, 2012 and 2018) comes up for reelection in a presidential year. Manchin, Tester and the like will be toast.
They might also bank a lot on Trump being the GOP nominee again in 2024, and public opinion on him still being extremely polarized and hardened, with a slight but persistent majority loathing him. So there probably is a path to nuking the filibuster for abortion and getting away with it. It's of course still a foolish approach since the risk would be huge, as you pointed out, but also since allowing Republican hardliners to overreach on the issue is the far smarter long-term strategy for Democrats.
So yes, I agree with you that it's a stupid idea for Democrats to nuke the filibuster this summer, but there is at least some logic to it.
Even if Republicans took the senate this year they wouldn't take a supermajority, and Biden would remain president and hold the veto, so yeah its a 2024 issue. And the deck stacked against them in 2024 to boot.
This is not 'getting away with it' The best case scenario is that they get to make abortions legal at the federal level for a matter of months, maybe 1.5 years tops, before its
immediately reversed by republicans. And then we'd be plunging the nation into a ridiculous back and forth on policy based on each election cycle, moreso than it already is right now. The filibuster has been mitigating that.
History has shown that every time the democrats overreach, the Republicans are the ones who win long term. Mitch McConnell said that to Harry Reid point blank when he went nuclear on the judiciary, and look how that turned out