d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Never Forget > 10th Anniversary
Prev18910111227Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 33,156
Joined: Apr 8 2006
Gold: 737.50
Sep 7 2011 09:44am
Quote (Matao @ Sep 7 2011 11:40am)
im telling you what people i talked to were actually saying in the days and weeks after the event
2 wrongs make a right ?  just where the fuck do i say it was right ?
the " norm " ? , maybe in america , but you are decieving yourself if you dont think americas image overseas isnt of a bloodthirsty nation

you just have to ask yourself why it actually happened
literally millions of people died at americas hands before 9/11
literally millions of people around the world rejoiced at the news of the attack

you can beleive they did it because " the hate freedom " all you want ( if thats what u beleive )
the truth is , there is no lack of normal  , average , able bodied men around the world willing to fight america , so long as they beleive they have some chance of victory
and that kind of hate didnt happen all on its own ....


Innocent civilians are not committing war crimes around the world. Anyone who has a quarrel with America does not have it with these innocent men and women. Therefore, to rejoice their deaths is what I would consider "bloodthirsty".

And yes, you are using a "two wrongs make a right" argument. You are bringing up millions of people dying at America's hands before 9/11 as an attempt to justify the murder of thousands of innocent civilians who were not responsible for those things.
Member
Posts: 34,979
Joined: Jan 28 2005
Gold: 4,910.00
Sep 7 2011 09:56am
if this was posted by anyone else it would end with a 'home to bel air'.

i was in first period art class when this happened. i don't think i comprehended what was actually going on at the time.
Member
Posts: 5,343
Joined: Sep 13 2010
Gold: 500.40
Sep 7 2011 10:06am
Quote (Matao @ Sep 7 2011 09:27am)
only americans died ?
innocent huh ?

the 2 most common versions at the time would be the analogy of the innocent nazi ( yeah , im a nazi  , and yeah , i knew the jews were getting it , but the furher said they were destroying our country , and i didnt actually gas any of them myself , so what did i do wrong ? )
and the simple fact , that for decades , the only people who were able to stop the usa from killing so many people , destroying so many lives , were the american voters , and they didnt do it ( here they would say they are culpable  , and just because some of us may be aware that the american political institutions were hijacked long ago , and that voting basically doesnt really matter there anymore , doesnt mean that those with the greatest axe to grind with american know that )

maybe they liked their " cheap gas " , maybe they " didnt know " what their govt was doing  "in their name " ( here they would say they needed to become aware , and previous attempts had failed , and again , simply because some of us are aware that the american general public is probably the most heavily indoctrinated in modern history , doesnt mean those who have survived american " imperialism " know this )

and the focus on individuals is deceptive
if al-quada did do it , then they certainly didnt do it to " punish " those in the buildings
nor did they do it because  " they are freedom haters " , nor because " they are religious crazies "
but i guess the term collateral damage only applies to non americans

there are facts that , simply , are basically unspeakable in american society
that doesnt mean we dont speak them elsewhere



Quote (Matao @ Sep 7 2011 09:40am)
im telling you what people i talked to were actually saying in the days and weeks after the event
2 wrongs make a right ?  just where the fuck do i say it was right ?
the " norm " ? , maybe in america , but you are decieving yourself if you dont think americas image overseas isnt of a bloodthirsty nation

you just have to ask yourself why it actually happened
literally millions of people died at americas hands before 9/11
literally millions of people around the world rejoiced at the news of the attack

you can beleive they did it because " the hate freedom " all you want ( if thats what u beleive )
the truth is , there is no lack of normal  , average , able bodied men around the world willing to fight america , so long as they beleive they have some chance of victory
and that kind of hate didnt happen all on its own ....


Americans are like Nazis? IF al Qaeda did it? We're bloodthirsty? We made the hate happen?

I guess as these are the kinds of people you associate with, it explains a lot of your posts.
Member
Posts: 35,291
Joined: Aug 17 2004
Gold: 12,730.67
Sep 7 2011 10:41am
Quote (JEB90 @ Sep 7 2011 04:06pm)
Americans are like Nazis?  IF al Qaeda did it?  We're bloodthirsty? We made the hate happen?

I guess as these are the kinds of people you associate with, it explains a lot of your posts.


Yea I'd ignore Matao...he's one of those with a blade of grass IQ. If we go by his logic, we shouldn't feel bad for any act of violence. After all, you reap what you sow.
Member
Posts: 52,226
Joined: Jan 3 2009
Gold: 8,902.00
Sep 7 2011 10:44am
Quote (Matao @ Sep 7 2011 09:20am)
i was 26 , and flicking thru the channels late at night , when i came across the 1st tower smoking
watched the 2nd tower get hit
watched them both fall
was better than a late night movie

and the next day  , talking to friends , we mostly tended to agree
you reap what you sow


I guess I can say I'm not surprised you hang with such a shitty crowd. Birds of a feather...
Member
Posts: 14,099
Joined: Jul 13 2006
Gold: 83.30
Sep 7 2011 10:46am
Quote (WidowMaKer_MK @ Sep 7 2011 08:48am)
If you have any vivid memories of that day and how it affected you please feel fee to share them here .

I have seen many important historical events unfold in my lifetime including the Vietnam War , the political assassinations of the late 1960's and Watergate and none have affected me as deeply as that one single day in September .


I remember it quite vividly myself.

I was in the last year of primary school, and came home to find my sister clinged to the radio whilst doing her homework. She told me that the Twin Towers collapsed and I thought she was joking, and when the radio confirmed it I thought it was a joke from the radio show. We proceeded to turn the tv on and watch in shock and awe as we realized what had happened. I gasped when the images of the airplanes crashing into those towers were repeated. I had tears in my eyes when I saw all those people on the higher floors who jumped to their deaths, their last act of desperation.

No other event in my living history has left such a lasting impression (Utoya comes close, but not quite), not just with me but with the whole world. I hope that the memorial will serve as a lasting point of remembrance, lest we not forget.
Member
Posts: 2,506
Joined: Aug 7 2010
Gold: 1,028.00
Sep 7 2011 10:58am
Quote (JEB90 @ Sep 7 2011 07:06pm)
Americans are like Nazis?  IF al Qaeda did it?  We're bloodthirsty? We made the hate happen?

I guess as these are the kinds of people you associate with, it explains a lot of your posts.


no nazis better they didnt say" only way to stop war one world goverment" like you ;) twin towers just excuse for your hunger of power again my post in last page ignored as a classical american tactic by some people

This post was edited by Mutantlord on Sep 7 2011 11:01am
Member
Posts: 5,343
Joined: Sep 13 2010
Gold: 500.40
Sep 7 2011 11:14am
Quote (Mutantlord @ Sep 7 2011 10:58am)
no nazis better they didnt say" only way to stop war one world goverment" like you  ;) twin towers just excuse for your hunger of power again my post in last page ignored as a classical american tactic by some people


Now Realists are worse that Nazis? Very insightful. As an aside, I don't know whether to be flattered or frightened that you pay that much attention to my views on international relations theory...
Member
Posts: 2,506
Joined: Aug 7 2010
Gold: 1,028.00
Sep 7 2011 11:17am
im sure its reality lol another tactic like guys who missbombs some places

This post was edited by Mutantlord on Sep 7 2011 11:20am
Member
Posts: 96,125
Joined: Mar 15 2007
Gold: 7,252.72
Sep 7 2011 11:51am
Quote (balrog66 @ Sep 7 2011 12:46pm)
I remember it quite vividly myself.

I was in the last year of primary school, and came home to find my sister clinged to the radio whilst doing her homework. She told me that the Twin Towers collapsed and I thought she was joking, and when the radio confirmed it I thought it was a joke from the radio show. We proceeded to turn the tv on and watch in shock and awe as we realized what had happened. I gasped when the images of the airplanes crashing into those towers were repeated. I had tears in my eyes when I saw all those people on the higher floors who jumped to their deaths, their last act of desperation.

No other event in my living history has left such a lasting impression (Utoya comes close, but not quite), not just with me but with the whole world. I hope that the memorial will serve as a lasting point of remembrance, lest we not forget.


I remember how rapidly my emotions changed when the second plane hit . On the channel I was watching they were discussing the size of the hole in the first tower hit since the initial media reports were saying a small plane had been involved and there was this one commentator saying that he thought the hole was way too big to have been anything but a jetliner .

As they discussed it back and forth the cameras were of course trained on the complex and then right in front of our eyes all doubt was removed as to what had happened when we all saw the second plane slamming into the other building .

It is amazing how vivid a memory can remain .
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev18910111227Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll