d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate >
Poll > Trump 2020 > Trump Vs. Pack O' Dems
Prev1889890891892893983Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
  Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.
Member
Posts: 27,048
Joined: Dec 21 2007
Gold: 14,569.69
May 5 2021 01:57pm
Quote (Black XistenZ @ May 5 2021 12:54pm)
if over 70 million Americans, representing 47% of the electorate, are an "active cancer in US politics", then civil war is inevitable.


regarding the Trump in 2024 thing: keep in mind that he has been out of office for little more than 3 months and already faaaar less relevant and 'dominant' in day-to-day politics.
it will take 30 months from now on until the first primary of the 2024 season takes places.


The ones that feel like the virus is a hoax and the election is stolen. That Joe B. is somehow less mentally able than listening to trump talk about his gene pool etc. or believe Barr was acting in good faith, endless amount of subjects here....
Etc. etc. etc..


But to your civil war statement if "reality" is in disagreement then yes.
absolutely
Member
Posts: 49,289
Joined: Jun 18 2006
Gold: 11.77
May 5 2021 02:38pm
Quote (Black XistenZ @ May 5 2021 10:49am)
Trump is getting less and less attention every month, just give it time. Trump doesnt even have it in him to be the leader of the Republican party as long as he himself isnt its presidential nominee. To fill the role of spiritus rector or grey eminence, he would have to be disciplined, consistent and interested in actual policy.

Trump got a free pass in 2015-2020, at least to some extent, because he forced a realignment onto the old GOP establishment and was backed by the rank and file in doing so. Cheney, on the other hand, wants to relitigate the past when it is clearly in the better interest of the party to move on from 2020. And yes, Trump currently is doing the same, he also can't let 2020 go, and it's bad for the party - and precisely because of that is it better for the party to give his bitter ramblings as little attention as possible. Do you seriously think that Trump can keep this act up, that he will be able to mobilize primary voters in 2024 by the narrative of a stolen election which will, by then, lie four years in the past?

On top of that, Trump was offering a new path for his party (whether you liked it or not), while Cheney is not - all Cheney has to offer is a return to neocon policies which have been outdated since ca. 2007...

My position is that Cheney should not spread a lie to her voters, particularly not when she doesnt personally believe in this lie. But explicitly ranting about Trump 24/7, and continuously pushing public attention back to his lie, is not helpful. Neither for the electoral prospects of the party, nor for the health of democracy. And since the majority of the party leadership have made the decision to try to move on from 2020 and Trump, and since the base clearly wants none of the nevertrumpy "hold him accountable" stuff, she is positioning herself against her party when she keeps this kind of fight up.

Whether you agree with the position and direction of a party or not doesn't matter in this regard: someone who's blatantly out of step with his or her party is not suitable for a leadership role, period.


Show me evidence that Trump is becoming irrelevant in the Republican party. Simply proclaiming it doesn't make it so. Various high profile Republicans visit him, Nikki Haley said she wouldn't run if he did, etc etc. He's out of the spotlight, but he's not irrelevant.

Your position is that Trump should be able to perpetuate the big lie without consequences, but if Cheney pushes back, she should be removed from leadership because it's contradicting what the party thinks, which was set by the leader of the Republican party, Donald Trump. What is true doesn't matter to you... what is good for the health of American democracy doesn't matter. The only thing that matters is keeping Trump happy and the Republican party unified. And keeping the Republican party unified means backing up Trump's constant lying, so Cheney isn't the right fit.

Oh look, here's the guy who everybody has to placate in the name of Republican unity:

https://twitter.com/meridithmcgraw/status/1389940678101176322

Trump attacking Cheney, Pence, and McConnell. But Cheney is the one who deserves to be stripped of their role in the Republican party, because *reasons*.

A healthy Republican party would've told this guy to fuck off years ago, but they can't do that because a large portion of their voters are in a personality cult devoted to him. At the end of the day, that's what it comes down to.

This post was edited by IceMage on May 5 2021 02:42pm
Member
Posts: 27,048
Joined: Dec 21 2007
Gold: 14,569.69
May 5 2021 02:41pm
Quote (IceMage @ May 5 2021 01:38pm)
Show me evidence that Trump is becoming irrelevant in the Republican party. Simply proclaiming it doesn't make it so. Various high profile Republicans visit him, Nikki Haley said she wouldn't run if he did, etc etc. He's out of the spotlight, but he's not irrelevant.

Your position is that Trump should be able to perpetuate the big lie without consequences, but if Cheney pushes back, she should be removed from leadership because it's contradicting what the party thinks, which was set by the leader of the Republican party, Donald Trump. What is true doesn't matter to you... what is good for the health of American democracy doesn't matter. The only thing that matters is keeping Trump happy and the Republican party unified. And keeping the Republican party unified means backing up Trump's constant lying, so Cheney isn't the right fit.

Oh look, here's the guy who everybody has to placate in the name of Republican unity:

https://twitter.com/meridithmcgraw/status/1389940678101176322

Trump attacking Cheney, Pence, and McConnell. But Cheney is the one who deserves to be stripped of their role in the Republican party, because *reasons*.


:thumbsup:

IE Reality is now a talking point
Member
Posts: 33,925
Joined: Oct 9 2008
Gold: 2,528.52
May 5 2021 02:46pm
Quote (theCrossbones @ May 5 2021 04:41pm)
:thumbsup:

IE Reality is now a talking point


It was ever since suckers like you believed communist propaganda.
Member
Posts: 49,289
Joined: Jun 18 2006
Gold: 11.77
May 5 2021 02:47pm
https://twitter.com/jaketapper/status/1390012808436330501

Quote
Today's attacks on Pence and McConnell underscore the fallacy of capitulating to his lies: he expects folks to exert powers they do not possess, and blames them for his own actions.

In short, you're asked not just to buy into one lie -- but to live in a universe of them.


Indeed.
Member
Posts: 27,048
Joined: Dec 21 2007
Gold: 14,569.69
May 5 2021 03:00pm
Quote (EndlessSky @ May 5 2021 01:46pm)
It was ever since suckers like you believed communist propaganda.


please explain your fantasy land communism?
Health care?
what?
Member
Posts: 33,925
Joined: Oct 9 2008
Gold: 2,528.52
May 5 2021 03:11pm
Quote (IceMage @ May 5 2021 04:47pm)


McConnel is almost dead and Pence won't have a political future.

Theres a reason why Democrats like their own representatives more than Republicans.
Member
Posts: 54,122
Joined: May 26 2005
Gold: 4,945.67
May 5 2021 03:14pm
Quote (IceMage @ 5 May 2021 22:38)
Show me evidence that Trump is becoming irrelevant in the Republican party. Simply proclaiming it doesn't make it so. Various high profile Republicans visit him, Nikki Haley said she wouldn't run if he did, etc etc. He's out of the spotlight, but he's not irrelevant.


I'm not saying Trump is irrelevant as of today, I'm saying that he's on the path to irrelevance; and that he will no longer be nearly as dominant in the GOP if he's just left alone and ignored.

Trump was an ultra-dominant figure, EVERYTHING in politics revolved around him for close to 5 years. He was the figurehead of conservatives during a time of hyperpolarization. These kinds of emotional ties need time to wear off. It was always unrealistic to expect rank and file Republicans to just ditch the investment into Trump that they had fostered throughout the years the moment he's out of office.

Of course Haley says she wont challenge Trump for the nomination. Even if she intends to run, she has nothing to gain but headache if she openly positions herself against Trump right now while he still enjoys strong residual support.



I've posted results from an Echelon Insights survey of registered Republicans before, and will post them again:


So, 60/71% of Republican primary voters consider it very important/important that a candidate supports the Trump agenda on trade and immigration to get their support, while only 41/54% think it's very important/ important that a candidate consistently supported Trump during his presidency, and only 35/47% are very invested/invested in Trump's lies about the stolen election. A "personality like Trump's" is polling even worse.

The bottom line, at least according to this poll, is that a significant majority of the party is ready to move on from Trump the person, but not from 'Trumpism'. Republicans are not overly attached to Trump's 'Big Lie' and to his personality, but they want to stick with his policies and feisty approach to politics instead of going back to the Koch brothers agenda and "losing with decorum".


Quote
Your position is that Trump should be able to perpetuate the big lie without consequences, but if Cheney pushes back, she should be removed from leadership because it's contradicting what the party thinks, which was set by the leader of the Republican party, Donald Trump.

My position is that nobody should listen anymore to what Donald Trump has to say. He should be ignored or treated as a nuissance. Depriving a narcissist of the attention he craves is the harshest form of punishment.

Cheney should not only be removed from leadership because she pushes back on the Big Lie - she should be removed because she's constantly and needlessly bringing up an issue which is clearly hurting her party. The rest of the party's leadership has chosen to follow the strategy of ignoring Trump's ramblings, but Cheney keeps harping on about principles instead of being a team player.


Quote
What is true doesn't matter to you... what is good for the health of American democracy doesn't matter. The only thing that matters is keeping Trump happy and the Republican party unified. And keeping the Republican party unified means backing up Trump's constant lying, so Cheney isn't the right fit.

This is uncomfortable, but it's the way it is: since losing the election, Trump has increasingly gone off the rails and become a liability and danger to his party. Ignoring the truth is not noble or desirable, but it is what's necessary right now to get rid of him without seeing the GOP ripped apart between warring pro- and anti-Trump factions. Guys like McConnell, who is absolutely finished with Trump, get that and keep their mouth shut for the better of the party. Cheney can't seem to do that.

Quote
Oh look, here's the guy who everybody has to placate in the name of Republican unity:

https://twitter.com/meridithmcgraw/status/1389940678101176322

Trump attacking Cheney, Pence, and McConnell. But Cheney is the one who deserves to be stripped of their role in the Republican party, because *reasons*.

In the intermediate future, it's indeed time for McConnell to go. He stands for policies which are just too broadly unpopular.
Poor Pence really got shafted though. He was always super loyal to Trump, only to be thrown under the bus. He does not deserve to be blasted like that.

This post was edited by Black XistenZ on May 5 2021 03:24pm
Member
Posts: 35,291
Joined: Aug 17 2004
Gold: 12,730.67
May 5 2021 04:21pm
Quote (Black XistenZ @ May 5 2021 02:14pm)
I'm not saying Trump is irrelevant as of today, I'm saying that he's on the path to irrelevance; and that he will no longer be nearly as dominant in the GOP if he's just left alone and ignored.

Trump was an ultra-dominant figure, EVERYTHING in politics revolved around him for close to 5 years. He was the figurehead of conservatives during a time of hyperpolarization. These kinds of emotional ties need time to wear off. It was always unrealistic to expect rank and file Republicans to just ditch the investment into Trump that they had fostered throughout the years the moment he's out of office.

Of course Haley says she wont challenge Trump for the nomination. Even if she intends to run, she has nothing to gain but headache if she openly positions herself against Trump right now while he still enjoys strong residual support.



I've posted results from an Echelon Insights survey of registered Republicans before, and will post them again:
https://i.imgur.com/zV6XwIN.jpg

So, 60/71% of Republican primary voters consider it very important/important that a candidate supports the Trump agenda on trade and immigration to get their support, while only 41/54% think it's very important/ important that a candidate consistently supported Trump during his presidency, and only 35/47% are very invested/invested in Trump's lies about the stolen election. A "personality like Trump's" is polling even worse.

The bottom line, at least according to this poll, is that a significant majority of the party is ready to move on from Trump the person, but not from 'Trumpism'. Republicans are not overly attached to Trump's 'Big Lie' and to his personality, but they want to stick with his policies and feisty approach to politics instead of going back to the Koch brothers agenda and "losing with decorum".



My position is that nobody should listen anymore to what Donald Trump has to say. He should be ignored or treated as a nuissance. Depriving a narcissist of the attention he craves is the harshest form of punishment.

Cheney should not only be removed from leadership because she pushes back on the Big Lie - she should be removed because she's constantly and needlessly bringing up an issue which is clearly hurting her party. The rest of the party's leadership has chosen to follow the strategy of ignoring Trump's ramblings, but Cheney keeps harping on about principles instead of being a team player.



This is uncomfortable, but it's the way it is: since losing the election, Trump has increasingly gone off the rails and become a liability and danger to his party. Ignoring the truth is not noble or desirable, but it is what's necessary right now to get rid of him without seeing the GOP ripped apart between warring pro- and anti-Trump factions. Guys like McConnell, who is absolutely finished with Trump, get that and keep their mouth shut for the better of the party. Cheney can't seem to do that.


In the intermediate future, it's indeed time for McConnell to go. He stands for policies which are just too broadly unpopular.
Poor Pence really got shafted though. He was always super loyal to Trump, only to be thrown under the bus. He does not deserve to be blasted like that.


You know that Cheney doesn't bring it up right? She is simply responding to Trump's quasi-Twitter account (https://www.donaldjtrump.com/desk). Cheney doesn't need to go, McCarthy does. He is the one who is going to Mar-a-Lago to work on GOP strategy. If you want Trump to be ignored, the GOP House leadership is failing spectacularly.
Member
Posts: 54,122
Joined: May 26 2005
Gold: 4,945.67
May 5 2021 05:24pm
Quote (thundercock @ 6 May 2021 00:21)
You know that Cheney doesn't bring it up right? She is simply responding to Trump's quasi-Twitter account (https://www.donaldjtrump.com/desk).


Of course she's bringing it up when she responds to Trump's musings on his personal blog that most people probably dont even know about. She's putting the spotlight on what he has to say and thus acts as a multiplier on his outreach.

---------

Some background on the rising tensions between Cheney and other Congressional Republicans:
https://thehill.com/homenews/house/551261-gop-frustration-with-liz-cheney-at-a-boiling-point

She is clearly putting her own views and self-promotion ahead of her party, which makes her unfit for a leadership role.


Quote
Cheney doesn't need to go, McCarthy does. He is the one who is going to Mar-a-Lago to work on GOP strategy. If you want Trump to be ignored, the GOP House leadership is failing spectacularly.

McCarthy is overdoing it with the kissing-the-ring thing imho. Still, not much will come from these "strategy" meetings in the long run.

Also note that this is not as much of a contradiction as it seems at first glance. I want Trump's delusional ramblings to be ignored, particularly those about the 2020 election which was oh so unfairly stolen from him, boo hoo.
This does not, however, mean that Trump can't play a productive role in other fields of GOP operations, be it strategy or voter outreach, if - and only if - he's up to it. (Which he wont in most cases...)


---------------------



game recognizes game
swamp recognizes swamp :lol:

This post was edited by Black XistenZ on May 5 2021 05:27pm
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1889890891892893983Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll