Quote (IceMage @ 5 May 2021 16:07)
Trump is not fading into irrelevance, he's the leader of the Republican party. When he chooses to lie about the election, and attacks Liz Cheney for trying to hold him accountable, it's reasonable for her to respond. Why is Trump given a free pass for attacking Republicans for 5 years, but Cheney responding to attacks and lies from Trump merits her being kicked out of a position of power?
Yes, we know that the Republican party is now the cult of Donald Trump, and since he lied to Republican voters for months about the election being stolen, they believe him. But the election wasn't stolen, and the idea that it was is poisonous to democracy.
Just to be clear, your position is that Liz Cheney should either spread the poisonous lie to her voters, or be silent when others in the party do so? That would make her suitable for a leadership position? And the rationale for that is because her voters believe the lie, because Trump and his cronies spread it for months?
Trump is getting less and less attention every month, just give it time. Trump doesnt even have it in him to be the leader of the Republican party as long as he himself isnt its presidential nominee. To fill the role of spiritus rector or grey eminence, he would have to be disciplined, consistent and interested in actual policy.
Trump got a free pass in 2015-2020, at least to some extent, because he forced a realignment onto the old GOP establishment and was backed by the rank and file in doing so. Cheney, on the other hand, wants to relitigate the past when it is clearly in the better interest of the party to move on from 2020. And yes, Trump currently is doing the same, he also can't let 2020 go, and it's bad for the party - and precisely because of that is it better for the party to give his bitter ramblings as little attention as possible. Do you seriously think that Trump can keep this act up, that he will be able to mobilize primary voters in 2024 by the narrative of a stolen election which will, by then, lie four years in the past?
On top of that, Trump was offering a new path for his party (whether you liked it or not), while Cheney is not - all Cheney has to offer is a return to neocon policies which have been outdated since ca. 2007...
My position is that Cheney should not spread a lie to her voters, particularly not when she doesnt personally believe in this lie. But explicitly ranting about Trump 24/7, and continuously pushing public attention back to his lie, is not helpful. Neither for the electoral prospects of the party, nor for the health of democracy. And since the majority of the party leadership have made the decision to try to move on from 2020 and Trump, and since the base clearly wants none of the nevertrumpy "hold him accountable" stuff, she is positioning herself against her party when she keeps this kind of fight up.
Whether you agree with the position and direction of a party or not doesn't matter in this regard: someone who's blatantly out of step with his or her party is not suitable for a leadership role, period.
This post was edited by Black XistenZ on May 5 2021 08:51am