Official Atheist / Agnostic Thread - Topic

Member

Posts: 57,901

Joined: Dec 3 2008

Gold: 286.00

Jul 14 2015 02:55pm

Quote (ThatAlex @ Jul 14 2015 03:50pm)

By that definition, then I think some cases of miscarriage could be classified as involuntary manslaughter, like the link Duffman shared.

Back to the more religious-themed question since this is the atheist thread:

If abortion is murder because it is intentionally killing human life, is miscarriage god's wrath? Did he intend for that fetus to die?

Is the fetus saved? Does the fetus go to hell for eternity? Maybe there is some special exception?

This is the Atheist and Agnostic thread, not the Christian apologetics thread :lol:

Devil_kin

Member

Posts: 32,208

Joined: Nov 27 2010

Gold: 159.02

#882

Jul 14 2015 02:56pm

ThatAlex

Member

Posts: 12,379

Joined: Jul 14 2008

Gold: 2,620.00

#883

Jul 14 2015 03:00pm

Quote (thesnipa @ 14 Jul 2015 15:53)

age of consent. before you are an adult you cant make choice on your own behalf, some consider sin to follow the law in this sense.

Christians who believe that young children that die go to hell have always perplexed me, fetuses moreso.

Fair enough, but where is the age of consent clause in the Bible?

Voyaging

Member

Posts: 63,058

Joined: Jul 15 2005

Gold: 152.00

#884

Jul 14 2015 03:01pm

Quote (Devil_kin @ Jul 14 2015 04:56pm)

http://i.imgur.com/MTc8o8t.jpg

LOL

Skinned

Member

Posts: 57,901

Joined: Dec 3 2008

Gold: 286.00

#885

Jul 14 2015 03:04pm

Quote (ThatAlex @ Jul 14 2015 04:00pm)

Fair enough, but where is the age of consent clause in the Bible?

The part about following positive laws, something about give onto Caesar.

Valhalls_Sun

Member

Posts: 10,566

Joined: May 31 2013

Gold: 0.76

#886

Jul 14 2015 03:06pm

Quote (ThatAlex @ 14 Jul 2015 15:50)

By that definition, then I think some cases of miscarriage could be classified as involuntary manslaughter, like the link Duffman shared.

Back to the more religious-themed question since this is the atheist thread:

If abortion is murder because it is intentionally killing human life, is miscarriage god's wrath? Did he intend for that fetus to die?

Is the fetus saved? Does the fetus go to hell for eternity? Maybe there is some special exception?

[/B]

Miscarriage is just a bad thing happening to a person, it happens all the time To follow the Christian View to answer your questions first No God promises that he won't come down and judge men until the final time. So no

According to most Christian denominations a person is enveloped in prevenient grace until they decide to take Christ as their savior.

thesnipa

Member

Posts: 93,001

Joined: Dec 31 2007

Gold: 2,299.94

#887

Jul 14 2015 03:10pm

Quote (ThatAlex @ Jul 14 2015 03:00pm)

Fair enough, but where is the age of consent clause in the Bible?

the bible doesn't cover every physically possible situation on the planet earth, nor is it written in modern english. interpretations and variations are the answer you are looking for, thought they are not direct.

Skinned

Member

Posts: 57,901

Joined: Dec 3 2008

Gold: 286.00

#888

Jul 14 2015 03:16pm

Quote (thesnipa @ Jul 14 2015 04:10pm)

I have a book about the history of abortion through cultures over time, I'm sure ancient Judaism is covered. Jesus seemed to be really into kosher law.

Devil_kin

Member

Posts: 32,208

Joined: Nov 27 2010

Gold: 159.02

#889

Jul 14 2015 03:17pm

Quote (Skinned @ 14 Jul 2015 15:16)

I have a book about the history of abortion through cultures over time, I'm sure ancient Judaism is covered. Jesus seemed to be really into kosher law.

bet that's a treat to read

Valhalls_Sun

Member

Posts: 10,566

Joined: May 31 2013

Gold: 0.76

#890

Jul 14 2015 03:18pm

Quote (Skinned @ 14 Jul 2015 15:23)

He thinks a woman accidentally dropping her infant into a wood chipper is a miscarriage :lol:

More like a fumble.

Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List