Quote (bogie160 @ Mar 18 2022 11:02pm)
Yes, but popular with whom? Not conservatives, for certain. David French is relevant today because he has spent the better part of the last 6 years carrying the water of the establishment-left. He's an Eric Snowden, locked in a foreign court and doing the needful to ensure that he's fed and watered. The minute he's not useful, he'll be cast out. There's no room for contemporary Christian thought on the left, and no room for moral thought at all for that matter. Either you subordinate morality to secular left-dogma, or you're out.
In the recent history of the right, there's never been much of a market for serious, intellectual conservative writers, even before Trump. The popular right-wing media figures are the ones who put out "boob bait for Bubba", like Rush, O'Reilly, Hannity, etc. It's not even related to policy issues, like free trade or the Iraq war, because the people I listed all supported free trade and the Iraq war. But those "boob bait for Bubba" guys all changed what they believed to fit the whims of their audience.
I disagree with your characterization of French. He's often a critic of the modern right, sure, any conservative with a triple digit IQ should be. But he's always maintained his traditional conservative beliefs. There's nothing inherently establishment-left about acknowledging racism exists, or opposing qualified immunity.
There will always be room at many mainstream political outlets for conservative voices. It's not like this is a phenomenon that only began once Trump came down the escalator. Important caveat though, Time and The Atlantic won't hire the sort of contrarian propagandists that French talks about.
Quote (Black XistenZ @ Mar 19 2022 03:01am)
This "contrarian faction" on the right only exists because the mainstream of the GOP refused to address their very justified concerns and criticisms for several decades. Trump's rise was the consequence, rather than the precursor, of this deep-running and almost reflexive anti-establishment sentiment on the right. The "mainstream Republicans" betrayed the priorities of a big chunk of their voters and put up nothing but token resistance against the triumph of liberalism for so long that voters on the right started considering them closeted allies of the liberals and part of "the swamp".
Trump and trumpism are the monsters created by the very people who bemoan their rise the most, people like David French or David Frum. The root cause is not that conservative rank and file suddenly lost their minds or entered a mass psychosis for no good reason - no, the root cause is that conservative elites failed to do their job and racked up too many "losses". But they still don't get that. :rolleyes: (And then, when they were headed toward the much-deserved "punishment" and much-deserved reality check in the form of a second Trump term, they got bailed out by a once-in-a-century pandemic. *sigh*)
That's a lot of work to defend people who think irrationally.
This post was edited by IceMage on Mar 19 2022 06:08am