d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Iron Curtain 2.0
Prev1789101112Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 3,046
Joined: Oct 1 2021
Gold: 1,979.01
Mar 9 2022 11:36am
Quote (Saucisson6000 @ Mar 9 2022 07:59am)
OK so you are proposing to 1/ surrending to Russia, 2/ to remove actual democratically elected government of Ukraine (and to let Russian put his own), and 3/ to partially pay yourself a part of damage done by Russia.


=> no comment .


That you suddenly see Ukraine as some sort of deeply-respected nation state with a completely legitimate and democratic government steeped in the values of fair elections and republicanism shows how susceptible to propaganda you are on this subject. Look into it.
Member
Posts: 66,666
Joined: May 17 2005
Gold: 17,384.69
Mar 9 2022 11:42am
Quote (Nibthebarb @ 9 Mar 2022 17:36)
That you suddenly see Ukraine as some sort of deeply-respected nation state with a completely legitimate and democratic government steeped in the values of fair elections and republicanism shows how susceptible to propaganda you are on this subject. Look into it.


Watch yourself
Member
Posts: 50,834
Joined: Jan 20 2010
Gold: 5,846.00
Mar 9 2022 11:43am
Quote (thesnipa @ Mar 9 2022 11:35am)
so correct me if i'm wrong but the tough line would then have been to mobilize troops into and heavily arm Ukraine against an invasion as Putin rallied troops on the entire border to ready an invasion. essentially crating a defacto nato member that we're required to defend should Russia invade, or in the best case Putin then bolsters his entire border with basically every other nation to the east, but we're also risking all out war.


Pretty much. There are degrees of it- sending more military aid for ukrainians to use vs having a fleet in the sea vs troops on the border vs troops inside ukraine vs preemptively invading russia vs nuking the kremlin.
But there's no real way we could have staved off a Ukrainian invasion without it being a de facto NATO member, which is what the whole point of the Russian invasion is to preempt in the first place.
Trump crossed over that red line when he sent lethal arms to Ukraine, and Putin can cite that as pretext, but Trump never went full blown military deployment and we can't know what he would have done in the same scenario, or if that scenario exists only but for him losing. And we sure can't gauge what Trump actually would have done by what he's saying now either. Or for that matter, even what he'd say if he was in power.

Quote (Nibthebarb @ Mar 9 2022 11:36am)
That you suddenly see Ukraine as some sort of deeply-respected nation state with a completely legitimate and democratic government steeped in the values of fair elections and republicanism shows how susceptible to propaganda you are on this subject. Look into it.


Insurrections and nazi war criminals are good now bruh. Its why PBS was giving a puff piece interview to that mayor with a framed picture of a holocaust architect on his wall without a hint of skepticism or irony. Its not Saucy who sees Ukraine as some sort of golden shining example of liberty and democracy, its the entire neoliberal world order in the US and EU.

This post was edited by Goomshill on Mar 9 2022 11:46am
Member
Posts: 92,975
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,299.94
Mar 9 2022 11:48am
Quote (Goomshill @ Mar 9 2022 12:43pm)
Pretty much. There are degrees of it- sending more military aid for ukrainians to use vs having a fleet in the sea vs troops on the border vs troops inside ukraine vs preemptively invading russia vs nuking the kremlin.
But there's no real way we could have staved off a Ukrainian invasion without it being a de facto NATO member, which is what the whole point of the Russian invasion is to preempt in the first place.
Trump crossed over that red line when he sent lethal arms to Ukraine, and Putin can cite that as pretext, but Trump never went full blown military deployment and we can't know what he would have done in the same scenario, or if that scenario exists only but for him losing. And we sure can't gauge what Trump actually would have done by what he's saying now either. Or for that matter, even what he'd say if he was in power.



Insurrections and nazi war criminals are good now bruh. Its why PBS was giving a puff piece interview to that mayor with a framed picture of a holocaust architect on his wall without a hint of skepticism or irony. Its not Saucy who sees Ukraine as some sort of golden shining example of liberty and democracy, its the entire neoliberal world order in the US and EU.


we made false heroes of the soviets because they helped beat the nazis, only to make false heroes of the nazis because they are fighting the Russians.

time really is a circle.
Member
Posts: 31,667
Joined: Dec 29 2016
Gold: 291,611.20
Warn: 10%
Mar 9 2022 05:05pm
Quote (thesnipa @ Mar 9 2022 12:48pm)
we made false heroes of the soviets because they helped beat the nazis, only to make false heroes of the nazis because they are fighting the Russians.

time really is a circle.


What did the nazi's do wrong in the eyes of the west other than invade czechoslovakia.
Britan Gleefully supported them up until that point and wanted them to eventually invade russia.
Member
Posts: 50,834
Joined: Jan 20 2010
Gold: 5,846.00
Mar 9 2022 07:51pm
https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1566069/russia-will-nationalize-assets-of-foreign-firms-that-leave-ruling-party

Unsurprising reciprocal action by Russia. Now pushing a bill in the federal assembly that says that if a firm is more than 25% foreign owned by hostile states and has declared it will withdraw from Russian markets, they can seize the firm's assets and put them into external administration. Companies will have five days to change their minds and resume, or sell their company to new owners who will resume business in Russia, otherwise a court will appoint administration for three months of nationalized operations before its liquidation to private ownershio.

at face value its more evenhanded than "seize their yachts now, come up with a plan later"
Member
Posts: 53,368
Joined: Sep 2 2004
Gold: 57.00
Mar 10 2022 12:17am
https://www.classical-music.com/news/cardiff-philharmonic-removes-tchaikovsky-from-programme-in-light-of-russian-invasion-of-ukraine/

V For Vendetta came true 16 years later. Tchaikovsky’s 1812 Overture has been banned by High Chancellor adam sutler “I’m Helping”
Member
Posts: 9,899
Joined: May 7 2006
Gold: 550.00
Mar 10 2022 12:38am
wild to me how many people on this forum want to boost russia to score some political points against dems instead of standing for democracy
Member
Posts: 50,834
Joined: Jan 20 2010
Gold: 5,846.00
Mar 10 2022 01:42am
Russia's VTB and other major banks are now offering deposit accounts in RMB, in addition to SWIFT being replaced by China's UnionPay. Erdogan and Putin held a phone call on Sunday and details are out, Erdogan agreed to trade with Russia using the Ruble, RMB or Gold, instead of the USD or Euro. What we're seeing isn't the gradual decline of US petrodollar dominance of world markets, what we're seeing is someone launching it out of a cannon to see how fast it can be done. Its not just going to be dominos gently knocking down one by one, its going to be the entire board blown down. As soon as they start trading oil for RMB, the dollar is jeopardized.
Member
Posts: 28,880
Joined: Aug 11 2013
Gold: 10,712.00
Mar 10 2022 05:54am
Quote (Goomshill @ Mar 10 2022 02:42am)
Russia's VTB and other major banks are now offering deposit accounts in RMB, in addition to SWIFT being replaced by China's UnionPay. Erdogan and Putin held a phone call on Sunday and details are out, Erdogan agreed to trade with Russia using the Ruble, RMB or Gold, instead of the USD or Euro. What we're seeing isn't the gradual decline of US petrodollar dominance of world markets, what we're seeing is someone launching it out of a cannon to see how fast it can be done. Its not just going to be dominos gently knocking down one by one, its going to be the entire board blown down. As soon as they start trading oil for RMB, the dollar is jeopardized.


damn, really thought this would be a multi year transition
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1789101112Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll