Quote (IceMage @ 29 Oct 2020 01:09)
To me this looks like a childish justification from someone who is upset at the political landscape.
I am indeed upset with the political landscape. The policies or ideologies which are commonly referred to as "right-wing populism" are my political home, and they were under- or unrepresented for the longest time. It seems, however, that I'm not alone in this sentiment. These right-wing populist parties have popped up across the world in recent years. Many of them saw unprecedented success. There must be a reason for this global political trend, a reason which goes beyond Trump or his personality cult. The emergence of right-wing populism has to do with the state of the (western) world and the direction its mainstream political leaders want to steer it. Voters from all around the world did not all of a sudden become childish, there are good, substantive reasons for this frustration with the (old) political landscape.
Quote
Trump using his personality cult to destroy people who criticize him for obvious missteps might make you feel good
No, it does not. Let's be real for a second here: I defended Trump's endless controversies and shitty behavior for all those years because I like his policies and put policy over personality. Do you seriously think that I
enjoyed having to do that, do you seriously think I enjoyed having to bend over backwards and push the boundaries of my own integrity to defend the man I wanted to see succeed, no matter how big his personal short-comings were?
Quote
but it's not the same thing as ideologically realigning the party. Not even close. Republican voters today are more supportive of tariffs, not because Trump made a convincing argument, but because they are part of a personality cult, and thus go along with whatever he says. So when he goes away at some point, the lasting impact on the party and voters will be more temperamental than ideological.
So moderate Democrats are "corporate Democrats" and the left-wingers are insane and dangerous. Again, I think your statements here are childish. It makes you feel good when people you don't like on the left are triggered. But how does that help move the country forward? How does it help your ideological movement? Success might look like bringing Democrats on Trump's side to get certain things done. Pissing them off accomplishes nothing.
Ideologically realigning the GOP in a direction that I preferred on policy grounds, and potentially bringing some Democrats on his side to form a lasting majority coalition, similar to FDR's new deal coaliton or Reagan's silent majority - that's indeed what I had hoped for at the start of Trump's presidency. In hindsight, this hope was always unrealistic. I still believe that the opening to do just that was there, but I should have seen that Trump's personality would always stand in the way and prevent him from ever forming a majority coalition.
I'm not so sure about the importance of the personality cult vs Trump adjusting his policy position to the sentiment which is already prevalent among the base. It imho is also totally up in the air whether the ideological realignment of the GOP under Trump will persist after he's gone, or if the party will revert back to where it was under Bush or Romney.