d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Arizona Takes A Massive Step Backwards
Prev1789101112Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 22,435
Joined: Mar 3 2007
Gold: 106.11
Apr 10 2024 09:15pm
Quote (Black XistenZ @ Apr 10 2024 07:56pm)
Imho, there is very little practical difference between an outright mandate and threatening people to lose their jobs if they don't get vaccinated.

Imagine a nutter right-wing state enacting a law that allows for abortions, but any women who ever got one will be added to a government-run blacklist and ineligible for public employment going forward (and fired from her current job if she's already employed at the state or municipal level) - would that qualify as a "government infringment on bodily autonomy" in your eyes?




In case anyone cares or wonders: I'm pro-choice, triple vaccinated myself, but staunchly against vaccine mandates. The point I'm getting to is that while I agree with lefties on the "bodily autonomy" argument in the abortion debate, I consider most of them hypocrites because they shat all over bodily autonomy during the covid era.


I see them as quite different, and I prefer to stick to real potentials rather than getting into hypotheticals.

This post was edited by Handcuffs on Apr 10 2024 09:36pm
Member
Posts: 19,223
Joined: Oct 23 2003
Gold: 7,104.95
Apr 10 2024 09:29pm
Quote (Ryvulet @ Apr 10 2024 06:32pm)
Waaah peopel have to deal with their consequences oh shit! Good! I bet your ignorant ass didn't realize that there were less kids out of wedlock and not having shit when peopel had consequences. Notice how it spiked when abortion became a thing?


so you admit its all about punishing the mother? i love when people have mask-off moments like this.
who do you think will really bear the punishment, the mother who is likely living near the poverty level or her child that has drastically lower odds at succeeding in life?
anti-abortion bible thumpers havent EVER given a shit about the babies, its about punishing people for having sex but youre too dense to see the child suffers. is that what you want? more people suffering?
absolutely psychotic religion-fueled delusion

This post was edited by gnarjay on Apr 10 2024 09:30pm
Member
Posts: 54,032
Joined: Jun 1 2010
Gold: 1.74
Apr 10 2024 11:05pm
Quote (gnarjay @ 10 Apr 2024 23:29)
so you admit its all about punishing the mother? i love when people have mask-off moments like this.
who do you think will really bear the punishment, the mother who is likely living near the poverty level or her child that has drastically lower odds at succeeding in life?
anti-abortion bible thumpers havent EVER given a shit about the babies, its about punishing people for having sex but youre too dense to see the child suffers. is that what you want? more people suffering?
absolutely psychotic religion-fueled delusion


Dude is delusional tbh. Bible thumpers? Doesn’t take that to be anti-abortion for w.e reason the people involved want
Member
Posts: 54,082
Joined: May 26 2005
Gold: 4,945.67
Apr 10 2024 11:32pm
Quote (Handcuffs @ 11 Apr 2024 05:15)
I see them as quite different, and I prefer to stick to real potentials rather than getting into hypotheticals.

"If you insist on your bodily autonomy, we will ruin your livelihood and exclude you from nearly all facets of social life" isn't really much different if you ask me. In some aspects, it's even worse since women from states where abortion is banned can still get the procedure elsewhere and then resume their previous life while those who didn't want to get vaccinated had no way out.

You're of course free to disagree, but I stand by my point. Those who are pro-choice because they ostensibly value bodily autonomy so much while also supporting vaccine mandates, are massive hypocrites.

This post was edited by Black XistenZ on Apr 10 2024 11:32pm
Member
Posts: 22,435
Joined: Mar 3 2007
Gold: 106.11
Apr 10 2024 11:53pm
Quote (Black XistenZ @ Apr 10 2024 10:32pm)
"If you insist on your bodily autonomy, we will ruin your livelihood and exclude you from nearly all facets of social life" isn't really much different if you ask me. In some aspects, it's even worse since women from states where abortion is banned can still get the procedure elsewhere and then resume their previous life while those who didn't want to get vaccinated had no way out.

You're of course free to disagree, but I stand by my point. Those who are pro-choice because they ostensibly value bodily autonomy so much while also supporting vaccine mandates, are massive hypocrites.


Perhaps you can take that umbrage up with them.
Member
Posts: 66,666
Joined: May 17 2005
Gold: 17,384.69
Apr 11 2024 03:07am
Quote (Black XistenZ @ Apr 11 2024 07:32am)
"If you insist on your bodily autonomy, we will ruin your livelihood and exclude you from nearly all facets of social life" isn't really much different if you ask me. In some aspects, it's even worse since women from states where abortion is banned can still get the procedure elsewhere and then resume their previous life while those who didn't want to get vaccinated had no way out.

You're of course free to disagree, but I stand by my point. Those who are pro-choice because they ostensibly value bodily autonomy so much while also supporting vaccine mandates, are massive hypocrites.


Didn't know abortion was contagious and lethal to this point. This was a fatal non-sense.
Member
Posts: 46,928
Joined: Sep 5 2016
Gold: 100.00
Apr 11 2024 03:11am
abortionists
Member
Posts: 26,862
Joined: Feb 27 2013
Gold: 4,445.68
Apr 11 2024 12:32pm
Quote (Black XistenZ @ Apr 10 2024 10:32pm)
"If you insist on your bodily autonomy, we will ruin your livelihood and exclude you from nearly all facets of social life" isn't really much different if you ask me. In some aspects, it's even worse since women from states where abortion is banned can still get the procedure elsewhere and then resume their previous life while those who didn't want to get vaccinated had no way out.

You're of course free to disagree, but I stand by my point. Those who are pro-choice because they ostensibly value bodily autonomy so much while also supporting vaccine mandates, are massive hypocrites.


Vaccine "mandates" were heavily unenforced in every state, and basically all employers had exemptions in place along with policies stating you could continue without a vaccine as long as you worked remotely or had a negative Covid test every two weeks. The only place that took it semi-seriously was the TSA if you were a non-citizen coming into the US.

Texas, Missouri and Tennessee have also made efforts to ban getting an abortion in other areas. 5 counties in Texas, including Lubbock, have an ordinance that ban people from transporting others along local roads for abortions. Pretty clear signal of their true intentions. I'm sure Florida isn't too far behind considering they attempted to pass a bill to allow adults to kidnap their trans children and prevent them from going across state lines despite custody agreements.

Also bodily autonomy isn't a black and white issue where you believe an individual can do absolutely anything to their body. That's why controlled substance abuse is illegal. It's about making decisions about one's body without undue control or policing. You'd be hard-pressed to find someone who believes in a wide spread ban of alcohol just because they believe in bodily autonomy.
Member
Posts: 28,868
Joined: Aug 11 2013
Gold: 10,712.00
Apr 11 2024 01:02pm
Quote (MrSK @ Apr 11 2024 02:32pm)
Vaccine "mandates" were heavily unenforced in every state, and basically all employers had exemptions in place along with policies stating you could continue without a vaccine as long as you worked remotely or had a negative Covid test every two weeks. The only place that took it semi-seriously was the TSA if you were a non-citizen coming into the US.

Texas, Missouri and Tennessee have also made efforts to ban getting an abortion in other areas. 5 counties in Texas, including Lubbock, have an ordinance that ban people from transporting others along local roads for abortions. Pretty clear signal of their true intentions. I'm sure Florida isn't too far behind considering they attempted to pass a bill to allow adults to kidnap their trans children and prevent them from going across state lines despite custody agreements.

Also bodily autonomy isn't a black and white issue where you believe an individual can do absolutely anything to their body. That's why controlled substance abuse is illegal. It's about making decisions about one's body without undue control or policing. You'd be hard-pressed to find someone who believes in a wide spread ban of alcohol just because they believe in bodily autonomy.


Simply untrue. Many corporations eventually asked employees to get vaccinated or potentially lose their jobs. I know people that said no and were let go. I switched jobs in 2022 and I was literally mandated to provide proof of vaccine as pre-requisite for employment. Vaccine mandates were widespread pretty much most of the white collar world.

This post was edited by ofthevoid on Apr 11 2024 01:04pm
Member
Posts: 26,862
Joined: Feb 27 2013
Gold: 4,445.68
Apr 11 2024 01:12pm
Quote (ofthevoid @ Apr 11 2024 12:02pm)
Simply untrue. Many corporations eventually asked employees to get vaccinated or potentially lose their jobs. I know people that said no and were let go. I switched jobs in 2022 and I was literally mandated to provide proof of vaccine as pre-requisite for employment. Vaccine mandates were widespread pretty much most of the white collar world.


That is a corporation/employer level and not a state level. CDC and OSHA merely gave out guidelines and employers enacted whatever they saw fit to put in their employee policy, which is their right in a free market such as the US. Federal employees had a mandate but that also had legal exemptions.

This post was edited by MrSK on Apr 11 2024 01:13pm
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1789101112Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll