d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Russian Arms Dealer Swapped For Brittney Griner
Prev167891012Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 49,289
Joined: Jun 18 2006
Gold: 11.77
Dec 8 2022 01:36pm
Quote (bogie160 @ Dec 8 2022 02:13pm)
Whether it's arms dealing or mercenaries, they're effectively extensions of the Russian government. Bout's value isn't personal, he's not going to do any deals, but it's a message that Putin will come and get those who work for the regime.

The US doesn't negotiate with terrorists because they don't want to encourage the taking of American hostages. The Economist ran an analysis a few years back, and true to form, Americans were far less likely to be taken hostage overseas. If the United States won't pay you, and you're likely to get an air strike for your trouble, the cost benefit analysis is pretty clear-cut. The same rule should have applied here. If Russia wants to grab WNBA players for weed, then don't bring weed to Russia, or preferably don't go at all.


Well, Bogie agrees with me on the point of Bout being taken back, but I'd like to get some feedback from people who know Russia.

On the broader point of hostages in hostile countries, I don't think this is anything new. Trump received that brain dead kid from North Korea. There are others in recent history where America gives up something to receive our own from hostile states. I view prisoners/hostages from hostile states differently than those who are held by terrorist groups. Hostile states have much more legitimacy than terrorist groups.

This post was edited by IceMage on Dec 8 2022 01:38pm
Member
Posts: 29,432
Joined: Mar 24 2011
Gold: 489.70
Warn: 40%
Dec 8 2022 01:49pm
Quote (bogie160 @ 8 Dec 2022 13:13)
Whether it's arms dealing or mercenaries, they're effectively extensions of the Russian government. Bout's value isn't personal, he's not going to do any deals, but it's a message that Putin will come and get those who work for the regime.

The US doesn't negotiate with terrorists because they don't want to encourage the taking of American hostages. The Economist ran an analysis a few years back, and true to form, Americans were far less likely to be taken hostage overseas. If the United States won't pay you, and you're likely to get an air strike for your trouble, the cost benefit analysis is pretty clear-cut. The same rule should have applied here. If Russia wants to grab WNBA players for weed, then don't bring weed to Russia, or preferably don't go at all.


Well said +1
Member
Posts: 13,313
Joined: May 20 2004
Gold: 253.00
Dec 8 2022 04:32pm
I don't like Brittney Griner or what she stands for but nothing she has done warrants time in a Russian Gulag, there are few crimes that do. The trade was crap, and it actually reminds me of TWD when Neegan told Rick that he just slid his dick down Rick's throat and Rick thanked him for it. I'll leave it to you to figure out who is who in the analogy.
Member
Posts: 33,358
Joined: Dec 20 2007
Gold: 11,245.00
Dec 8 2022 05:15pm
Absolutely fucking disgusting.
Member
Posts: 150,002
Joined: Apr 19 2005
Gold: 290.11
Dec 8 2022 06:05pm
The best part about this is the right wing poster boy being Paul Whelan, the former Marine currently locked up in Russia still. People sharing his pic with his story as if he was left behind, what a disgrace, etc.

....yet don't even realize he was court-martialed in 2008 for attempted larceny, false statements, dereliction of duty, and other offenses and received a bad conduct discharge from the Marine Corps. :wallbash:
Member
Posts: 10,146
Joined: Jan 19 2008
Gold: 455,241.49
Dec 8 2022 08:37pm
Quote (Sixers @ Dec 8 2022 06:05pm)
The best part about this is the right wing poster boy being Paul Whelan, the former Marine currently locked up in Russia still. People sharing his pic with his story as if he was left behind, what a disgrace, etc.

....yet don't even realize he was court-martialed in 2008 for attempted larceny, false statements, dereliction of duty, and other offenses and received a bad conduct discharge from the Marine Corps. :wallbash:


Geez, sounds like he did everything except some low level stupidity like accidentally smuggle marijuana product into Russia like a complete moron, good thing we aren't bringing home someone who broke the law and got themselves into trouble so that we have to bail them out at our own geopolitical expense . . . oh . . . wait . . . nevermind . . .

This post was edited by softcoresux on Dec 8 2022 08:39pm
Member
Posts: 43,761
Joined: Aug 27 2009
Gold: 63,142.89
Dec 8 2022 10:40pm
This begs the question of what will it be like for American athletes traveling to unstable countries in the future. It happened in Russia this time, but it could happen somewhere else next time. It seems to send a message to other governments that it can be rewarding to nab a celebrity and trump up some charges in hopes that they can be used as a bargaining chip.

I don't think it's a coincidence that this exchange happened shortly after the US was eliminated from the World Cup in Qatar. That would have been a prime opportunity for a player to be caught breaking one of the murky and inconsistent rules there. The question is what will the US have to trade the next time a female Olympian gets caught wearing a skirt that doesn't extend below the ankle.

This post was edited by Kayeto on Dec 8 2022 10:42pm
Member
Posts: 6,408
Joined: Aug 3 2009
Gold: 10.00
Dec 10 2022 02:41am
Quote (SwamiVivekananda @ Dec 8 2022 06:00pm)
Anyone who thinks this was even close to a fair swap is suffering severe brain damage and should probably head to the ER immediately.

I'm sure a pot-smoking WNBA player who only SJW's give a shit about can do so much for our country! Forget the real POW's who Biden neglected despite saying, "We tried".

As for those who also think an International Arms Dealer can't do shit from prison in Russia you are sadly mistaken. He now has access not only to his people but is closer to his assets as well.

#BidenISaCUCK

# If you bring cannabis on a plane to a country that it's illegal you should serve out every day for being retarded.


Agree 100% with this. The US Marine is the one who should have came home they had a choice of who to pick but they chose a POS over a service member who fought for their country. Sad day
Member
Posts: 3,908
Joined: Jun 20 2022
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 30%
Dec 10 2022 03:20am
Quote (Rare_Rose8830 @ Dec 10 2022 02:41am)
Agree 100% with this. The US Marine is the one who should have came home they had a choice of who to pick but they chose a POS over a service member who fought for their country. Sad day



There is another us citizen, name escapes me at the moment, who is in a labor camp in Russia for the past few years for the same thing, besides him being a medical marijuana user.

Also this is pretty sketchy. It seems original reporting stated there was a choice, and later edited to align with the white house’s “official response”.


This post was edited by YeeHaw on Dec 10 2022 03:21am
Member
Posts: 6,408
Joined: Aug 3 2009
Gold: 10.00
Dec 10 2022 03:32am
Quote (YeeHaw @ Dec 10 2022 11:20am)
There is another us citizen, name escapes me at the moment, who is in a labor camp in Russia for the past few years for the same thing, besides him being a medical marijuana user.

Also this is pretty sketchy. It seems original reporting stated there was a choice, and later edited to align with the white house’s “official response”.


Yes I saw that report also crazy just shows who they really care about
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev167891012Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll