d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Should Trans Women Be Able To
Prev167891020Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 45,719
Joined: Aug 25 2008
Gold: 40,130.00
Apr 2 2022 06:48am
Quote (JessiWan @ 31 Mar 2022 09:22)
compete in women's sports.

I was having this discussion with someone on another forum. He said that once a trans woman athlete has started hormone therapy (that either mimics female hormones or otherwise suppresses testosterone) for a period of time, all the physical and physiological advantages that "she" has had over cis-females will be gone. Apparently, according to him, estrogen has a "weakening" effect on a person's body. But to me, if a trans woman's physiology is sufficiently weakened by estrogen, wouldn't a cis woman's be weakened even further, because the latter has had estrogen in her body for longer than the former?

And this doesn't even take into account things that are structural, things that cannot be undone by hormone replacement. Such as having a bigger heart, being of greater height, having greater lung capacity..etc and many more. All of these things are barely altered by simply placing the body on hormone therapy.

Apparently, some people think it's bad to exclude trans women from participating in women's sports. They want sports to be inclusive and open to all. However, I feel that this can result in unfairness to cis women. We make two teams, one for men and the other for women, for a reason. It's because we recognize that it's not fair to make women compete against biological men.

Anyway I would like your thoughts.


In my personal opinion no.
Please take note that I am from Singapore.
Member
Posts: 57,901
Joined: Dec 3 2008
Gold: 286.00
Apr 2 2022 06:52am
Quote (sirthom @ Apr 2 2022 08:41am)
Tranny=abused
Don't allow abuse and boom, no trannies.
Was ez.


But that just isn't the case at all. Most people coming out don't have any allies and even their parents are trying to stop them from becoming themselves. They have to go out and find people who actually love and care about them in the world because they don't find that at home sometimes. In people who have a supportive family and community they are fine but when every social force in the world invalidates your identity and experience day by day it leads to very negative inner experiences. I imagine the trauma isn't very different from being a combat veteran in the sense that you are wounded in a way that nobody else could ever understand. I encourage people to be comfortable in their own bodies as much as possible and have self-empathy and I encourage the same for you. If you have self-empathy you might start having empathy for others :)

People talking about gender identity at school aren't making kids gay Sirthom, they are encouraging kids who would otherwise struggle with self-love be able to accept their own identity. There aren't more homosexual and transgendered children, there are just less of a percentage of them forced by their families and schools to live in the closet. This is okay.

Look, I've never changed a bigot's mind when they've said "X category of people should not have rights/exist", be it Jew, mentally ill person, sexual minority, racial minority, doesn't really matter, it is literally all the same thing. In the end we will just agree to disagree Sirthom. But I hope you grow into some understanding and empathy.

I'll probably be suspended for this post for some fucking reason so I might not be able to respond for awhile.

Quote
d2jsp Notifier Suspension for Flaming 1 day ago

d2jsp Notifier Suspension for Spam 2 days ago

d2jsp Notifier Topic Moved Notification 4 days ago

d2jsp Notifier Suspension for Vulgarity 6 days ago

d2jsp Notifier Suspension for Harassment 9 days ago

d2jsp Notifier Suspension for Flaming Feb 4 2022

d2jsp Notifier Suspension for Flaming Feb 4 2022

d2jsp Notifier Suspension for Vulgarity Jan 28 2022

d2jsp Notifier Suspension for Flaming Jan 1 2022


Just this year. I'm definitely a piece of shit. I'm trying to be civil guys.

This post was edited by Skinned on Apr 2 2022 06:52am
Member
Posts: 23,970
Joined: Feb 28 2007
Gold: 35,554.14
Warn: 10%
Apr 2 2022 06:55am
Quote (Skinned @ Apr 2 2022 07:52am)
But that just isn't the case at all. Most people coming out don't have any allies and even their parents are trying to stop them from becoming themselves. They have to go out and find people who actually love and care about them in the world because they don't find that at home sometimes. In people who have a supportive family and community they are fine but when every social force in the world invalidates your identity and experience day by day it leads to very negative inner experiences. I imagine the trauma isn't very different from being a combat veteran in the sense that you are wounded in a way that nobody else could ever understand. I encourage people to be comfortable in their own bodies as much as possible and have self-empathy and I encourage the same for you. If you have self-empathy you might start having empathy for others :)

People talking about gender identity at school aren't making kids gay Sirthom, they are encouraging kids who would otherwise struggle with self-love be able to accept their own identity. There aren't more homosexual and transgendered children, there are just less of a percentage of them forced by their families and schools to live in the closet. This is okay.

Look, I've never changed a bigot's mind when they've said "X category of people should not have rights/exist", be it Jew, mentally ill person, sexual minority, racial minority, doesn't really matter, it is literally all the same thing. In the end we will just agree to disagree Sirthom. But I hope you grow into some understanding and empathy.

I'll probably be suspended for this post for some fucking reason so I might not be able to respond for awhile.



Just this year. I'm definitely a piece of shit. I'm trying to be civil guys.


Didn't read.
Condense if want me to.
I am fine if don't.
Member
Posts: 9,415
Joined: Jan 1 2007
Gold: 0.00
Apr 2 2022 06:55am
Quote (sirthom @ Apr 3 2022 01:27am)
Live???
I completely agree.



Hahahaha savage
Member
Posts: 2,877
Joined: Oct 1 2007
Gold: 103.00
Apr 2 2022 06:55am
Guild: Transcend
Member
Posts: 23,970
Joined: Feb 28 2007
Gold: 35,554.14
Warn: 10%
Apr 2 2022 07:01am
Quote (CheatEngine @ Apr 2 2022 07:55am)
Guild: Transcend


Yes, as in send the trans to the abyss.
Ty for pointing that out.

There is only one way to stop an egg sucking dog.

Member
Posts: 22,265
Joined: Aug 17 2021
Gold: 1,546.83
Warn: 30%
Apr 2 2022 09:01pm
Quote (Skinned @ Apr 2 2022 05:52am)


People talking about gender identity at school aren't making kids gay Sirthom, they are encouraging kids who would otherwise struggle with self-love be able to accept their own identity.


If this were their goal then they should be doing this for all kinds of freaks, people like furries or necrophiliacs. But they don't. They also focus on the sexually deviant because they want to make sure there are as few breeding white people as possible.
Member
Posts: 49,893
Joined: Jun 19 2006
Gold: 3.88
Apr 2 2022 09:17pm
Quote (JessiWan @ Apr 3 2022 01:01pm)
If this were their goal then they should be doing this for all kinds of freaks, people like furries or necrophiliacs. But they don't. They also focus on the sexually deviant because they want to make sure there are as few breeding white people as possible.


Your opinion on what is or is not a freak is valueless.
I would legit rather hang out with a regular trans person than someone as nasty as you literally any day of the week.
All you do is sit here attacking people 24/7..
Why would anyone value your opinion on literally anything?
Try becoming likeable before you try to foist your own hang ups on everyone else.

This post was edited by Plaguefear on Apr 2 2022 09:59pm
Member
Posts: 23,970
Joined: Feb 28 2007
Gold: 35,554.14
Warn: 10%
Apr 2 2022 09:26pm
Quote (Plaguefear @ Apr 2 2022 10:17pm)
Your opinion on what is or is not a freak is valueless.
I would legit rather hang out with a regular trans person than someone as nasty as you literally any day of the week.
All you do is sit here attacking people 24/7?
Why would anyone value your opinion on literally anything?
Try becoming likeable before you try to foist your own hang ups on everyone else.


No such thing, that is a dude in a dress.

Also, freak has a definition and her use of it coincides.
No opinion needed.

Lastly, facts don't care about your feels or why you want to hang out with dudes in dresses.
Member
Posts: 2,614
Joined: Sep 17 2021
Gold: 0.00
Apr 2 2022 09:29pm
why is it always trans women why dont they ever mention trans men what does it all mean bazal
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev167891020Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll