d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Trump Bodyslams Rand Paul Through The Table
Prev1678910Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 64,763
Joined: Oct 25 2006
Gold: 0.00
Aug 9 2020 11:28am
Quote (Bazi @ Aug 9 2020 12:19pm)
Right so no tax penalty with early withdraws with new provisions, but basically you have to clarify are you taking a loan from your 401k vs taking a withdrawal I guess. (?)

In regards to loan, my 401k is a roth401k so my contributions are post tax anyway - in regards to paying it back later, so I won’t be income taxed on it if I were to retrieve it now or at 59.5. What is this interest on the 401k loan, I don’t understand this interest on the loan that Thor is talking about - how do they come up with such a figure?


I think the loan thing might be dependent on who's handling your 401k. It was available to us when we moved, but I'm not sure if that's universal.
Member
Posts: 53,368
Joined: Sep 2 2004
Gold: 57.00
Aug 9 2020 11:44am
Quote (Bazi @ 9 Aug 2020 13:19)
Right so no tax penalty with early withdraws with new provisions, but basically you have to clarify are you taking a loan from your 401k vs taking a withdrawal I guess. (?)

In regards to loan, my 401k is a roth401k so my contributions are post tax anyway - in regards to paying it back later, so I won’t be income taxed on it if I were to retrieve it now or at 59.5. What is this interest on the 401k loan, I don’t understand this interest on the loan that Thor is talking about - how do they come up with such a figure?

yeah loan you have to pay back and withdrawal no, its yours to keep, so make sure youre sure on what you want to do. remember if you withdraw $50k for example itll take you 2.5 years to put that back in due to contribution limits, whereas with a loan you could theoretically put it all back in the next day by repaying it

interest is usually prime rate plus a little bit. so no matter what amount you borrow you’ll owe 4.25% or 4.5% in interest (which gets paid back into your retirement account anyways) and thats the annual rate. the effective interest rate will depend on what you set up your repayment term as (long repayment terms = higher effective rate but due to time but lower fixed payments on your repayment schedule)

This post was edited by excellence on Aug 9 2020 11:47am
Member
Posts: 41,270
Joined: Apr 14 2006
Gold: 1,788.71
Aug 9 2020 12:02pm
Quote (excellence @ Aug 9 2020 12:44pm)
yeah loan you have to pay back and withdrawal no, its yours to keep, so make sure youre sure on what you want to do. remember if you withdraw $50k for example itll take you 2.5 years to put that back in due to contribution limits, whereas with a loan you could theoretically put it all back in the next day by repaying it

interest is usually prime rate plus a little bit. so no matter what amount you borrow you’ll owe 4.25% or 4.5% in interest (which gets paid back into your retirement account anyways) and thats the annual rate. the effective interest rate will depend on what you set up your repayment term as (long repayment terms = higher effective rate but due to time but lower fixed payments on your repayment schedule)



Can you break contribution limits by taking a loan and paying xtra into your account via the interest on it ..?

Assuming U have contributed 19.5k after your “loan”

This post was edited by Bazi on Aug 9 2020 12:03pm
Member
Posts: 53,368
Joined: Sep 2 2004
Gold: 57.00
Aug 9 2020 12:19pm
Quote (Bazi @ 9 Aug 2020 14:02)
Can you break contribution limits by taking a loan and paying xtra into your account via the interest on it ..?

its not considered a contribution then. so in theory sure. max loan is $100k through the end of the year for right now then it goes back to $50k. so at 4.5% a 100k loan would be like 11-12k or so in interest over 5 years. which you could pay it all back then in theory (you would owe $112k, the loan term sheet would spell it all out for you)

and you can only do a certain number of loans in a set amount of time, i’m sure the 401k plan administrator would figure out what you were up to and tell you to knock it off

This post was edited by excellence on Aug 9 2020 12:21pm
Member
Posts: 41,270
Joined: Apr 14 2006
Gold: 1,788.71
Aug 9 2020 01:16pm
Quote (excellence @ Aug 9 2020 01:19pm)
its not considered a contribution then. so in theory sure. max loan is $100k through the end of the year for right now then it goes back to $50k. so at 4.5% a 100k loan would be like 11-12k or so in interest over 5 years. which you could pay it all back then in theory (you would owe $112k, the loan term sheet would spell it all out for you)

and you can only do a certain number of loans in a set amount of time, i’m sure the 401k plan administrator would figure out what you were up to and tell you to knock it off



Understood.

Interesting and thanks for your infos
Member
Posts: 57,901
Joined: Dec 3 2008
Gold: 286.00
Aug 9 2020 01:49pm
Quote (Bazi @ Aug 9 2020 12:54pm)
I have wondered this

If you borrow from your 401/403/ira early without the penalty - can you put that money back in this calendar year? scenario to clarify my questions:

Let’s say you have 100k in your 401k. You take out 50k, 50k remaining and you pause your contributions. By November your finances have changed - are you able to contribute 50k back to your 401k, or is it still capped at 19.5k for the year? Rather, are you able to contribute 69.5k at years end? (50k you borrowed from it, plus 19.5k yearly allotted contribution)

Thx for anyone with insights on this


Yes this is allowed on this fidelity account.

This post was edited by Skinned on Aug 9 2020 01:49pm
Member
Posts: 64,763
Joined: Oct 25 2006
Gold: 0.00
Aug 9 2020 01:53pm
Thinking about the 300 vs 100 unemployment benefit, I initially thought it was balanced, but now I can't imagine states have that available in their budgets. As was brought up earlier in the thread, states can't just print money, and especially now where their income is far lower than was planned for the year and expenses are likely higher I can't imagine most states have the money to put up even if they really wanted to.
Member
Posts: 57,266
Joined: Oct 14 2010
Gold: 56,946.92
Aug 9 2020 01:55pm
Been working through this whole shitfest.
Doesn't apply.
That tax break is nice though cause I've been keeping about an extra 300ish per check.
Member
Posts: 54,184
Joined: May 26 2005
Gold: 4,945.67
Aug 9 2020 04:02pm
Quote (Thor123422 @ 9 Aug 2020 21:53)
Thinking about the 300 vs 100 unemployment benefit, I initially thought it was balanced, but now I can't imagine states have that available in their budgets. As was brought up earlier in the thread, states can't just print money, and especially now where their income is far lower than was planned for the year and expenses are likely higher I can't imagine most states have the money to put up even if they really wanted to.


Couldnt they run some sketchy tax scheme where they raise state taxes by $100 per person per week and use this money to "unlock" the federal $300?

People would effectively only get $300/w that way, which might be a bit low for many families though.
Member
Posts: 61,688
Joined: Mar 14 2006
Gold: 28.77
Aug 9 2020 04:17pm
Quote (Bruv @ Aug 9 2020 12:55pm)
Been working through this whole shitfest.
Doesn't apply.
That tax break is nice though cause I've been keeping about an extra 300ish per check.



You don't get to keep it. It's a deferment, not a tax holiday. Don't spend it now or you're going to be fucked.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1678910Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll