d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > No Food Stamps (ebt) October?
Prev167891022Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 19,309
Joined: Feb 24 2018
Gold: 9,765.50
Oct 30 2025 07:57am
Would take that graph with a grain of salt.

The chart shared on social media originated from a June blog post from The Personal Finance Wizards, which cited “US Census Table S0201” as its source. The site offers financial advice, but published a disclaimer saying it cannot guarantee the “completeness, accuracy, or reliability” of its information.

The site’s authors appeared to cherry-pick groups to include in the chart, noting, “It’s important to note that the graph highlights a selection of ethnicities we felt would be most relevant and engaging for our audience.” It did not name an author.

In a comment on an Instagram post sharing the chart, Personal Finance Wizards shared a link to the US Census table it used. It shows data from the 2024 American Community Survey, filtered by 49 racial and ethnic groups. The filtered groups don’t completely overlap with the groups in the chart, but the dataset has a column for “households with food stamp/SNAP benefits”, which shows percentages similar to the ones in the chart.

The data does not show what percentage of all SNAP beneficiaries belong to an ethnic or nationality group.


According to the most recent USDA data available, from 2023, white people are the largest racial group receiving SNAP benefits, at 35.4 percent. African Americans are next, making up 25.7 percent of recipients, then Hispanic people at 15.6 percent, Asian people at 3.9 percent, Native Americans at 1.3 percent and multiracial people at 1 percent. The race of 17 percent of participants is unknown.


The same report found that 89.4 percent of SNAP recipients were US-born citizens, meaning less than 11 percent of SNAP participants were foreign-born. Of the latter figure, 6.2 percent were naturalised citizens, 1.1 percent were refugees and 3.3 percent were other noncitizens, including lawful permanent residents and other eligible noncitizens.



I am sure the usual groups are up there, I mean everyone here knows certain groups are more perished, fact is though the wealth gap has also increased 10 fold, and the middle and lower class are more dependent than ever. The good days are long, long gone and I only foresee more bad days coming until we somehow achieve some UBI but even that will be impacted by the wealth gap, have to keep the poors poor afterall.

As I expected, a cherry-picked graph.
Member
Posts: 9,097
Joined: May 11 2009
Gold: 5.01
Oct 30 2025 08:55am
Would take that graph with a grain of salt.

The chart shared on social media originated from a June blog post from The Personal Finance Wizards, which cited “US Census Table S0201” as its source. The site offers financial advice, but published a disclaimer saying it cannot guarantee the “completeness, accuracy, or reliability” of its information.

The site’s authors appeared to cherry-pick groups to include in the chart, noting, “It’s important to note that the graph highlights a selection of ethnicities we felt would be most relevant and engaging for our audience.” It did not name an author.

In a comment on an Instagram post sharing the chart, Personal Finance Wizards shared a link to the US Census table it used. It shows data from the 2024 American Community Survey, filtered by 49 racial and ethnic groups. The filtered groups don’t completely overlap with the groups in the chart, but the dataset has a column for “households with food stamp/SNAP benefits”, which shows percentages similar to the ones in the chart.

The data does not show what percentage of all SNAP beneficiaries belong to an ethnic or nationality group.


According to the most recent USDA data available, from 2023, white people are the largest racial group receiving SNAP benefits, at 35.4 percent. African Americans are next, making up 25.7 percent of recipients, then Hispanic people at 15.6 percent, Asian people at 3.9 percent, Native Americans at 1.3 percent and multiracial people at 1 percent. The race of 17 percent of participants is unknown.


The same report found that 89.4 percent of SNAP recipients were US-born citizens, meaning less than 11 percent of SNAP participants were foreign-born. Of the latter figure, 6.2 percent were naturalised citizens, 1.1 percent were refugees and 3.3 percent were other noncitizens, including lawful permanent residents and other eligible noncitizens.



I am sure the usual groups are up there, I mean everyone here knows certain groups are more perished (Edit: LMAO, meant impoverished, had my mind on food), fact is though the wealth gap has also increased 10 fold, and the middle and lower class are more dependent than ever. The good days are long, long gone and I only foresee more bad days coming until we somehow achieve some UBI but even that will be impacted by the wealth gap, have to keep the poors poor afterall.


That definitely adds perspective, but the percent I was talking about was percent of the segment (percent recipient from total count of ethnic group). If I follow your post is percent of total recipient. Two different perspectives. Actually can't get the gov site to load now*... Go figure

Example

About 4.5% of whites of total pop on SNAP. Which represents 37% of snap recipients.

This post was edited by RedFromWinter on Oct 30 2025 08:58am
Member
Posts: 22,432
Joined: Mar 3 2007
Gold: 106.11
Oct 30 2025 10:27am


It's abhorrent when leadership of any kind takes such a stance, I agree.

This post was edited by Handcuffs on Oct 30 2025 10:44am
Member
Posts: 22,432
Joined: Mar 3 2007
Gold: 106.11
Oct 30 2025 10:35am
No one is asking the real questions: why do so many people in a first world nation need food stamps? Is there a problem with employment or the wages paid? Addressing those issues should be the priority long term.


Economic factors aside, I do believe a significant reason for why so many Americans find themselves on SNAP is due to the discontinuation of home economics in schools and the increasing dependency on businesses to fill the needs that historically were met more within the home. Fewer and fewer people know how to grow their own food, cook, meal prep, or have nutritional literacy, which then cascades down generationally. Without that knowledge and skillset, people are much more vulnerable economically when it comes to food.

It's part of a larger puzzle though, imo, as it does seem to me that there's been a discontinuation or decreasing of civics, economics, and tradecraft in our education system and greater emphasis placed on college preparedness/job prospecting. Whether it's intentional or accidental I have no idea; however, it certainly benefits those at the top of a hierarchical power structure to have a populace that is less independent, educated, and self-sufficient/communal. It's a delicate house of cards though, because you want people disempowered yet content enough that they can be 'managed', but the moment things reach a tipping point then you're just a few steps away from an economic collapse, civil unrest, or revolution.

This post was edited by Handcuffs on Oct 30 2025 10:44am
Member
Posts: 8,306
Joined: Oct 16 2006
Gold: 57.00
Oct 30 2025 10:45am
I don’t understand the logic of democrats voting no. The people that get snap benefits are Democrats so why would they vote no on this?

I understand the potential of illegals voting being a big push for their healthcare but today’s Democrat voter base needs food stamps.

This post was edited by SP00K on Oct 30 2025 10:45am
Member
Posts: 92,890
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,299.94
Oct 30 2025 11:01am
I don’t understand the logic of democrats voting no. The people that get snap benefits are Democrats so why would they vote no on this?

I understand the potential of illegals voting being a big push for their healthcare but today’s Democrat voter base needs food stamps.


they want people to starve, riot, and get in the streets. then they want Trump to crack down, so they can play clips of the national guard at literal war with people in the streets.
Member
Posts: 9,097
Joined: May 11 2009
Gold: 5.01
Oct 30 2025 11:14am
Economic factors aside, I do believe a significant reason for why so many Americans find themselves on SNAP is due to the discontinuation of home economics in schools and the increasing dependency on businesses to fill the needs that historically were met more within the home. Fewer and fewer people know how to grow their own food, cook, meal prep, or have nutritional literacy, which then cascades down generationally. Without that knowledge and skillset, people are much more vulnerable economically when it comes to food.

It's part of a larger puzzle though, imo, as it does seem to me that there's been a discontinuation or decreasing of civics, economics, and tradecraft in our education system and greater emphasis placed on college preparedness/job prospecting. Whether it's intentional or accidental I have no idea; however, it certainly benefits those at the top of a hierarchical power structure to have a populace that is less independent, educated, and self-sufficient/communal. It's a delicate house of cards though, because you want people disempowered yet content enough that they can be 'managed', but the moment things reach a tipping point then you're just a few steps away from an economic collapse, civil unrest, or revolution.


I think it's intentional. Higher education is supposed to offer exit counseling to graduates specifically for financial preparation and strategies to tackle the loan debt. Almost no one actually gets this even though it's a requirement for these institutions that take FED loans. I think I got a generic email when I inquired in my higher ed era.
Member
Posts: 8,306
Joined: Oct 16 2006
Gold: 57.00
Oct 30 2025 11:15am
they want people to starve, riot, and get in the streets. then they want Trump to crack down, so they can play clips of the national guard at literal war with people in the streets.



There’s no better place to mourn than the electronic section at target
Member
Posts: 56,894
Joined: Nov 7 2009
Gold: 2,195.68
Oct 30 2025 12:14pm
No one is asking the real questions: why do so many people in a first world nation need food stamps? Is there a problem with employment or the wages paid? Addressing those issues should be the priority long term.


does half of this shit look like stuff people "need"
Member
Posts: 28,855
Joined: Aug 11 2013
Gold: 10,712.00
Oct 30 2025 12:24pm
does half of this shit look like stuff people "need"
https://i.gyazo.com/a1b2f6a06ac6a7cd1acb01cb6a283d51.png


It's only a matter of time before this is reformed and should be reformed and probably would have been already if it wasn't for the sugar lobby.

At some point IMO under the debt burden there's a collective realization that we can't be subsidizing wants and will probably restrict it to needs. I have no problem with old, sick, kids, the needy in general, getting vouchers for stuff that's actually nutritious but for trash that has drove the obesity epidemic, why they fuck is this still a thing? This should be one of the biggest targets for Robert Kennedy right now, and both the left and the right should both agree that it's the right course of action.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev167891022Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll