Quote (Slowtoanger @ 8 May 2022 18:17)
But is there really an "end" to de-incentivise abortion? Because at the end of the day, there is nothing that the de-incentivizing programs that can ever offer that will ever free itself from the notion of woman's bodily autonomy right? Because woman's bodily autonomy is greater than the POTENTIAL life. Like, the current life that woman has will and always be greater than the potential life that can be created into this world and this is your personal opinion. (Is that about right? Please correct me if I oversimplified it or isn't correct).
And I know it's semantics but you should say a woman's choice vs the mother's choice unless you are meaning that any woman that gets pregnant does get donned the motherhood status. (If that's what you're saying, that's fine too but that would be odd thing to say because what constitutes a woman to be a mother is the HAVE a child where as the woman who chooses abortion doesn't see the fetus as a child at all). But yeah, I don't know if I can ever get behind the notion that some woman MAY use abortions as a form of "birth control" but with that, I would guess that the percentage of these kinds of woman cannot be that high in nature.
But one thing that I want to ask though is, in your opinion, government should have less regulation on private affairs so isn't RvW getting overturned a "positive" step towards that direction? Going from the control of a federal government to State? Or is it the idea that if RvW gets overturned, the power that's given to each individual states will be too great and potentially restricting the woman's right bylarge?
you don't have to "get behind" the idea, you don't ever have to support it. again, i too am morally opposed to those kinds of abortions. the questions you should ask yourself are:
- firstly, and most importantly: is it my place, my right to decide that for other people? are my moral concerns so important to warrant a massive infringement on every woman's right, even though it will predictably not even prevent such abortions in the future, but merely punish poor and minority women disproportionally.
- secondly: even if you concluded it's up to you to make that decision, what is the bigger "evil"? missing out on punishing women who callously misuse abortions as birth control, or punishing all women including those in difficult, even desperate circumstances, by stripping away their right to bodily self-determination?
i don't think those are particularly difficult questions to answer, especially if you're aware that so much really basic (as in it's already long standing practice in many peer countries) stuff can be done to drastically decrease the need for "convenience" abortions, from education to mental and physical healthcare, to financial support for women and children...
let's not forget, and this ties into your final question about the impact of overturning roe v. wade, that while we can have exhaustive conversations about hypothetical scenarios and moral considerations, decisions like this will have a very tangible, real life effects: in large parts of red america, abortions are ALREADY de facto unavailable thanks to legal tricks and loopholes used to make it nearly impossible for abortion providers to operate in states - despite roe. with roe v. wade, which was decided based on the right to privacy, falling, not only will those abortion bans (many not even including exceptions for rape, incest, or ectopic pregnancies!) go unchallenged in all red states, but other decision based on the right to privacy are sure to follow. some of the issues this concerns: homosexuality, contraception, pornography, gay marriage, forced sterilisation, interracial marriage... a eugenics wet dream for conservative bigots...

some further reading on the real life impact:
https://twitter.com/jburnmurdoch/status/1522260023379902466Quote (Slowtoanger @ 8 May 2022 18:22)
Are you saying that there isn't a program currently or are you saying that the current programs are not enough?
I'd have to look into it but I was under the assumption that there are programs to help woman who are in such predicament.
This post was edited by fender on May 8 2022 11:08am