d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Anne Frank
Prev15678923Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 17,563
Joined: Mar 5 2016
Gold: 27.45
Warn: 40%
Dec 5 2022 11:42am
Quote (JessiWan @ Dec 5 2022 04:41pm)
By listening, I mean to give consideration to what they have to say. It doesn't mean I will automatically believe whatever they say.

I don't understand why this triggers so many people. Some people want to hear both sides, especially in regards to something that they have no direct personal knowledge of. Why is this approach even controversial? No offense but people like you sound like you are very invested in the holocaust being real and the earth being a sphere.


I am also invested into oranges being orange color
Member
Posts: 8,545
Joined: Oct 4 2021
Gold: 281.64
Dec 5 2022 11:46am
Quote (IceMage @ 3 Dec 2022 11:30)
Imagine my surprise when I learn the anti-masker/anti-vaxxer is a Holocaust denier.


Words hit harder than zyklon B
Member
Posts: 3,046
Joined: Oct 1 2021
Gold: 1,979.01
Dec 5 2022 11:48am
Quote (thesnipa @ Dec 5 2022 09:26am)
The emergence of socialism, especially free market capitalist socialism, happened because leftists abandoned communism. the right is far more interested in demonizing communism, a fairly dead system of govt, than the left is in defending it.

sure if you toss out 100 fishing lines criticizing communism you'll get some no true scotsmen responses, but ask those people afterwards if they support communism and you'll find they're nitpicking specifics, not advocating communism.

its like arguing about how VCRs use to eat up the occasional tape when rewinding.


I don't disagree materially with this, however it misses the spirit of the argument, that regardless of what you name it, current Leftist trajectory is every bit as careening toward humanitarian disaster as it ever was. Moderates and conservatives have a healthy skepticism of so called "democratic socialism" as a gateway drug to what eventually becomes ovens designed for people who wear glasses.
Member
Posts: 8,545
Joined: Oct 4 2021
Gold: 281.64
Dec 5 2022 11:48am
Quote (sirthom @ 3 Dec 2022 21:55)
It doesn't mater if they are not your enemy.
You are theirs and they plot against you and your family.
What are you going to do about it?


Is this how they got you? preyed on your fear?
Member
Posts: 92,959
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,299.94
Dec 5 2022 12:00pm
Quote (Thebarba @ Dec 5 2022 11:48am)
I don't disagree materially with this, however it misses the spirit of the argument, that regardless of what you name it, current Leftist trajectory is every bit as careening toward humanitarian disaster as it ever was. Moderates and conservatives have a healthy skepticism of so called "democratic socialism" as a gateway drug to what eventually becomes ovens designed for people who wear glasses.


the end result is the same no matter what system of govt prevails. 100-200 years from now Labor dies, entirely. it's just done, gone. no one will have a "job" as we currently understand it.

at which time either corporations or the people own the fruits of that labor. democratic socialism, for all of it's many failures, seeks to place the spoils in the hands of the population. ironically due to a desire to empower workers, who themselves are doomed. but they're the only real system that can prevent our great grand children from living in a 1 bedroom apartment on govt subsidy stipends. not that they even understand why.

automation and corporate profit are the two most important policies of our time, and they're hardly a footnote in most political debates. we'd rather waste valuable time talking about abortion (which the govt will likely pay you to get 100 years from now) and trans bathrooms (which no one will care about regardless of what we do now). we're just a pack of greyhounds chasing the bogus rabbit while others make bets on us.
Member
Posts: 30,165
Joined: Sep 10 2004
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 30%
Dec 5 2022 01:10pm
Quote (JessiWan @ 5 Dec 2022 16:21)
I never said I doubted an event just because I didn't see it with my own eyes. I said, the fact that I didn't see it with my own eyes means I should always allow for the possibility that it's not what it's portrayed to be and as a result, I should listen to people who doubt it.


regardless of the reason for their doubt though? i'd argue that there is a big difference between "doubting" something due to a lack of evidence and "doubting" something with the intention of downplaying / denying an event for political reasons.

let's say someone hated white people and claimed "white people never invented anything". a ridiculous claim ofc - but you, in your chosen role of open-minded listener without any historical knowledge of their own, except for what you have witnessed with your own eyes, "should listen" to them and entertain their brain farts? that seems like a ridiculous "standard" - and quite frankly, i don't believe you actually apply that to anything else, except of course the holocaust. and it's not particularly difficult to guess why...
Member
Posts: 22,264
Joined: Aug 17 2021
Gold: 1,546.83
Warn: 30%
Dec 5 2022 01:40pm
Quote (fender @ Dec 5 2022 11:10am)
regardless of the reason for their doubt though? i'd argue that there is a big difference between "doubting" something due to a lack of evidence and "doubting" something with the intention of downplaying / denying an event for political reasons.

let's say someone hated white people and claimed "white people never invented anything". a ridiculous claim ofc - but you, in your chosen role of open-minded listener without any historical knowledge of their own, except for what you have witnessed with your own eyes, "should listen" to them and entertain their brain farts? that seems like a ridiculous "standard" - and quite frankly, i don't believe you actually apply that to anything else, except of course the holocaust. and it's not particularly difficult to guess why...


Dude, you literally have no way of knowing what motivates people to doubt certain things. Stop being unreasonable.

Besides, it shouldn't matter, either. Whether or not holocaust is real is independent of whether the denier hates Jews.

This post was edited by JessiWan on Dec 5 2022 02:07pm
Member
Posts: 30,165
Joined: Sep 10 2004
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 30%
Dec 5 2022 02:06pm
Quote (JessiWan @ 5 Dec 2022 20:40)
Dude, you literally have no way of knowing the reason why people doubt certain things. Stop being unreasonable.

Besides, it shouldn't matter, either. Whether or not holocaust is real is independent of whether the denier hates Jews.


don't be silly, the argument obviously goes the other way around: the more the person hates jews, the more likely they are to deny the holocaust. i've yet to encounter a holocaust denier who isn't an anti-semite.

it's pretty rich of you to tell me to stop being unreasonable, while insisting to listen to unreasonable people, denying undeniable historical facts.

that's not "reasonable", "fair", "open-minded" or any other spin you like to put on it. it's bad revisionist history in order to downplay an unspeakable atrocity. no one is buying the "concerned sceptic" the "unbiased observer" act. holocaust deniers and their defenders are hate-mongers, plain and simple.
Member
Posts: 22,264
Joined: Aug 17 2021
Gold: 1,546.83
Warn: 30%
Dec 5 2022 02:08pm
Quote (fender @ Dec 5 2022 12:06pm)
don't be silly, the argument obviously goes the other way around: the more the person hates jews, the more likely they are to deny the holocaust. i've yet to encounter a holocaust denier who isn't an anti-semite.

it's pretty rich of you to tell me to stop being unreasonable, while insisting to listen to unreasonable people, denying undeniable historical facts.

Ok, prove that these facts are undeniable.

Quote
that's not "reasonable", "fair", "open-minded" or any other spin you like to put on it. it's bad revisionist history in order to downplay an unspeakable atrocity.


It's an unspeakable atrocity only if it happened. But it didn't.

This post was edited by JessiWan on Dec 5 2022 02:16pm
Member
Posts: 30,165
Joined: Sep 10 2004
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 30%
Dec 5 2022 02:17pm
Quote (JessiWan @ 5 Dec 2022 21:08)
Ok, prove that holocaust-deniers are unreasonable.

It's an unspeakable atrocity only if it happened. But it didn't.


there's my proof. when someone claims, against an overwhelming body of evidence (including countless eye witnesses, victims, their families, perpetrators, contemporaries, document, photos...), that something didn't happen, they are unreasonable, to say the least.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev15678923Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll