Quote (thesnipa @ 1 Aug 2022 16:36)
by far the most intellectually dishonest part of the anti-trans side is the strawman that being trans and having gender dysmorphia isn't mental illness. the issue comes when you use the illness as a stigma.
it's just funny because the left is directly calling for people to go to therapist, take medication, etc. and the right says "lol u deny that its mental illness". like lol what?
Being trans isn't a mental illness. It's generally regarded (correctly in my view) as a disorder of sexual development. One that can come with comorbid mental illness. Just like basically any disorder. But being trans, in and of itself, is not a mental illness.
Dysphoria could be classified as mental illness but I personally think it is perfectly normal distress caused by the disorder. Do you have a mental illness if you're disgusted if you suddenly grow breasts? Nah. It can lead to mental illness (depression, anxiety etc) but I wouldn't describe the disgust you feel at the body you no longer like as being a mental illness.
So it's not a strawman. Both the pro-trans left and most medical institutions regard transness in this fashion.
Frankly the right could use a slightly better understanding of mental illness given how much untreated mental illness we see among their number. Especially the more online, dissident right types.