Quote (IceMage @ Nov 6 2021 01:38am)
If we want to call Kilimnik a Russian intelligence operative, we're going to need to iron out when exactly he became a Russian intelligence operative. Are we saying that he was considered an intelligence operative at the same time that the United States was paying his salary at the IRI? That sounds absurd. He left the IRI to work for Manafort's Ukrainian consulting business, lobbying on behalf of various Ukrainian oligarchs. At what point did he stop being Kilimnik, political consultant and become Kilimnik, intelligence operative?
These labels are important. Relationships in Russia are intensely personal, anyone tangentially related to government work is going to rub shoulders with oligarchs who are in some way connected to Putin, because all Russian business is in some way connected to Putin. Steele's dossier is living proof of that, being a product of Russian disinfo itself. That does make Kilimnik a security threat, he is clearly not a trustworthy recipient of information. It doesn't make him a Russian spy, and it's certainly not evidence of a conspiracy between Manafort and the Russian government.
Manafort's motives appear relatively clear, he was interested in promoting his work to potential clients, some of whom he believed owed him money. He's a professional political grifter in that arena, his clients stopped asking for his services, he wanted to fill the pipeline for future work after Trump. It makes sense. What doesn't make sense is Manafort using Kilimnik to sneak Putin a few pages of polling data, the vast majority of which was public. Russian intelligence has better connections, and we know that because Obama was being briefed on the fact that Russian intelligence was allegedly aware that Clinton was trying to tie Trump to Russia.
Quote (NetflixAdaptationWidow @ Nov 6 2021 02:27am)
Didn't answer the question.
We have Trump's campaign directly colluding with Russia. Only thing we don't have is Trump on a call saying "Yes, I will give you X for Y". But you'd have to be pretty dumb, or think pretty lowly of Trump, to think he had no idea this was going on.
Mueller specifically investigated whether there was a conspiracy between the Trump campaign and the Russian government. The answer is no. Turn of Maddow and join us in the real world.
Quote (Sioux @ Nov 6 2021 12:35am)
So what's the simplest explanation for Trump's associates deleting their conversations and stalling mullers investigation then? Shits and giggles?
Edit: this is fun it's like I'm 20 again. Wassup bogie
Yo.
Manafort committed crimes for which he was successfully prosecuted. Why wouldn't he be deleting conversations and obstructing the investigation? That sounds like eminently reasonable behavior.
This post was edited by bogie160 on Nov 6 2021 12:41am