d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate >
Poll > Freedom Or Security? Choose One
Prev15678921Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
  Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.
Member
Posts: 64,763
Joined: Oct 25 2006
Gold: 0.00
Oct 1 2021 11:22am
Quote (thesnipa @ Oct 1 2021 12:07pm)
you're correct, its a moot comparison owing to the massive gap in technology. but if we control for inflation and for technology Rome is far more impressive.

we'd have to look at similar things for a valid comparison, the roman road system is far more impressive in both construction and upkeep than even the post-WW2 interstate highways of the US. They had better plumbing and waterway management than the modern US, etc. Again all controlling for inflation of technology.

i can 3d print a keychain today, 200 years ago a blacksmith may take a full day to make something similar. he's still far more impressive.


Rome and the U.S. have surprisingly similar histories. They were both basically backwaters until they started actively interferring with their neighbors to gain an economic advantage. In the case of Rome it was taking taxes, and the U.S. it was securing oil markets, but the point stands.

Similarly, Rome's fall came largely because of the transition from the masses owning land to becoming effectively serfs to the economically connected. Similar to what we are seeing now under neoliberalism.

Roman roads were impressive for the time, but so was the modern highway system. The reason Rome's roads lasted so long is because they didn't have semis driving down them.

I think the best measure might be Rome as a percentage of global GDP, versus the same measure for the U.S. There's no way to "adjust for inflation and technology" because modern economics didn't exist but for the past few hundred years, and the same for the massive boom in technology the past 100 years.
Member
Posts: 92,984
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,299.94
Oct 1 2021 11:23am
Quote (SkillRincer @ Oct 1 2021 12:17pm)
all i'm talking about in OP is which YOU would choose; freedom or security

you're the one trying to veer off into all these sub topics and debates that really have no relation to my OP

if you were to list reasons why security is valued to you greater than freedom that would be more on topic or vice versa


it does look like more people would choose freedom over security on here, which is good to see i will admit :P


being vaccinated by my choice (freedom) gives me the ability to travel places i otherwise couldnt (freedom) including visiting elderly relatives (freedom) and eating at restaurants anywhere (freedom).

choosing not to be vaccinated (freedom) removes a large number of things you can legally do.

until someone rolls up to your house and forces you to take a shot in your arm you freedom hasn't been infringed upon, you have the freedom to get a vaccination or not. exercising that freedom in one way or another changes what OTHER freedoms you may be able to exercise.

that's how freedom works, it isn't a simple choice, ever. it's a door to a hallway of many more doors. the false binary of freedom and security is rarely that simple. perhaps on a topic like the Patriot Act it's fairly straight forward, because all americans were (unconstitutionally) opted into a system of illegal surveillance. Nothing about the modern vaccine mandates in the US has been unconstitutional or even on a state level illegal.
Member
Posts: 26,862
Joined: Feb 27 2013
Gold: 4,445.68
Oct 1 2021 11:26am
Quote (SkillRincer @ Oct 1 2021 10:07am)
im just talkin bout gdp lmao relax with it ok?

United States (GDP: 20.49 trillion) vastly superior to any other country in 2020



Why didn’t you just say richest then lmao
And why did it take like 8 posts for you to finally admit you were talking solely about gdp? Kinda sus my dude

This post was edited by MrSK on Oct 1 2021 11:27am
Member
Posts: 72,480
Joined: Jan 21 2008
Gold: 284,241.70
Oct 1 2021 11:38am
Quote (MrSK @ Oct 1 2021 11:26am)
Why didn’t you just say richest then lmao
And why did it take like 8 posts for you to finally admit you were talking solely about gdp? Kinda sus my dude


bruh you clearly are lacking comprehension

"USA has highest GDP in 2020, ranks #1 in power rankings, then just overall influence the united states has had on the entire world for decades is to be noted as well."

was what i said in a previous post
Member
Posts: 26,862
Joined: Feb 27 2013
Gold: 4,445.68
Oct 1 2021 11:49am
Quote (SkillRincer @ Oct 1 2021 10:38am)
bruh you clearly are lacking comprehension

"USA has highest GDP in 2020, ranks #1 in power rankings, then just overall influence the united states has had on the entire world for decades is to be noted as well."

was what i said in a previous post



Oh I see it now lmao
Also you think power rankings and influence on the world = most correct interpretation of freedom? How does having a strong military and exploitable capitalist market have anything to correlate with that. If America went broke tomorrow you’d say China or Russia’s interpretation would be “correct”? You’re actually cracked if you think so
Member
Posts: 11,344
Joined: Jul 2 2019
Gold: 2,170.00
Oct 1 2021 11:51am
freedom at any cost.
Member
Posts: 2,614
Joined: Sep 17 2021
Gold: 0.00
Oct 1 2021 11:52am
Quote (MrSK @ Oct 1 2021 12:49pm)
Oh I see it now lmao
Also you think power rankings and influence on the world = most correct interpretation of freedom? How does having a strong military and exploitable capitalist market have anything to correlate with that. If America went broke tomorrow you’d say China or Russia’s interpretation would be “correct”? You’re actually cracked if you think so


nah he would blame it on the democrats or something and say america is the perfect system while sitting atop his nice little priviledge while hard working innocent people continue to suffer while working 80 hours a week still being unable to survive
Member
Posts: 72,480
Joined: Jan 21 2008
Gold: 284,241.70
Oct 1 2021 12:28pm
Quote (SanduLungu @ Oct 1 2021 11:51am)
freedom at any cost.


this is more where i align, much rather make my own choices and live with the consequences good or bad than live under the boot of authoritarianism
Member
Posts: 64,763
Joined: Oct 25 2006
Gold: 0.00
Oct 1 2021 02:09pm
Quote (SkillRincer @ Oct 1 2021 01:28pm)
this is more where i align, much rather make my own choices and live with the consequences good or bad than live under the boot of authoritarianism


Quote (SanduLungu @ Oct 1 2021 12:51pm)
freedom at any cost.


Cool, so I should be free to shoot you and burn down your house?
Member
Posts: 26,862
Joined: Feb 27 2013
Gold: 4,445.68
Oct 1 2021 02:13pm
Quote (NetflixAdaptationWidow @ Oct 1 2021 01:09pm)
Cool, so I should be free to shoot you and burn down your house?


How dare you imply Anarchy is better than Authoritarianism
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev15678921Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll