Quote (thesnipa @ Mar 26 2021 01:00pm)
in what sense? that god can't be loving and send people to hell?
that's a solid argument, but as a counter does the parent of a drug abusing child who shuns them and bans them from their household not love their child? im not sure how that comparison works out in infinity, but im also not stuck on the idea that hell is without redemption. or that afterlife is a binary, purgatory has always appealed to me.
You've spent the last few posts arguing under the assumption that bad things contradict a good God unless there's an infinite amount of good consequence to bring the balance in favor of good. I still don't agree with this, since if it cancels depends how you set up the equation.
An all good God is not compatible with an infinite punishment. The analogy to the parent fails because the parent isn't perfect.