d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Abortion 2021
Prev15678918Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 48
Joined: Sep 19 2020
Gold: 0.00
Jan 30 2021 09:28pm
I think it's interesting that the people who are the most anti abortion also champion the idea that no gun signs stop gun crime.

I don't like abortion. However nothing anyone can ever do will ever stop people from having an abortion, or smothering their newborn babies if that is what they want to do. It's been happening for thousands of years.

In light of that, I think the only logical way is to provide access, education, and make contraception available. That way the number of people needing abortions goes down, but a woman who decides that is what she wants to do can keep herself safe.

I just don't see any reason to make the situation worse for those who go down that route, when abolishing the practice is entirely impossible.
Member
Posts: 24,802
Joined: Mar 7 2010
Gold: 22,202.22
Jan 30 2021 09:30pm
Quote (Thor123422 @ Jan 29 2021 04:09pm)
This kind of argument is not convincing to me. If you want me to stop from doing something with my body you need a compelling reason. "It's the consequences" is not a compelling reason to stop the consequences from happening. If I put bacon on my face nobody then argues I can't get a face treatment for the acne. What is the reason I can't work to avert consequences from previous action in this case?


a human fetus is not acne.... :bonk:


Quote (Thor123422 @ Jan 29 2021 04:58pm)
None of what I've said requires ownership over the fetus, or the fetus to be part of the mother.

If I want to expel something from my body, I have the right to do that absent a compelling reason to prevent me from doing it.

You might say the compelling reason is that I would kill the fetus, and the fetus is a person, but that only holds water with me after 23 weeks, and is dependent on the fetus having a right to your body that supersedes your own right to bodily autonomy afterwar 23 weeks.


you choose to give up that right when you choose to have sex.
Member
Posts: 24,802
Joined: Mar 7 2010
Gold: 22,202.22
Jan 30 2021 09:33pm
Quote (Black XistenZ @ Jan 30 2021 10:52am)
Clearly pro choice.


I think this notion is far too common and unjustified... this notion that a significant share of the women getting abortions are irresponsible, guiltfree sluts who use it as some sort of day-after contraception. In my (admittedly limited) experience, getting an abortion is almost never easy for a woman, and insinuating otherwise is a dirty trick by the pro life side to sway the debate in their favor.

For every callous woman who isnt emotionally affected by an abortion, there are at least 5 woman who were emphatically pro choice, but then struggle far more with the decision and procedure than they anticipated.


thats exactly part of the problem. women get abortions thinking 'oh, but its just a clump of cells'. but then they realize that its NOT just a clump of cells, its a human life that they just ended, and have to live with that fact for the rest of their lives.
Member
Posts: 64,763
Joined: Oct 25 2006
Gold: 0.00
Jan 30 2021 09:35pm
Quote (ReturnFormer @ Jan 30 2021 09:30pm)
a human fetus is not acne.... :bonk:

you choose to give up that right when you choose to have sex.


No you don't lol. Your body is still yours. That's like saying you give up the right to your digestive system when you order a pizza.
Member
Posts: 24,802
Joined: Mar 7 2010
Gold: 22,202.22
Jan 30 2021 09:43pm
Quote (Thor123422 @ Jan 30 2021 10:35pm)
No you don't lol. Your body is still yours. That's like saying you give up the right to your digestive system when you order a pizza.


you have that view because you dont value human life, so you see it as no different than acne or pizza in your stomach. an infection to be cured. i disagree. human life has intrinsic value and if you choose to engage in something that might create a human life you give up your right to end that human life one it is created. life, especially human life, should not be ended without a compelling reason.
Member
Posts: 64,763
Joined: Oct 25 2006
Gold: 0.00
Jan 30 2021 09:47pm
Quote (ReturnFormer @ Jan 30 2021 09:43pm)
you have that view because you dont value human life, so you see it as no different than acne or pizza in your stomach. an infection to be cured. i disagree. human life has intrinsic value and if you choose to engage in something that might create a human life you give up your right to end that human life one it is created. life, especially human life, should not be ended without a compelling reason.


So then you think anybody who needs lifesaving medicine should get it?

Like it should be illegal to charge $1000 for insulin?
Member
Posts: 24,802
Joined: Mar 7 2010
Gold: 22,202.22
Jan 30 2021 10:04pm
Quote (Thor123422 @ Jan 30 2021 10:47pm)
So then you think anybody who needs lifesaving medicine should get it?

Like it should be illegal to charge $1000 for insulin?


ideally, yes, anyone who needs medicine should get it, but im also realistic enough to recognize that if its not profitable to make medicines, it wont be done. but thats a whole other discussion.

relevant here, your comparison is a fallacy. actively ending a life is different than allowing one to end by not giving it what it needs to survive.
Member
Posts: 54,177
Joined: May 26 2005
Gold: 4,945.67
Jan 30 2021 10:17pm
Quote (ReturnFormer @ 31 Jan 2021 05:04)
ideally, yes, anyone who needs medicine should get it, but im also realistic enough to recognize that if its not profitable to make medicines, it wont be done. but thats a whole other discussion.

relevant here, your comparison is a fallacy. actively ending a life is different than allowing one to end by not giving it what it needs to survive.


You are trapped in an unrealistic black-and-white thinking. In the beginning, an embryo is indeed nothing but a clump of cells. Then, as the pregnancy moves on, the embryo develops into a fetus and gradually develops more and more characteristics of human life, like brain activity or a heartbeat. The development of human life is taking place on a continuous scale, it is absurd to pretend as if fully fledged human life with all its dignity and (moral and legal) rights starts the second the sperm enters the egg cell. Did you know that 30-40% of all pregnancies end in a miscarriage before the 12 week mark out of natural reasons; often times without the woman even having noticed that she was pregnant?

This post was edited by Black XistenZ on Jan 30 2021 10:18pm
Member
Posts: 24,802
Joined: Mar 7 2010
Gold: 22,202.22
Jan 30 2021 10:32pm
Quote (Black XistenZ @ Jan 30 2021 11:17pm)
You are trapped in an unrealistic black-and-white thinking. In the beginning, an embryo is indeed nothing but a clump of cells. Then, as the pregnancy moves on, the embryo develops into a fetus and gradually develops more and more characteristics of human life, like brain activity or a heartbeat. The development of human life is taking place on a continuous scale, it is absurd to pretend as if fully fledged human life with all its dignity and (moral and legal) rights starts the second the sperm enters the egg cell. Did you know that 30-40% of all pregnancies end in a miscarriage before the 12 week mark out of natural reasons; often times without the woman even having noticed that she was pregnant?


it develops over time, yes, but its still human life.
Member
Posts: 3,381
Joined: Nov 24 2012
Gold: 1,300.00
Jan 30 2021 10:49pm
My fiancee miscarried our first. I would have done anything, payed any amount to save my child. It makes me sick that people abort simply because their choice to have sex has inconvenienced them. Listen to some of the change my mind segments on abortion from steven crowder. It made me think.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev15678918Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll